r/NonDessKnightSquad • • Jul 21 '26

Announcement / Mod Post Cracking Down on Over-saturation of Tierlists

69 Upvotes

The mod team has heard the complaints about too many low effort posts being made, with them all being in a similar style, that being a tierlist or a chart of some sort (images below of what we mean). To keep the quality of posts in this subreddit better, we're taking a stance on this.

There will be no tierlist/chart posts allowed, unless it's a Tuesday, then you will be allowed to post them on that day. To prevent any confusion, we will be using the EST timezone. Remember to use the new flair we've made "Tierlist Tuesday", when posting.

Additionally, we have seen many of these posts being made with DessKnight at the top, which has bothered us. This subreddit was made to allow for space for non-dessknight candidates to be posted, without being downvoted to hell, meaning we will not allow DessKnight posts like that. So, even on tuesdays, if you're a DessKnighter (either by flair of having DessKnight at the top of the tierlist), your post will still be removed.


r/NonDessKnightSquad • • Jan 18 '26

Announcement / Mod Post "How would you feel if DessKnight got confirmed" posts are no longer allowed

99 Upvotes

The mod team recently has seen the same question posted here many times. Also responded to many times. So, we have decided to take action on it. To prevent it being posted again and again.

If you wanted to see how people would react, please find and check out one of those old posts. But don't make your own.

No punishments will happen for those who do it. But they will not be left up. Consider this a ban for those types of posts.


r/NonDessKnightSquad • • 7h ago

Meme Knight candidate slander

Post image
593 Upvotes

I just think it's funny that for almost every candidate (with the exception of Noelle because she already has tons of stuff going on with her), there's the argument of "if _ isn't that Knight then what would be their role in the story", like by that logic half the cast is pointless lmao.


r/NonDessKnightSquad • • 1h ago

Meme This video is genuinely frying me

38 Upvotes

original by mwah6708 I think.

I don't even know why I find it so funny, it's just random BS but I can't stop laughing at it. Like I didn't even know green guy was called 'Sad Dragon' before watching this 😭


r/NonDessKnightSquad • • 9h ago

Found Art Holidays are always full of surprises

142 Upvotes

r/NonDessKnightSquad • • 59m ago

Meme genuinely tho, wtf is the plan for when it gets revealed lmao

25 Upvotes

r/NonDessKnightSquad • • 39m ago

Discussion CAROL KNIGHTERS! Yall gotta drop an edit dawg

Post image
18 Upvotes

4% Is insane


r/NonDessKnightSquad • • 5h ago

Discussion What is it about Rudy Knight specifically that gets some twitter users so riled up?

27 Upvotes

I've seen an excellent Rudy Knight edit that I'm going to link right here. So far so good... except that it reignited the umpteenth discourse in which people say things such as "this is what happens when people take a joke too far, they start to actually believe it" and "it's easy to convince people when you take random images and put music over it" and I'm like... no?

Maybe it's convincing because the evidence is actually really solid? Idk I know it's twitter and all, but I never personally saw reactions like these for other theories except THEY slash THEM/Kris slash.

And don't get me started on "it's all hype moments and aura"... I hate that phrase so much, it poisons any kind of internet discussion by framing anything cool as unintellectual! And the worst part is that doesn't even apply in this case, where people have been analysing the whole game to gather evidence and connect threads to make their theory. And even if one were to dislike the theory so much, why not just scroll and move on?


r/NonDessKnightSquad • • 4h ago

Discussion what's this for you?

Post image
25 Upvotes

(you don't have to go in-depth, but if you wanna rant about your theory then I support that.)


r/NonDessKnightSquad • • 5m ago

Agenda Posting I wanted to join in on the edit trend too-

5 Upvotes

except I have no editing skills-


r/NonDessKnightSquad • • 8h ago

Discussion What do you think of Papyrus Knight?

Post image
21 Upvotes

r/NonDessKnightSquad • • 9h ago

Agenda Posting If this is a Zelda reference...

Thumbnail
gallery
20 Upvotes

This monster mimics Kris's movements just like Shadow Link in Zelda, and the envirement is obviously based of Zelda game. The location of this room also aligns with location of the lake on Hometown map, and in most iconic Zelda games you fight Shadow Link on water. The Knight mimics 12 poses from Kris too. So the Knight is Kris confirmed.

