I can’t believe an Ann Liang book bored me this much. I am the biggest fan of this exact concept, I loved the K-drama Doom at Your Service, and the C-dramas When Destiny Brings You the Demon and Love Beyond the Grave, so it hurts to say that this book felt like a complete rip-off of those tropes. Of course, she couldn't have made last-minute changes since Love Beyond the Grave was released the same year, but the similarities to When Destiny Brings You the Demon are impossible to ignore. Maybe because I haven't watched many historical or costume C-dramas, I am finding these similarities suspicious. or maybe most C-dramas just share these tropes, making this feel like a copy-paste job to me.
To be fair, it’s not entirely the author’s fault. Maybe most of audience might not watch C-dramas at all, meaning these storylines would feel completely fresh to them. I guess I just wasn't the target audience for this book. However, this doesn't mean I’ll stop reading her work! She is still one of my favourite authors, and everyone is allowed a little slip-up.
The tropes that felt identical to the C-dramas (SPOILERS AHEAD): ||
When Destiny Brings You the Demon parallels: 1- Liao Tingyan is a literal slacker who just wants a quiet life but gets trapped into serving a dangerous grumpy master. Similarly, Rujia is an exiled, isolated god of healing who puts on a noble front but is actually desperately scheming to avoid her execution.
2- Sima Jiao is a feared grandmaster locked away, suffering from immense spiritual and physical pain that makes him cruel. Keran (the Death God) is likewise feared by all realms and suffers from a violent, excruciating, century-old curse.
3- Liao Tingyan is the only person who doesn't trigger Sima Jiao's rage, her passive energy physically calms his chaotic power. Meanwhile, Rujia is the only one who can actively soothe Keran's curse through her medical and divine touch.
4-Just like the Prince's plotline in the book, Sima Jiao also lived a second life in the mortal realm where he was weaker.
Love Beyond the Grave parallels:He Simu is someone whose parents were banished, mirroring Rujia, who also lived in the mortal realm during her childhood.
What I disliked about the book:
1-You have the literal God of Death as a character, and he feels entirely flat. Why experiment with a concept that powerful only to make it boring? I never felt like others feared him.
2-Why is everyone suddenly DYING? I didn't feel connected to any of the characters, so their deaths carried no weight.
3- I was 60% into the book and the story was still stuck on the initial blurb. Why wasn't the plot moving?
4- The entire plotline of making the prince pass a mortal exam was incredibly boring .
5- The ending was abrupt. ||