​
I'm hoping to find other former Argosy University students who have gone through, or are currently going through, the Borrower Defense discharge process.
I'm honestly at a point where I don't know what to believe or what my actual status is anymore.
I applied for Borrower Defense in April 2023, approximately a year after the borrowers who received relief through the Argosy lawsuit. The frustrating part is that I had absolutely no idea the lawsuit had even happened. I was a former student, and I feel it's incredibly disappointing that students who may have qualified weren't directly notified that there was a lawsuit or that they might be entitled to relief.
My husband also attended Argosy University, and his student loans have already been discharged. So I know relief has happened for former Argosy students. I'm just trying to understand where my own case stands.
Here's where things get confusing.
I received a letter from StudentAid.gov dated October 3 that was honestly very exciting. The letter discussed the discharge process for eligible Argosy borrowers and included the following statement:
“FSA is notifying the guarantors of eligible borrowers, who will then notify the servicer to process the discharge.”
The letter also explained that my loan servicer would notify me once all my eligible federal Argosy loans had been fully discharged.
Based on this letter, I understood that I was included in the eligible-borrower discharge process and that the next steps involved getting the discharge processed.
Now, when I call Aidvantage and enter my Social Security number into their automated phone system, I'm told that my Borrower Defense discharge is being worked on and processed.
The automated message tells me to expect changes to my account, including possible negative balances, and to bear with them while they process the discharge.
That sounds promising, right?
But here's the problem.
When I log into StudentAid.gov and look at my Borrower Defense case, the status still says “Being Reviewed.”
It doesn't appear to update at all.
I've also figured out how to access the additional status information using the little status-code workaround, and that currently shows 2.10.
So I have three different things happening:
\- StudentAid.gov sent me a letter discussing the discharge process for eligible Argosy borrowers.
\- Aidvantage's automated system says my discharge is being processed and warns me about upcoming account changes and possible negative balances.
\- My actual Borrower Defense dashboard still says “Being Reviewed,” while the additional status code shows 2.10.
How do these things fit together? Is this normal? Is the website simply behind the actual processing?
The other major issue is that I'm trying to buy a house.
My mortgage lender needs written confirmation that my loans have been approved for discharge or that the discharge is actively being processed.
Neither Aidvantage nor the Borrower Defense department will give me a letter that clearly states where my loans stand.
I've explained that I don't necessarily need the discharge completed today. I need something in writing that my mortgage lender can use to determine how these loans should be treated during underwriting.
I've now filed a complaint with the Ohio Attorney General's office because I'm getting nowhere.
And here's the frustrating part:
\- Borrower Defense tells me to contact StudentAid.gov.
\- StudentAid.gov tells me to contact Aidvantage.
\- Aidvantage tells me to contact Borrower Defense.
I'm literally being sent in a triangle, and nobody seems willing or able to give me a straight answer.
I have several questions for anyone who has gone through this:
- Has anyone received the Argosy discharge processing letter from StudentAid.gov but continued to see “Being Reviewed” on their dashboard?
- Does anyone know what status code 2.10 means in this situation?
- Has anyone had Aidvantage's automated system give them the same message about discharge processing, negative balances, and account changes?
- How long did it take from receiving that message to actually seeing your loans discharged?
- Did anyone successfully get written confirmation from the Department of Education or Aidvantage that their discharge was approved or being processed?
- If you were buying a house, what documentation were you able to provide your mortgage lender?
- Is there another department, supervisor, ombudsman, or agency I should contact when nobody will take responsibility for answering my questions?
I'm especially interested in hearing from people who applied after the original Argosy lawsuit and received relief through the later Borrower Defense process.
I'm not looking for guesses or someone to simply tell me to be patient. I would genuinely appreciate hearing from people who have experienced this firsthand, including actual timelines and what their account statuses looked like.
I've been fighting this since 2023, and after everything I've been through, I just want some clarity. I'm trying to buy a home, and these loans are standing in the way of that.
Has anyone else been in this exact situation?
Edit #1 – October 3 Letter
I originally opened a feedback case with StudentAid.gov because I was frustrated with getting nowhere trying to find out the status of my Borrower Defense case. I explained that I was trying to buy a house and needed written clarification about my loans for my mortgage lender.
In response, StudentAid.gov sent me a letter explaining that eligible Argosy borrowers' loans were being sent for discharge processing. It included this statement:
“FSA is notifying the guarantors of eligible borrowers, who will then notify the servicer to process the discharge.”
Within a few days of receiving that letter, Aidvantage's automated phone system changed. When I entered my Social Security number, it began telling me that my Borrower Defense discharge was being processed. It also mentioned possible negative balances and account changes while the discharge was being completed.
However, StudentAid.gov still says “Being Reviewed,” and my additional status code is 2.10.
Has anyone else experienced this sequence? I'm trying to figure out whether this means my discharge is actually moving forward.