Also, you make a goner in location known as Depths, which looks exactly like Kris, and is potentially also stolen by Kris with the Soul to do stuff. The monster sprite is the same as Asgore’s sprite in this minigame, which makes sense if both of them are Dreemurrs, and we take control over the monster after completing the puzzle like another Vessel. The monster's HP is 999, the max amount of letters in goner's name is 9, unlike 12 in Player's name.

The only problem is the unseen deer sprite running beneath, but it can possibly represent goner Kris having Dess’s Soul (another part of her is in the code), or her corpse puppetered by Kris's Soul as alternative. But since Kris and the Knight have the same "lightning of mind", which is how Organiks call dark world colors in chapter 4, Goner would need to have Kris's mind even with out slight modifications, and I don't think Dess has influence over it.

Also, it would make sense why this is the only monster Kris kills without Player's output, because its not just a Holiday, but a horrible version of themselves.


r/NonDessKnightSquad • • 5h ago

Agenda Posting shadow carol

7 Upvotes

r/NonDessKnightSquad • • 1h ago

Discussion Ask me anything about PapyrusKnight and I’ll do my best to answer Pt. 33

Post image
2 Upvotes

Sorry it’s been a while since the last one!


r/NonDessKnightSquad • • 21m ago

Discussion Who's your backup pick?

1 Upvotes

Or if not these comment which i cant fit them all


r/NonDessKnightSquad • • 20h ago

Discussion I’m a Carol knighter, but recently I’ve been thinking…

Post image
37 Upvotes

So I’m a big Carol knighter but I’ve seen so many Rudy knight videos and connections, it seems a little more accurate.. RUDY KNIGHTERS! Please give me your arguments!


r/NonDessKnightSquad • • 4h ago

Agenda Posting The Weird Route makes Carol Knight a million times more interesting (and plausible)

3 Upvotes

Gonna be completely honest, I made this account purely because I've been getting too goddamn ragebaited by posts throughout the various Deltarune subs while lurking

I've seen so many snap judgements about Carol Knight and I'm not willing to buy into any of them. "It's too obvious" and "it isn't narratively satisfying" and "it doesn't fit her character" are all being built around assumptions over what the story HAS to be, as well as what Carol apparently HAS to be. And after chapter 5 people aren't even willing to count Carol as part of the conspiracy. There are even arguments that she knows less than Asgore did in Chapter 5, and the Weird Route is at the center of more than a few of those theories.

But yall motherfuckers just don't see the VISION

Why it can fit

Right now, the biggest assumptions about Carol's character (even with Carol Knighters) are that she's trying to preserve the past. But other than Dess's room, we don't see any evidence of her doing that today. There's Noelle's bronzed snowflakes, sure, but those were bronzed back when she was a kid, probably when Dess was still around.

And how much Carol cares for Noelle is in question, too. The most "recent" moment of her showing motherly kindness to her is canceling school while it's raining (https://deltarune.com/rain/), but there's no stated time frame for when this is going on. Noelle and Catti are still close in it, so it must be some time before Susie showed up. And the hints at FRIEND's appearance there make me think that it's closer to the time frame of Dess vanishing. (We don't know if FRIEND had anything to do with the dessappearance, sure, but the whole "children followed the pointed tail" thing makes it pretty damn likely.)

What we know about Noelle's current relationship with her mom is that she's is terrified of her. She tries doesn't even bother to call her when getting locked out of her house. It's a sign that Carol's treatment of Noelle isn't exactly kind or healthy. Hell, a recent mainsub post even highlights this fact...and yet the commenters pretty quickly shut down any idea that she could still be connected to the weird route.

But the weird route also gives us some pretty big fucking hints to her involvement.

Carol calls Noelle ahead of time in the weird route specifically to tell her that she's going to be late. This is done in place of Berdly's call (obviously he can't because he's been Snowgraved) but there's no reason this new call needed to exist. It's there just to explicitly tell the player that Carol is supposed to be late coming home. It doesn't show up at all in the normal route, and it's not like anything in the weird route up to this point directly impacted Carol enough to make her reach out to Noelle...right?

