I'm new to advertising. I started running Meta ad sets for my new product. There is clearly demand for the product, as I've been able to raise $3,000 in revenue (mostly from ads) in 20 days, mostly off $50/day ad spend budget.
However, there's a big issue: All of the ad sets fall off a massive cliff after about 4 or 5 days. They do really well (as far as CAC goes), then don't just fall off a little, the CAC just starts exploding to 5x, 6x, 7x, and 8x even pretty much over night.
What I've learned is this is almost certainly due to the $50/day budget. With such small spend, the machine learning algo doesn't have enough data to accurately start bidding on the right buyer.
What's worse? It drifts...It just starts spending money on worse and worse people if the first set of people it found were the wrong ones, but just happened to convert by variance.
So this is my question.. does it feel to anyone else like an ad set is a gum-ball machine? Where yo put 25 cents in, and hope for the blue gum ball, but you're at the mercy of variance? And furthermore, it's something you have to let thrive or kill early on. It's like a trajectory of an arrow. From a target 1 foot away, moving the arrow an inch won't do much. But if the target is a mile away, 1 inch off center will be a massive miss.
So what I've been wondering is, does anyone else agree? You can have the "perfect" ad, the "perfect" landing page, and the "perfect" audience, but if the algorithm accidentally clings to the wrong data up front, it throws everything downstream off, by pure luck.
In theory, you could run the same duplicate ad set and have a massive success on the duplicate copy.
If you agree, what is your solution to this? My best guess would be: hedge. Always have multiple ad sets running simultaneously.
Thoughts? Thanks.