r/PKMS • • 21d ago

Self-Promotion Self promotion thread (November 2026)

10 Upvotes

r/PKMS • • Aug 11 '26

Combating AI Slop and Astroturfing

58 Upvotes

The mod team will now be more strict against AI slop on this subreddit; any continuous violations of rule #5 (No AI Slop) will result in a ban. We highly encourage users to flag any AI posts/astroturfing.

All promotions should go in the Promotions thread.

Also, I want to give a shout out to our top 1% contributors and everybody who makes this cove of the internet the best place to discuss PKM. You guys are the best :)


r/PKMS • • 18h ago

Discussion What is the smallest rule that keeps a PKMS useful when life gets busy?

6 Upvotes

When I am busy, I am tempted to stop capturing altogether or add more structure than I can maintain. What is the one low-effort rule in your system—such as a weekly cleanup, a default inbox, or a limit on new tags—that has kept it useful without turning maintenance into another project?


r/PKMS • • 1d ago

Other My quest has finished

0 Upvotes

I started searching for the ideal "record " and task management app over a year ago. "record" means Notes and Diary. I tested at least 50 apps.... Finally, I found Eidos

I'm longing to find a replacement for Joplin that would be an integrated personal workspace: a mature FOSS application with a visual interface and WYSIWYG editing, document organization in folders and collections, notes, tasks, diary and mood tracking, attachments of any type, and accessible data in an open format. Mandatory compatibility between Windows and Android, true offline functionality on Android, CRUD without connection, preferably transparent synchronization, as well as reliable import and export of existing data.

Yes, Eidos exists : it brings together notes, tables, relationships, formulas, views, and tasks in a single application, with a local SQLite database (.eidos) and markdown files editor , portable files, offline operation, and a native Android app.

To use it coming from a reasonably good export app (as neither Affine nor Logseq are...) is easy with the use of AI, a script and a good verification....

Below is a brief history from where I went to arrive at at Eidos, the app as perfect as it can be (at least to me)... Anyone who wants to go straight to the practical side can download the app (or try it in the web) and maybe use my templates that are here and be happy.

Actually, I've been looking for this app since the beginning of the popularization of personal computers, which only arrived in my family in the 90s... I was amazed by the possibility of abandoning the notes scattered in pocket notebooks that had no indexing or possibility of structured index...

There was the promise of "eternity" of what was written: it would be available from the beginning and, with a good backup, forever... That was not what happened on reality....

From my first attempts with .txt files, the systems became outdated, the apps unusable, or they started charging monthly fees to use something that was not even known if it would continue to exist...

What happened several times was that my "eternal" and "always accessible" data became an export that had no indexing or reference. That is, when you were lucky : sometimes what you could retrieve from the software was not even readable... Eventually it was even corrupted!

The backup was useless: a thing that only the the old app, which I couldn't even use on the new system, could read... I have files on my PC which I occasionally stumble that are an idea, text, or piece of information of great value to me buried in a file... A lot creations or references that I remember making but gave up looking for....

I think, I'm not entirely sure, but I have the impression that around 2010 this changed a bit... With the idea of ​​free software and portability between systems getting closer and closer to the omnipresent Windows, apps started trying to be cross-platform and have at least a readable export... A few at least....

After the "Palm" (I had a "Zire 21") came Nokia, which was left behind (my data from the spectacular Nokia N 810, who knows where it ended up) by Android (my first was a 5" Samsung "tablet" that wasn't a smartphone...).

However, the same story continued.... But there were already apps whose export was common, readable files. I've searched and used some , only to be stay with for Joplin: as "fluid" and "beautiful" as a square wheel, but it works and I felt safe hoping that someone in the world would make something that had some beauty and functionality so that I could use it properly for things other than note-taking. I tried to adapt how I used tasks to what Joplin offered only to understand that this was not possible... I even went into Logseq, which resembled more of an information labyrinth where one corridor was enough, just to return to Joplin.

With AI, many new things appeared, a lot of excitement, only to frustrate me by discovering that an app that met what I wanted and that I liked apparently did not exist....or maybe I hadn't looked properly...? As I said, after more than a year of searching and "false positives" and others "almost there for real" (HelixNotes and ZenNotes) I've arrived at Eidos.


r/PKMS • • 2d ago

Discussion Help choosing a notes app

11 Upvotes

I'm looking for a notes app to store my notes that are 70% text, 20% doctor prescriptions (images, PDFs) and a few videos (5%) and Misc files (excel etc. 5%). I also need to be able to create basic tables and enter some information inside.

