TL;DR: How to teach loose-leash walking and better frustration tolerance without constantly creating situations where my dog gets overwhelmed.
I have a ~7yo, 40 lb rescue (Aussie/Beagle mutt) who I've had for several years. She was found as a stray, and she's smart, independent, VERY opinionated, and easily frustrated when she can't do what she wants.
We’ve worked a LOT and she’s gotten so much better over the years. She's very good at relaxing around the house, but gets incredibly excited about certain activities, especially walks. As soon as the leash comes out, she starts jumping, barking, and biting at the leash. On walks, she pulls a LOT, will lunge at squirrels, and will even try to circle around me to pull us in the direction she wants to go. Sometimes she’s fine and usually will start to walk well after 30-45min.
I've tried stopping whenever she pulls, changing directions, rewarding loose-leash walking, etc. She'll sometime go loose leash for a second, but immediately goes back to pulling. If I repeatedly stop or redirect her, she just gets more and more frustrated and may bark at me or nip at my hands. She has good bite inhibition, but I don't want to push her to that point.
She's food motivated at home, but outside, moving and exploring are much more rewarding than treats. She also has severe food allergies and is on a prescription hydrolyzed diet, so high-value treats are pretty limited.
I've recently tried desensitizing her to the leash by casually picking it up and putting it down without going for walks. She doesn't necessarily react much in the moment, but afterward she's been going to the leash area, barking at me, and generally seeming more agitated. I'm concerned I'm just increasing her frustration.
I've worked with trainers before, but many recommended aversive tools, including a shock collar, which I've decided to stop using. I'd really like to focus on reward-based methods. I've tried to find better ones but have not had much success.
My biggest question is how to teach loose-leash walking and better frustration tolerance without constantly creating situations where she gets overwhelmed. She still needs daily exercise, and I don't want every walk to become a frustrating training session.
What approaches could work and how do I know if I need to keep pushing through? I know consistency is key but I don't want to be consistent on something that might just make things worse.
I have just purchased a y-shaped harness for her and a lead that can hook onto the front and the back. Plus, I've bought little reusable squeeze pouches to keep her HP wet food which she likes more than her normal kibble so I can have some treats on the go.