And there's only one thing that hints as to why she's home early at all:

There are plenty of arguments over whether Carol is actually the caller in the kitchen or the closet, but one thing is certain. In the weird route, Kris only gets a moment alone to themselves between equipping the ThornRing on Noelle and kicking the shit out of us in the bathroom. Carol arrives home almost immediately after that, and their phone is wiped of everything. And unless this is just a big fat lie or an actual oversight on Toby Fox's part, it's heavily implied that Kris called Carol during that time and told her that something happened to Noelle.

Carol knows something happened to Noelle at this point.

And yet, after this all happens and you have the conversation outside of the house, if you go to check the door...

Something important to note here is that this line is the exact same in both routes. Whether Carol is "scolding" Noelle in the normal route or checking in on her in the weird route, she still seems more focused on Kris and Susie than she does on her own daughter.

Almost like, by the end of both routes, the exact same thing is happening to Noelle.

Yeah that's right bitch we're getting weird with it

How it can work

People theorized that Carol went through her own "weird route" back during the chapter 4 era, but that idea has pretty much died out at this point. Hell, I'm not sure many people even believe she can use Snowgrave anymore. But if she IS the knight, then it's almost certain that she knows about the weird route. And there's no way she wouldn't have attempted to check for the ThornRing on Noelle's finger...unless she was already fine with it.

Or, if she was planning on doing it herself.

If you abort the weird route right after getting the ThornRing, Spamton drops this line. Most people would probably just assume it's a throwaway line, but it still leaves us with the implication that there's more than one. Heck, for an item that's supposedly only obtainable from the weird route, it's still featured prominently in the fusion shop as a material for the Twisted Sword. It's almost like we're still meant to encounter it sometime later in the normal route.

And, in fact, there's a perfect place for it.

Why does this unused sprite exist? This sprite, an edit of her grinning face, which is only used when she hits us with the "YOU are welcome here" line after bringing Noelle into the kitchen?

Hell, why would saying hello to Kris take precedence over scolding Noelle? And why would she pay so much attention to whether Kris and Susie have left if she's in the middle of that? Everything we know about Carol's current demeanor makes her seem like a very thorough person. The only way that works is if she has no reason to assume Noelle will act up while she's so distracted.

Not to mention, Noelle doesn't mention anything about the day before to Susie during the festival. Rudy says he wore Carol down on the matter, but the fact that Noelle doesn't acknowledge anything, even in a throwaway line, feels strange as hell. Not when they meet, not when her mom calls, nothing. It's like the scolding didn't even happen.

But what if that's exactly the point? Because why would she need to scold her daughter, when she can just push a thorn into her finger and maker her follow any command she gives, without question?

It's Theory Time, Bitches

Assuming Carol is the knight, the weird route must be part of her plan. Maybe it's a backup in case her normal route plans don't work out, but either way, she knows about it, and she's willing to accept it. And that's why we get this phone call at the end of chapter 4's weird route:

If Carol is the caller in every instance, there's a simple explanation as to why the dialogue box is so different. When it's distorted, she's calling near or inside a dark world. But in the weird route, she's calling from her house, probably just outside Noelle's bedroom after encouraging her to follow through with the route.

She's doing this not because she suddenly stopped loving Noelle or anything, but because she simply doesn't love her as much as Dess. Parents might not consciously play favorites, but she cares a lot more about preserving Dess's memory than paying any sort of positive attention to Noelle. Despite whatever love she might've felt for her family before "that day" happened, well, grief is a hell of a drug. And if a grieving mother was presented with the opportunity to save the daughter she loved most in exchange for the one she's lost most of her love for...there's no evidence that Carol wouldn't make that trade.

With how things are playing out in the normal route, this doesn't seem to be necessary so far. But if she's the knight, she still has to show up in the church before Kris and Susie seal the fountain. So when Susie gets the guitar, she rushes home, brings Noelle into the kitchen...and puts the ThornRing on her. Then, she tells Noelle to go to her room and wait for her there. Both Noelle and Carol leave the kitchen at the same time, and we only see Carol because Noelle is offscreen by that point.

From there, she watches Kris and Susie and tails them to the church. They jump into the dark world, she goes in after them, transforms into her bird-knight form, and flies above the duo while they're doing the short introductory puzzle. Then, Susie notes the fountain without noticing the knight:

Only for the knight to then fly down in front of the doorway, roar, and the game plays out as usual from there. Sometime during or after the chapter, she has her conversation with Rudy, returns to Noelle, and tells her to forget about what happened today, permitting her to go to the festival with Susie before taking her ThornRing from Noelle's finger.