I have found Evernote works well for me but (1) it's not offline first so at clinics with poor mobile connectivity, if I haven't 'offlined' the folder or note, I'm stuck and (2) the mobile app is not native quality and (3) I share the general concerns about (a) the direction their pricing is headed and (b) whether the company is serious about maintaining and running EN in the long term.

The only other app that has worked well for me is Bear. But the lack of folders bothers me as does the need to have an icloud subscription (since my prescriptions take up a lot of space). Offline is great since it's local first but table support is poor. Like their support too!

Which of these would you pick? Any other recommendations?

Here's what I've tried so far: Notion (too clunky and involved), Obsidian (needs plugins for some basic needs I have and these are 3rd party + too easy to waste time on 'customizing'), Craft (don't like blocks), Capacities, Anytype, Upnote (team details missing, some privacy worries, file upload limit and longevity concerns)...

(I'm on Macs and iOS)

Thank you


r/PKMS • • 2d ago

Discussion 自身のライフログを集計して、宇宙のように広がっていくの楽しいと思うのですが異常でしょうか。

12 Upvotes

I'm a 33-year-old Japanese man.

I haven't used Reddit much, so I apologize if my manners are lacking.

*Also, I'm not very good at English, so I've translated this into English.

I collect my own life log raw data (voice recordings (like talking to myself), location information every 15 minutes, biometric data like sleep and heart rate, and digital activities like files edited on my PC),

and at the end of the day, I put everything into a daily database table and visualize it on the front-end UI as a 3D universe of knowledge and a 3D mind-body terrain.

Honestly, I've stopped caring about maximizing productivity. I find it strangely interesting to fly around the universe of my past thoughts, discover unexpected connections, see how my heart rate was elevated at 8 AM on this day and that day, and observe how it shapes the terrain of my thoughts.

It's like my memories become art,

and although it's still in the conceptual stage and I don't know if it's feasible, I'm thinking of making it a real-time, moving desktop PC wallpaper.

I use a lot of different third-party apps, like Macrodroid and various Google Apps Scripts, and the maintenance and management are quite a challenge...

Are there others who enjoy visually appreciating data rather than using it as a productivity tool?

My favorite is the recovery elevation map.

It's like the space-themed ones in Paradox's Stellaris game.

I'd love to see any of your clusters or space-like graphs you've created.

-- In Japan, there aren't many communities like this, except for business purposes, so I'm very excited to find a place like this in the English-speaking world.

33歳日本人男性です。

reddit自体あんまり使ったことが無いのでマナーができてなかったら申し訳ございません。

※あと英語はあんまり出来ないので、グーグルで英語に翻訳しています。

自分のライフログ生データ(音声※独り言とか、15分ごとの位置情報、生体データ睡眠とか心拍数とか、PCで編集したファイルなどのデジタル活動)を集めて、

1日の終わりにすべてをまとめて1日のDBのテーブルに入れて、フロントエンド側のUIで3Dの知識の宇宙や3Dの心身地形として可視化しています。

正直、もう生産性の最大化とかはどうでもよくなっていて、過去の思考の宇宙を飛び回るような感じで意外な繋がりを見つけたり、心拍数が朝8時に上がっていたのがこの日とこの日がつながっているとか、自分の思考の地形をどう形作っているか眺めたりするのが、妙に面白く感じています。

自身の思い出がそのままアートみたいになるっていうか、

まだ構想で出来るかもわかっていない段階ですが、リアルタイムで動く、デスクトップPCの壁紙にしようとかと思うほどです。

色々なサードパーティのアプリとかをかなり使っていてmacrodroidとか、GASいろいろ、もう保守管理の方が大変ですが・・・

もう生産性ツールというより、データを視覚的に楽しんでいる人はいますか?

私の一番のお気に入りは回復標高マップです

paradoxのstellalis gameみたいな宇宙っぽいやつです

皆さんのこういうクラスターというか宇宙のようなグラフあればぜひ見せてほしいです。

ーー
日本にはこういうコミュニティ?がビジネス用途でしかあんまりないのでこういう場が英語圏にあってとてもワクワクしています。

---

実際は揺らいでいて綺麗
たぶんタグごとのクラスターをうまくいじって色を動かせば良くなりそうなcosmos系

r/PKMS • • 1d ago

Other I built a free, open-source journaling app with prompts inspired by popular books (works offline, too!)

