TLDR: Fire Matt Patricia, at the very least.
I've been saying this since Ryan Day lost to Michigan for the 25th time. The standard response is "he won a natty," so let's deal with that.
1. The 2024 title doesn't prove what people think it proves.
Yes, he won it, and I'm glad he did. But a result isn't evidence of process. A two-loss team got into the playoff, and the teams we faced were fundamentally broken. The team won that title, not just Day. With a different head coach we might have gone undefeated. I can't prove that, but "Day is the reason we won" is just as unprovable, and it's the claim everyone treats as settled.
2. 2025 hid every problem.
Everything that won us 2024 left, and every weakness that held us back was still there. An easy conference schedule and weak competition covered it up. Against the only good teams we played, Day still got embarrassed, and the 2024 clutch card made sure nobody cared. That's vibes, not evaluation.
3. 2026 is where it falls apart.
Teams rebounded and the schedule is much harder. Any sane person saw a three-loss season, but the committee and this sub didn't. I expected Day to shit the bed. I expected the offense to shit the bed with Sayin. What I didn't expect was Matt Patricia's defense collapsing like a cheap roll of toilet paper.
4. The Patricia defense.
If you ignored everything above, at least take this one point. If you need elite players to run a defense, you're a bad coach. Who can't run a defense with the best talent in the country? That's the baseline for the job……
Fire Patricia!!!! Then we can argue about Day.