But with Rudy's collapse in Chapter 5, maybe Chapter 6 plays out a bit differently. Maybe Carol ends up taking advantage of Noelle's despair. Maybe she gives her the ThornRing once again, and convinces her to make a new dark world where Rudy can stay without succumbing to his illness. Preserving the family for just a bit longer, not just for the family's sake...but for Dess's, too, whenever Carol manages to pull her out of the dark.

There are way more pieces to this theory that I'm not gonna dive too much into, but I'll give those bits a general mention here. Stuff like Dess currently being the angel, which explains why the dark worlds are still so connected to her without her being the one who opened the Cyber and Church fountains. Or Carol using Dess's bat as her main knight weapon in conjunction with the black katana hidden in her room, which is why Flowery getting cut in half has the slice coming from the opposite side of the knight's sword. Or the idea that Carol stopped Undyne before she reached the Dreemurr house, which is why both of them are so late to the TV dark world.

But I also want to take a moment to discuss other ideas regarding Carol here.

The Opinion Zone

The general consensus is that Carol is a red herring. For the most part, that just applies to her being the knight, but these days people are arguing that every ounce of her antagonistic nature is a red herring, too. She isn't working with the knight, she's not in any "truce" with Kris, and she doesn't even know more about the dark worlds than Asgore does.

Thing is, there's nothing in the game to disprove this. All of those ideas could be correct. But I honestly don't understand why people are fighting so hard for it, because it just...kinda seems like ass to me.

If all that is true, then she's going to get properly understood in Chapter 6. She's still probably gonna be filled with grief, but we'll fight her and get her to see the error of her ways...and then the knight will kidnap or kill her at the end. And we already went through this exact arc in chapter 5 with Asgore. The only difference here is that we (probably) would fight Carol in a boss fight directly. Sure, we'd still probably advance the overarching plot in exciting ways, and whatever the actual knight reveal is would be hype as hell. But Carol's presence doesn't add anything different or new to the narrative, and to me, it doesn't make her character any more interesting. It makes every bit of her foreshadowing in chapter 4 just a big fat fucking lie, all for the sake of "subverting expectations" and being rugpulled by Tricky Tony.

And on that note, I think people are focusing on the wrong thing to get "shock value" out of when it comes to knight theorizing. It's treated like the knight's secret identity is the defacto most important part of them. Heck, even when I see people saying that it isn't all that important...Dess Knighters are the ones saying that half the time, not Carol Knighters. And it's real goddamn frustrating because they do sort of have the right idea.

The knight's identity is meant to be a mystery, yes. Kris wouldn't be trying so hard to hide it from you otherwise. But the game honestly downplays it pretty hard compared to what the knight is actually doing. Especially when it's emphasized by kidnapping people, preparing to make a "sacrifice" on the kitchen call, ragebaiting Susie, laughing before summoning the Titan, and critically wounding Tenna and Flowery. And that also ends up being what Susie focuses on above everything else.

Sure, the initial reveal of Carol being the knight wouldn't be as shocking as someone like Dess or Rudy or Asriel or Papyrus. But many people are also operating under the assumption that this is a Toby Fox game, and that there isn't a single truly "evil" character beyond the forces of nature that are the Titans and Spawn (and MAYBE Eram). Thus there's the argument that if Carol is the knight, it wouldn't change her antagonistic role much at all. I'm pretty sure even most (if not all) Carolknighters believe that she'll end up being redeemed by the end of it all.

Sure, Carol as the knight might not be unsympathetic...but what if she isn't meant to be redeemed? What if she's willing to dive straight into the depths and pull the entire world down with her, just for the chance for her daughter to visit it one last time? Even if she's doing her best to keep the family together, what if she's willing to sacrifice what remains for the sake of what she once had? And what would Noelle do, when confronted with how badly she's been manipulated and how much her family has fallen apart all at once, just to be given one more faint glimmer of hope when she delves into the darkness and reaches out to Dess herself?