Thumbnail gallery
0 Upvotes

r/PKMS • • 2d ago

Method META REFLECTION 🪞 PKM - Personal Knowledge Management 📖 Self Amplification 8🗓️26

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/PKMS • • 3d ago

Discussion What do you do with the reels and posts you save? Do you ever find them again?

5 Upvotes

r/PKMS • • 4d ago

Discussion How big is your largest vault?

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/PKMS • • 5d ago

Discussion Mem shutting down

25 Upvotes

One of those early apps that eventually drowned in a sea of similar LLM assisted apps. Early on I recall a lot of video influencers hyping it. Over time, it went through so many different iterations, never able to distinguish itself. Good lesson to remember, death comes for all apps. With the big LLMs expanding their capabilities and having ongoing memory of user conversations, these smaller apps will likely continue to get picked off. It makes me appreciate orgmode and other offline centered alternatives that don’t have so many moving parts dependent on AI.


r/PKMS • • 5d ago

Discussion I used an algorithm to automatically detect clusters in my collective knowledge graph

Post image
0 Upvotes

Instead of relying purely on manual organization, I wanted to see what would happen if I let an algorithm automatically detect clusters (i call them "Hubs") in my knowledge graph purely from how notes and concepts are linked together.

I'm currently working on an update for a collaborative knowledge app I'm building, and I've been testing the Louvain community detection algorithm on the global graph (the shared knowledge graph)

I was genuinely surprised by the quality of the results and what pure graph structure reveals without any AI or text analysis.

For instance, it surfaced parallel clusters across languages, like "Productivity" and "Productivité" showing up as two separate hubs. That raises an interesting design question: writing bridge notes to link both concepts could eventually pull them together, though keeping distinct clusters for each language community might actually be preferable (we'll see what happens!).

On the flip side, it kept closely related topics separate, like "Prise de notes" (note-taking) and "Système de prise de note" (note-taking systems), simply because their notes connect to different neighboring concepts. It was also fascinating to spot tiny clusters forming around very specific niche topics that individual users just started exploring.

For the technical part for those interested : I looked into Leiden algo too, though my current stack only had a solid library for Louvain. Each detected cluster gets assigned a color and is automatically named after its highest-weighted concept. Since the script runs every night at midnight, I added a small stabilization step that compares each new output against the previous day's run, keeping the same IDs and colors whenever a cluster's core nodes haven't shifted too much.

Watching how these clusters grow, split, or merge over time should be really interesting, but for now I don't store historical snapshots of each daily run.

Have any of you experimented with automated graph clustering (via plugins, custom scripts, or specific PKM tools) ?

I'm curious to hear how you approach discovering structure in a growing graph, or any thoughts and questions you have on this setup!


r/PKMS • • 6d ago

Method How to get posts to an inbox?

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/PKMS • • 7d ago

Discussion App Slopocalypse: The not-so-good, the bad, and the ugly

21 Upvotes

With AI dramatically lowering the barrier to building software, we're seeing an explosion of new apps, especially in the note-taking space which already had a lot of options.

Some are genuinely impressive. Others feel like hastily assembled clones with a fresh coat of paint.

It's beginning to feel impossible to sort through it all. I'm curious how people distinguish between what's worth the time and what's outright slop. Even worse is the issue of abandonware. It's never been cheaper and quicker to develop, but maintaining software still takes dedication.

What are your biggest green flags and red flags when evaluating a new app? What makes something worth your attention rather than just more noise?


r/PKMS • • 6d ago

Other outl new logo, the octopus grew up, and it is still an octopus

Post image
0 Upvotes

outl has a new logo. The cartoon octopus with glasses and an Esc keycap is replaced by a flat silhouette on a 91 by 128 grid: a head with 21 unit corners, a short stub and three tentacles, all cut at the same slope, atan(3/5), which is 30.96 degrees. The post walks through the real numbers (the widths 25, 18 and 13, the lime tip on the dark theme, the 56% mark on the app tile, the contrast ratios), says what the new mark gave up, and notes that the site already wears it while the app icons on every client ship in the next release.

https://outl.app/blog/the-octopus-grew-up


r/PKMS • • 7d ago

Discussion Giving mobile AI assistants (Claude/Grok) read + write access to a private Obsidian vault (iCloud) via a self-hosted MCP on my VPS. Good idea?

