Extremely tired of Umera Ahmed pushing the same bullshit rhetoric in every other drama: that giving women independence or freedom of choice will inevitably corrupt them, that a daughter will always turn into a liability if you trust her too much or love her unconditionally, or that allowing women to choose their own partners will always end in disaster. Like, give me a frikin break and OPEN YOUR EYES AND LOOK AROUND??!?
Restricting women's freedom, denying them the right to choose, or abstaining from falling in love before marriage has in NO WAY guaranteed them the blissful, healthy marital life she so confidently idealizes and preaches. In fact, hundreds and thousands of women are being physically and mentally degraded, manipulated, abused, violated, and brutally MURDERED in those very certified HALAL marriages that happened with their parents' full approval and, in most cases, were arranged by their parents. A woman is statistically far more likely to end up with a Zaamil or an Aman Gujjar than an Abu Bakar, even if she keeps herself devoid of every supposedly "sinful" or "haram" activity and takes the very halal route society prescribes for her.
Khushbakht and Zaryab are constantly shown self-flagellating over their mistakes, blaming themselves for misusing the "freehand" and "blind trust" their parents afforded them. But in reality, the onus also lies on their parents for failing to instill basic social survival skills in them. Khushbakht's father kept her overly sheltered and protected, which left her extremely naive and gullible, while Zaryab's parents were neglectful of her emotional development and never taught her what healthy attachments look like. As a result, both girls grew up without a properly developed self-preservation instinct, unable to identify red flags, with a completely malfunctioning predator/manipulator-detecting radar.
Umera is quite right in pointing out the kind of horrible men our society enables and produces, but, as always, arrives at completely wrong and deeply regressive solutions. The solution is NOT to shut women inside their homes, restrict their movement, take away their choices, or deprive them of their agency. The solution is to equip our daughters with the tools to navigate the world safely: teach them to recognize manipulation, establish boundaries, question authority, assess character, cultivate financial independence, and make informed decisions without fear. Create an environment where they can share their inner worlds and emotions with you, come to you without shame or fear of punishment when things go wrong, and allow them the grace to move on from their mistakes.
And I also can't help but notice the not-so-subtle reinforcement of the "men will be men" angle. The words like "be-haya", "be-sharam", "be-ghairat", and "aazaad" are exclusively being uttered by the women in the drama to describe their own actions, while the men responsible for their suffering are let off the hook with barely any consequences or scrutiny of their upbringing, character, or accountability. Sure, we have Abu Bakar as an anchoring example of how men should be, but he's merely a crumb of progressiveness in an otherwise plethora of regressive messaging. The entire narrative's focus is on the women who are portrayed as sinners, and the message is repeatedly reinforced that this is the consequence of giving daughters too much affection and freedom. The numerous terrible men in the story are simply shown as terrible, as though they were born that way, as though most men are inherently like this, and there is nothing to be done about them. As if all the moral training and restrictions should be imposed on women because men cannot be restricted, corrected, or expected to do better.
And I think the audience's reaction to Abu Bakar's character is proof of this as well. The bar for men is so unbelievably low that his basic decency is enough to make people regard him as almost angelic. Apparently, all it takes for a man to stand out is to be respectful, emotionally mature, and not a complete asshole.
The drama's execution is brilliant, the direction is excellent, and the acting is phenomenal. But, as always, Umera Ahmed's intellectual and sociopolitical stagnation has been deeply disappointing.