This is the monthly thread for subreddit feedback. Feel free to air out your complaints, grievances, or (if we're lucky) praises to help us make this subreddit better.
Let us know how we're doing or what changes you'd like to see
Imagine a bowler who has 944 first-class wickets from 231 games, and this includes 139 Test wickets from 35 Test matches, at an average of 22.7 and economy of 2.51, what will you call him??? A good bowler, right??? But some people in Pakistan call him a slow bowler, he hasnât got the 140 kmph pace, call him a bowler without aura, a bowler who canât break partnerships, a bowler who farms tailender wickets, a bowler who depends on conditions, a bowler who canât take wickets anywhere but England, a bowler who will be very expensive in Pakistan, etc.
Mohammad Abbas takes a catch off his own bowling during the second Test against Sri Lanka at Rawalpindi.
This bowler is none other than 36 year old Mohammad Abbas! Mohammad Abbas was sidelined from Test Cricket after the July-August Test series against West Indies in 2021, Mohammad Abbas finally appeared in the Test squad again in November 2024, for the South Africa (away) Test series, he played the Boxing Day Test at Centurion, and this marked his Test comeback after 40 months (more than three years after his last Test appearance). At that time, he had achieved 700+ FC wickets that included 90 Test wickets.
At SuperSport Park Centurion, against South Africa, in the 1st innings he had figures of 21-4-79-1 with an economy of 3.76 while in the 2nd innings he had figures of 19.3-6-54-6 with an economy of 2.76. 2nd innings, the 19.3 overs he bowled, were in tandem and bowled consecutively in the Proteas Summer, he could've gotten us the win, but other bowlers didn't support him well, and Pakistan eventually lost by just 2 wickets, allowing Marco Jansen and Kagiso Rabada to get a 50 runs partnership from being down to 99/8 while chasing 150 odd. At Newlands, Cape Town, in the 2nd Test against Proteas, during their run-fest where Ryan Rickelton scored a double century, Abbas had figures of 27.3-1-94-3 with an Eco: 3.41 in the 1st innings and in 2nd innings 2-0-19-0 and an economy of 9.5, some context Proteas were chasing just 58 so it was a slog-fest that lasted just 7.1 overs, so don't get worried with the economy here. Here are his performances of the 2 tests he immediately played after comeback. Pakistan lost both games, first by 2 wickets, and second by 10 wickets.
Abbas was dropped for the subsequent home Test series against West Indies at Multan, where Pakistan prepared spin wickets and dropped Abbas after his brilliance in South Africa. Abbas remained overlooked for the South Africa home Test series at Lahore and Rawalpindi, again because they introduced the spin factor there, despite playing two pacers (Shaheen Afridi and Hasan Ali) at Lahore, they didnât tell us why was Abbas not considered for this series.
Finally, the squad was announced for the away Test series against Bangladesh, and Abbas returns to the squad list.
Now he makes a comeback after 15 months to Test cricket, in the 1st test at Dhaka (Sher-e-Bangla Stadium), 1st innings, he had figures of 34-8-92-5, with economy of 2.70, and in the 2nd innings, he had figures of 14-3-35-1 with economy of 2.50. In the second Test at Sylhet (Sylhet International Cricket Stadium), he has figures of 16-3-45-3 with economy of 2.81 in 1st innings, while in second innings, his figures are 23-3-66-1 with economy of 2.86. Pakistan lost both games by 104 runs and 78 runs respectively.
His next Test comes at the Brian Lara Cricket Academy at Tarouba, he has figures of 26-6-63-3 with economy of 2.42 in 1st innings, and then figures of 15.5-6-22-5 with economy of just 1.38. Needless to say, Pakistan lost by 90 runs despite Abbas bringing Pakistan into the game with his brilliant bowling in the second innings. Despite this performance, he was dropped for the very next game at Port of Spain without any proper clarifications.
Coming to the England tour of 2026, where our fanbase had a lot of expectations from Abbas as well as our team as well, two at least win a single Test match, if not the Test series. At Headingley, Leeds, he had figures of 25-5-78-1 with economy of 3.12 in the only innings Pakistan bowled and England batted, Pakistan lost this game by 103 runs and an innings. At the iconic Lordâs, London, he had figures of 20-3-73-4 with economy of 3.65, in 2nd innings, he had figures of 22-3-57-5 with economy of just 2.59, he took 9 wickets this game, and etched his name on the Lordâs record board, extending his wickets tally at Lordâs to 17 in just 2 Test matches, that includes 3 four wicket hauls and one fifer. Pakistan lost this game by 194 runs. At Edgbaston, he had figures of 23-1-95-1 with economy of 4.13 in 1st innings, while his figures in second innings were 8-1-27-2 with economy of 3.37, Pakistan lost this game by 8 wickets, and lost the series 3-0 to England. Abbas was joint Man of the Series with Englandâs Ollie Robinson.