I'm not against other knight candidates, and I'm not here to argue over why any of them would be the "wrong" pick. But the shock value of their identity isn't the only thing to focus on here. The person behind the mask might be a mystery, but it's not the mystery. And besides, Deltarune isn't a whodunnit, at least in my eyes. It's an RPG. Even if she isn't the knight, throwing everything about Carol into the "red herring" pile is basically just doing what the Pokemon franchise did to Lusamine after Sun and Moon. (Which is especially ironic, because she's also an evil woman in power that has a connection to ice.)

I wanted to get these ideas out in the open sometime before chapter 6 dropped, less for the sake of proving myself right and more for the sake of sharing them before it's too late. And maybe to inspire people, if they like this idea enough to mix their own theories or fanart into it. No telling if this post will actually take off enough to get that far, especially with how much of a fat fucking wall of text it is, but at least it's here for people to see.


r/NonDessKnightSquad • • 1d ago Bravo

Agenda Posting I finally finished it! Jane! | A RudyKnight Edit is out now!

Thumbnail
youtube.com
132 Upvotes

RudyKnighters unite! I just wanted to say that I really appreciated all the support I was given on the posts leading up to this, without your help in finding evidence for me to use, this wouldn't have turned out as good as it did.

I chose this song due to it's meaning sharing a lot of similarities to Rudy's situation. Jane! Is about the very real serial killer Jane Toppan, on the surface she was was a kind nurse, however, she had a much darker side that came out in the hospital when no one was looking. Now, obviously I don't think Rudy is some sort of serial killer, but I strongly believe he has a darker to him side that he keeps hidden away in the hospital, which was enough for me to make this song my pick.

I mainly made this because of all of the recent hate I've seen towards the RudyKnight theory, it's perfectly fine if you don't believe it, but the claims of it having "no evidence" and only "hype moments and aura" have been really disappointing to hear. So I'm hoping by making this edit, even if only a little, it will improve the reputation of the theory.

I am no editor by any means, in fact this is my first time editing anything like this, so it might have some issues that I might fix at a later time, who knows. However, I will say I'm pretty proud of how it's turned out, and I'm very much looking forward to seeing what you guys have to say about it!


r/NonDessKnightSquad • • 1d ago

Discussion The Good Luck Charm is hollow on the inside

Thumbnail
gallery
49 Upvotes

We know that because of the basement where we see the same doll that Soul can hide under. Meaning that the one Rudy has is most likely ALSO hollow on the inside. And since then we NEVER got to be in hospital again to check it.

There is something under that Rudy's charm... Literally and figuratively.


r/NonDessKnightSquad • • 1d ago

Discussion How would you reveal your Knight candidate without actually unmasking them? (As in, what could the Knight do that only applies to YOUR candidate that would make the player realise 'holy shit it's them' right before the identity reveal, joke example for NoelleKnight in the picture)

Post image
186 Upvotes

r/NonDessKnightSquad • • 8h ago

Discussion Ask me about my Kris knight theory and I'll do my best to answer

2 Upvotes

I have a very... Interesting theory that is most different


r/NonDessKnightSquad • • 1d ago

Discussion What piece of evidence would it take, outside of an outright confirmation of the Knight's identity, to swap candidates?

8 Upvotes

Sorry if the title is weird. I had a hard time phrasing it.

So almost a month ago now, I made a joke post about how I would immediately abandon Rudy Knight (My preferred candidate) for Carol Knight (My number 2 option) if Nightmare Knight started playing in chapter 6. I am wholeheartedly serious that it would be the thing that makes me certain it is someone else. This has made me curious to see if anyone had any relatively minor pieces of evidence that if found would make them jump ship.

Sorry if its vague lol


r/NonDessKnightSquad • • 22h ago

Discussion Thoughts on A Rudy Knight Theory I've Been Thinking About

Thumbnail
reddit.com
2 Upvotes

r/NonDessKnightSquad • • 1d ago

Your Art (OC) Ta-dah.

Post image
9 Upvotes

r/NonDessKnightSquad • • 22h ago

Discussion question does noelle second knight count as a nondess knight for the purposes of this sub

1 Upvotes

noelle second knight is a modified version of kriselle knight with a motive which has traits of findher based on the spamton sweepstakes connecting all that to noelle far more than anyone else, for context, but it also still implies that the knight we see is dess