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/PKMS • • 7d ago

Method I'm new here in this case...

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/PKMS • • 8d ago

Discussion Where do you capture everything, from quick to-dos to ideas buried in AI chats?

12 Upvotes

I’m looking for one place to dump thoughts as they come up. Ideally, I could dictate or type something and have AI automatically organise it into tasks, projects, ideas or calendar events.

Some of my thinking also happens inside ChatGPT and Claude conversations. Useful ideas end up buried in different chats, with no real system for reviewing them. I’m considering an Obsidian vault with an AI connector, so I could say “save this idea” during a conversation and have it stored somewhere permanent and searchable, although I’m not sure whether this is possible with ChatGPT.

I’ve also considered building my own personal dashboard. The idea would be simple: I dictate “dry cleaning at 10am on the 12th”, and it automatically creates a Google Calendar event and saves the information. Another day, I dictate a project idea, and it gets saved somewhere I can actually find again. That’s really all I’m looking for, perhaps with a little AI to help search everything.

But surely there’s an existing solution that does this well?

Has anyone solved this? What does your setup look like? Ideally something that works across Mac and iPhone, without constantly having to manually move information between apps.

Thanks!


r/PKMS • • 7d ago

Discussion Is there a way to access my Obsidian vault directly from ChatGPT's regular chat mode?

Thumbnail reddit.com
4 Upvotes

r/PKMS • • 7d ago

Discussion Does any note-taking app do dictation cleanup properly?

Thumbnail reddit.com
3 Upvotes

r/PKMS • • 8d ago

Feature Are there any PKMs that use textblocks as the core method of data organization?

6 Upvotes

I have been using Obsidian for quite awhile and I love so many things about it but there is one feature that not even the extensive plugin ecosystem supports extensively, block references. I am constantly wanting to reference a block of text or a paragraph in other notes that overlap in subject but the rest of the heading does not. I am using nested headings for mapping the local hierarchy of a notes wikilinks, which leaves the note lagging because there are so many block links. This especially becomes a problem when I want to make small or quick edits to the blocks or their identifiers and have to wait 5-10mins for my changes to update across the vault.

I think the issue is that I am using Obsidian for something that it was not designed for and need to move part of my workflow to another tool. I have considered moving stuff to Logseq but after some testing and noodling around with its block-linking system, I think I might run into a similar problems in different ways. I know emacs has some potential but have not gotten past the tutorial for its macros and am kinda in the dark on how it even works. At this point I have a pretty decent collection of criteria I could try coding up a prototype myself if I had the time, or more realistically biting the bullet and getting a claude code subscription, but thought I would make a post to see if this as already been done.


r/PKMS • • 8d ago

Discussion Does anyone know of a good tool/platform for this?

19 Upvotes

i have this habit of saving all the useful stuff I come across - like articles, Reddit posts, YouTube videos, research papers, etc. I always save them thinking like “this is going to be useful later” and then when I actually need something a few months later, I have no idea where I saved it.

i'm basically looking for something that's more than just a bookmark manager, but also doesn't require me to manually organize and write notes for everything I save.

Does something like this already exist? What do you guys use for this?


r/PKMS • • 8d ago

Method Highlighting came out low utility in the 2013 study-techniques review, and most clipping is highlighting

0 Upvotes

Dunlosky and colleagues reviewed 10 study techniques in 2013. Highlighting was rated low utility, along with rereading and summarizing. Practice testing and spacing reviews out were rated high. Self-explanation, where you write down why something is true, landed in the middle.

A web clip or a Kindle highlight import is mostly highlighting. So what probably does the work is a line you write under the clip about why it's true or what it connects to. If you can't write that line, the clip is likely not worth keeping.

The other cheap change is when you reopen a note, try to recall what it says before you read it.

Caveat: this is all research on students, nobody has tested it on note systems. Has anyone run a rule like this for a few months?


r/PKMS • • 8d ago

Other EIDOS as a notetaking and Tasks app

Thumbnail
reddit.com
0 Upvotes

Hello I've discovered https://github.com/mayneyao/eidos . I'm planning to make it my notes and tasks app. Anyone who already does any of this ?

Update : https://github.com/mayneyao/eidos/issues/404