In the 1st Test at Rawalpindi against Sri Lanka, the 1st home Test Abbas was playing after approximately 6 years, Abbas had figures of 33-12-68-2 with economy of 2.06 in the 1st innings, and the only innings Pakistan bowled and Sri lanka batted, this game was drawn. In the 2nd Test at Rawalpindi, he had figures of 14-6-14-3 with economy of 1, and in the second innings, he had figures of 34-15-55-3 with economy of 1.62, Pakistan won this Test match by 8 wickets, and Abbas was man of the match as well as Man of the series. It is worth noting that Pakistan was one bowler short in the second innings of the second Test, with Saqib Khan ruled out of the remainder of the test, with an injury after he bowled 1.2 overs and taken the 1st wicket, so Abbas, Razaullah and Aamir Jamal shared the additional duties of the fourth pacer here.
The 2nd Test at Rawalpindi vs. Sri Lanka, was the 1st Test match after Abbasâs comeback that Pakistan won with Abbas being part of the playing XI, the other three instances Pakistan won the Test match, was at Multan (against West Indies), Lahore (against South Africa) and Port of Spain (against West Indies), where in the 1st two victories, Abbas wasnât part of the squad, while in the win at Port of Spain against West Indies, he was dropped from the playing XI and he was sitting on the bench.
Mohammad Abbas since his Test comeback in 2024.
To see a bowler, who has for the first time in this year, received consistent chances in Test Cricket, he has topped the charts with 39 Test wickets, he might be surpassed by the end of this year, by either Josh Tongue or Mitchell Starc, but it speaks a lot about the greatness of Mohammad Abbas. We see other fast bowlers bowl well here and there and we say that if Abbas is that great, why he canât be like them. One of the main reasons are, Abbas is bowling with different bowlers nearly every other Test match. Even if we take the bowlers he bowled with this year. In Bangladesh, he bowled alongside Shaheen Shah Afridi, Hasan Ali and Khurram Shahzad. In West Indies, he bowled alongside Khurram Shahzad, Mohammad Ali and Aamir Jamal. At Headingley and Lordâs, he bowled alongside Khurram Shahzad and Mohammad Ali. At Edgbaston, he bowled with Mohammad Ali, Razaullah and Imran Randhawa. At Rawalpindi in the 1st Test, he was bowling with Saqib Khan and Razaullah, in the second Test he was bowling with Saqib, Razaullah and Aamir Jamal. The pacer combination was changed thrice in the 8 Test matches he played this year. It takes some time to make a good understanding while bowling in a Test match with other bowlers. But even then, he is producing goated stats.
And perhaps he has hit a purple patch of his career, I remember that in September 2024, he achieved the 700 FC wickets mark in the County Championship. Now 26 months later, he has 944 FC wickets. This means that he has taken 244 FC wickets in 26 months, and that includes 49 Test wickets as well. He has taken wickets in the County Championship in England, in the Presidentâs First-Class Competition and Quaid-e-Azam Trophy in Pakistan, as well as taking wickets in South Africa, Bangladesh and West Indies. This alone rejects the concept that he is a conditions bowler, and cannot perform well outside England, this was the general belief of our cricketing fanbase in the recent past. Now all of them would be finding new excuses to imply that Abbas isnât that good.
I am just trying to say here. Respect Mohammad Abbas. He can do so many things while bowling at 118-128 kmph in actual Test matches. He gives his 100% in the matches we play. He puts in so much effort playing domestic, county cricket, and never gave an interview saying that he was done injustice by PCB. Whenever he was called in the national side, he came and performed.
He received joint POTS award with Ollie Robinson in the England series, while he received POTS award for the Rawalpindi Test series against Sri Lanka, as well as the MOTM award of the 2nd Sri Lanka Test.
Khurram Shahzad has bowled 35 no balls in Tests this year, more than Abbas, Razaullah and Saqib Khan combined, and he's played just 7 innings. And that's probably one of the reason he is out of the team.
Abbas is the opposite story. He's bowled more than double the overs of anyone else on this list (307.5), has 74 maidens, and only 15 no balls. That's 0.05 per over, which is remarkable discipline for a workhorse.
Razaullah has bowled 14 no balls in just 5 innings, and only 5 maidens to show for 88 overs. And Saqib Khan is pretty much similar case as well.
Is it an issue with the team's coaching and monitoring? Do we need a dedicated no-ball drill in camps? Curious what you all think.
