r/Northfield • u/Murky_Gur_5845 • 19h ago
City advances plans for dam removal
The city of Northfield is moving forward with removing and replacing the Ames Mill Dam. Widely recognized as a landmark of downtown Northfield, the city is pursuing replacement of the dam with rock arch rapids to address safety and environmental concerns tied to the aging infrastructure.
The existing concrete dam, located adjacent to Bridge Square, was built in 1918 to power the historic Ames Flour Mill. In 1927, John Campbell, founder of Malt-O-Meal, purchased the mill and dam, and ownership transferred to Post Consumer Brands in its 2015 acquisition of Malt-O-Meal.
Recommendations for the dam's removal have been noted as early as 1997, when Short Elliot Hendrickson Inc. (SEH) inspected the dam. SEH advised removing it due to downstream erosion and the need for repairs. In 2007, Barr Engineering Co. conducted a dam replacement study evaluating seven options, six of which included replacement of the dam.
The Ames Mill Dam is currently inoperable and serves no functional purpose. Water Quality Technician James McDermott described the primary reason for its replacement as ecological reform, public safety and the potential for future recreational opportunities.
The dam obstructs aquatic organism passage, isolating populations and depleting biodiversity. It also restricts water flow, which alters habitat conditions and interrupts the movement of nutrients and sediment downstream. Replacing the dam with rock arch rapids, a series of boulder arches, would remove the drowning hazard and enable future recreational activities on, in and around the river.
“You'd be able to kayak through that stretch of the river and be able to fish along more areas close to the river instead of just right in front of the dam,” said McDermott.
The 2020 Riverfront Enhancement Action Plan gave formal structure to the dam's removal and replacement by identifying the exploration of Ames Mill Dam reconstruction as a priority. While “admittedly an attractive feature downtown, \[the dam\] inhibits the natural processes of the river and limits recreational possibilities,” states the Action Plan.
In 2023, the city pursued a feasibility report to explore options for removing the dam and replacing it with rock rapids. Varying configurations were evaluated with criteria including public recreation, aquatic organism passage and funding source preferences. “Stakeholder and public input was received on the different options and concluded that there was general support for the Option 3 – Long Rock Rapids due to enhancing the river recreation opportunities, improving safety and improving river ecology,” stated the City Council resolution adopted in November 2023, which authorized further exploration of the option.
The city is pursuing an options agreement with Post, whom McDermott described as supportive of the project, to enable an environmental assessment of the dam and work toward a potential future ownership transfer. The options agreement and the city's contract with Barr Engineering will be discussed in City Council meetings on Tuesday, Nov. 10 and Tuesday, Nov. 17.
“The City does not need to insert itself, and thus the Northfield taxpayers, into a responsibility, potential liability or financial obligation that belongs to others.”— Katy Vondrasek via Facebook
“The Barr Engineering contract is the details of that exploration work. So that contract entails environmental site assessments, geotechnical and hydrological investigation, the environmental assessment worksheet, permitting prep and then preliminary design,” said McDermott. “Part of what this Barr assessment would be doing is testing that sediment behind the dam for heavy metals and PAHs, which are cancer-causing hydrocarbons. We'd be testing for those, and then, depending on what we find, removing that sediment and sending it to a solid waste facility.”
While organizers highlight the project's benefits, a growing coalition of Northfield residents has voiced strong opposition, citing the dam's historical value and expressing concern that the project will put financial pressure on taxpayers. “It is more than a structure; it is part of our city's story,” said City Councilor-elect Katy Vondrasek on her campaign Facebook page.
“The City does not need to insert itself, and thus the Northfield taxpayers, into a responsibility, potential liability or financial obligation that belongs to others.”
In response, McDermott noted the extensive array of funding sources that the city is considering, including the DNR Dam Safety Grant and various grants through the Minnesota State National Fish Passage Program. He also noted the potential ownership transfer agreement with Post as instrumental to funding the project, as many grants are contingent on public ownership.
Regarding the historical aspect of the dam, McDermott said, “In the future I know we'd like to do historical exploratory work behind the dam and then some sort of acknowledgment... about the history of the Ames Mill Dam.”
The dam replacement project's construction phase is tentatively scheduled for 2027 to 2028.