During our international cricket off-season...I have decided to start a new series on r/pakcricket. I would need your support.
We had special Pakistan XI editions over the Pakistani summer, previously did 'Guess the Player' and r/pakcricket Trivia series as well. Big thanks to u/Ghostly_100 for keeping us busy throughout our off-season last summer, as well as u/Downtown_Bat7013 for starting the 'Guess the Player' Segment and then letting me to continue it.
By next week, the new series will be starting, and hopefully it runs throughout December till the All-Pakistan tri-series.
I knew that Younis was not as good in ODIs as he was in tests, but when I took a closer look I was genuinely dumbfounded.
He's played 265 ODIs, batted 255 times, has 7249 runs, 7 centuries and 48 50s at an average of 31.2
There are 48 players with 7k+ ODI runs. He ranks #47 in average and #36 in strike rate. Even if you relax the constraint to 6K or 5K ODI runs, he still ranks near the bottom 10 in average and the bottom third in strike rate.
If you go by innings batted, with 250+ innings batted he ranks #29 in average and #22 in strike rate out of 32 players. Even if you restrict it to his era (between his debut and final match), there are 91 players in this time frame with 100+ innings batted. He ranks #64. Almost every single one of the players below him in every single one of these lists is either an all rounder, a tailender, a pinch hitter, or a WK batter. Almost none of them were true specialist batters.
By all accounts, there is no specialist batter in the history of ODI cricket who got as many chances as he did and was worse.
I understand that todays era of ODI is a lot more batting friendly but even if there was a guy averaging like 35-36 (which I think is comparable to the 31 that Younis had in his time) at a below average SR as a 3,4, or 5 in todays game there's no way they would last long enough to even get to 50 ODIs let alone the 250+ that Younis got.
For those of you who actually watched his ODI career in full, can you explain to me how he got such a long run in the team? Was the talent drought in the Pakistan team this bad that he managed to just be an automatic inclusion for a decade? Or was it a case of him being in the ODI team on the basis of his legendary test status?
Various newspaper writers in England had used various phrases to highlight such accusations, one stuck out as the worst in an already back batch: "pack of cheats"...the writer knew what he was doing by using that first word, in reference to a group of Pakistanis.
This was 1992.
Wasim and Waqar, in their pomp, befuddled England's batters throughout the test series and if not for some sloppy performances, they would likely have won the ODI series too.
Pakistan had been on that tour of England for over three months when the Daily Mirror ran that headline and more than stirred the pot. They had played 29 matches, from tour games to international contests, winning 16. This was truly one of the greatest sides to ever set foot on English soil and yet, because reverse swing was not under the command of the English (or the Aussies, or the Saffers) it was regarded as blatant cheating.
In the late 90s and mid-00s, as English cricket's premier fast bowlers in Gough, Flintoff, Jones and Harmison started to reverse it, with much help from Wasim and Waqar, that the headlines now morphed. The dark arts had become just an art...
There is so much more that could be said of those years, or those that followed but let's fast forwar to 2026 and Usman Khawaja.
Usman was an Australian cricket of the highest regard from a Pakistani background. He was part of the teams that battled South Africa, winning and losing in competitive games which bookended a great rivalry. When he made the quite obvious claim that the whole team knew and that the bowlers "must" know, he was viewed with the same squinty eyed suspicion as his Asian counterparts.
"Thrown them under the bus"
"Why now?"
"We're sure Starc, Cummins and co could never know, they never would"
(Why they never would I leave to your imagination)
Cameron Bancroft's letter, published on cricinfo, in Australian newspapers and global back pages change the game. It blew open the door Uzzy had nudged.
Everyone is taking it very seriously now, those same voices that downplayed Khawaja, that mocked his long-time friend Warner, those same voices that echoed lines such as "pack of cheats" are now calling for an open and honest discussion and STILL they are downplaying the worst act of ball tampering in cricketing history.
Nasser Hussain, who really should know better, has just said it's not about the tampering but about how "un-Australian" it is to let down your team mates. Can it not be Australian to cheat? Or South African? Or English?
Weirdly enough, it is the non-Asian nations that have had the worst history of ball tampering. They are the ones who took the art and turned it dark.
Usman is being vindicated, even on Fox Sports while sat opposite Adam Gilchrist and next to Michael Vaughan. Bancroft is now speaking on the strength he now has because of those revelations and Warner can be a very proud friend but the dark ,racist history of cricket never seem to go away and I think that is truly the biggest problem here.
The problem can only be recognised if it is first accepted and then we can start addressing what may or may not be the art of reverse swing.