got suspended for a week and came back to an inbox that had turned into a dar-ul-ifta.. 7:55pm "is dar-e-nijaat haram or not just tell me straight".. 9:42pm "abu bakr is literally the best character ever I need answers".. 11:02pm "bhai i need a fatwa rn".. three different people, same drama, same emergency
i don't watch dramas.. so i did what any serious researcher does and asked my mother, who watches all of them.. she gave me the full plot in about four minutes without looking up from her phone and then asked why i wanted to know, which is a question i'm still dodging.. then i asked a friend, male, obviously, who pretended he'd "only seen a few episodes" and then explained episode 27 in detail
for the two people left in pakistan who haven't seen it: zaryab and zamil are engaged, rich, in love.. they go abroad, live together, get physical.. then zamil discovers deen, becomes very holy very fast, decides zaryab's "lifestyle" is beneath him, comes back and marries a clean girl.. zaryab asks abu bakar to marry her.. he finds out about her past, is furious, refuses the nikkah.. and then stays anyway
ok so now the question, and it's actually two questions
one.. is watching it haram
the story itself isn't the sin.. a story about a decent man being decent isn't haram, and Aisha رضي الله عنها watched the Abyssinians play with spears on Eid while the Prophet ﷺ stood in front of her so she could see, until she got bored (Bukhari 950).. watching a thing happen is not the problem, and nobody needs to pretend it is..
but that's not what's on your screen..
for the brothers, this is a straight no, and i'm not going to dress it up.. nobody on that show is covered.. hair open, hugged, held, crying into a man's shoulder, shot in a way that's built to make you feel it in your chest.. 24:30 doesn't say look less, it says reduce your looking, "tell the believing men to reduce some of their vision".. and the hadith jarir got, about the accidental glance, was answered with turn your eyes away, sahih muslim 2159a.. accidental.. the one you didn't plan and didn't pay for..
so we're not talking about a glance.. we're talking about 40 minutes, sitting down, on purpose, with a soundtrack, every night..
the "you have no right to the second" hadith (Abu Dawud 2149) is about the second look at someone who's dressed.. if the second look is already where it turns, what do we call tuning in at 8pm for the first look at someone who isn't..??
and before the "it's just acting, it's a story" comes, yeah, the story isn't the problem, i already said that.. the uncovered women are the problem, and they don't become covered because the plot is sad..
the girls watching are a different case and i'm not going to pretend otherwise.. a man's awrah isn't his face, so this specific trap is ours and not yours.. your version is lower down, and it's not about the eyes
two.. what the drama got right, and what everyone watching it is getting wrong
what it got right is zamil.. most accurate character in it.. a guy who sins with a girl, finds religion, then uses the religion to leave her.. the deen didn't make him do that, his guilt did, dressed up as taqwa.. Allah concealed his sin and the first thing he does is use hers against her.. "all my ummah will be forgiven except those who sin openly" (Bukhari 6069).. that's not a religious man, that's a man hiding behind religion.. if you grew up in pakistan you've met him
now the part that's wrong, and it's not the drama, it's the audience
everyone is calling abu bakar a saint for "accepting her despite her past".. despite.. as if he's doing charity, as if she's used goods and he's the exception.. her account was closed the day she made tawbah.. "except those who repent, believe and do righteous work, for them Allah will replace their evil deeds with good" (25:70).. not forgive, replace.. and "do not despair of the mercy of Allah, indeed Allah forgives all sins" (39:53), all, no footnote that says except girls.. so he isn't being generous, he's being normal.. it only looks heroic because the standard around him is so low
and let me say the other half before someone puts words in my mouth.. him accepting her was his choice, not his duty.. if he'd said no and walked away, he wouldn't have sinned either.. wanting a spouse who has no past is allowed, and it's not a small thing, it's the norm and it's the better ask, "good women are for good men and good men for good women" (24:26), nobody has to feel guilty for wanting clean.. but the man who does accept it, knowing what he knows and covering what Allah already covered, has stepped into something heavy and good, "the servant whose fault Allah conceals in this world, Allah conceals his faults on the Day of Resurrection" (Muslim 2590).. so two men, two halal roads, and only one of them gets called a saint by the internet.. the point i'm making isn't that you must accept, it's that he isn't a hero and she isn't damaged goods.. and if it's haram to shame her for it, it's also haram to shame him for wanting out of it
second wrong definition: "religious guy" meaning quiet, patient, tasbeeh, says inshallah a lot.. that's a vibe, and zamil had the vibe within a week.. the actual definition is how a man handles something that isn't his to judge.. abu bakar got angry, which is human.. then he didn't expose her, didn't punish her, didn't make her pay for the rest of her life for something Allah already dealt with.. that's the religious part, the rest is lighting
and third, the one nobody says: it took zina, abandonment and a breakdown for a man like abu bakar to show up in a story.. in real life your family will introduce you to five zamils before you meet one abu bakar, and they'll call the zamils "settled"
the wider thing, since i'm already in trouble with three people
most pakistani dramas aren't showing you the flaws, they're selling them.. the affair, the second wife, the 14 year old bride, the cousin obsession.. not a warning, it rates.. a warning ends with consequences, these end with a wedding song.. judge any drama by one question, does it end with the consequence or the wedding song
the cost nobody counts is time.. my mother is the most disciplined person I know and we've still had dinner at 10:30 because an episode "was at a critical point".. if a thing is regularly moving your salah, your meals, your sleep, your studies, that's not entertainment, it's fitnah with a theme song.. the drama doesn't have to be haram for the habit to be
and the part that actually worried me reading those dms: nobody asked if zina is ok, but a lot of people have quietly started finding zaryab's story relatable, romantic, almost normal.. "she made a mistake and found her abu bakar".. no.. she committed zina and found a man with enough deen not to destroy her for it.. different sentences.. the moment the sin becomes the plot you root for instead of the thing the plot survived, you've been moved and you didn't notice.. that's the part i'd call misleading, not the watching
so the ruling, since you asked for one
watching it: for the brothers, no, and "i only watch the story" doesn't fix it, the story comes wrapped in women you were told to look away from
the girls: the show isn't this trap for you, but abu bakar isn't real and you already know what the attachment thing is doing
liking him: he's not a person, it's a wishlist, and it's a good one.. you just found out you want patience and manners, not a bike and a jawline
the industry: does it end with the consequence or the wedding song
the actual lesson: don't marry the man who found deen last week and is already grading you with it.. don't call the decent one a hero for doing what Allah already asked of him.. and don't let a good character make a bad choice look normal
and my actual verdict, since i've been dancing around it for 40 paragraphs.. don't watch it at all..
not for the girls, who can watch a story and take a lesson from it.. for the brothers, because you told me it brought you closer to Allah and then couldn't survive two weeks without it.. because "hooked" was your own word.. because three of you needed a fatwa at 11pm about a tv serial and none of you asked me anything about your salah all year.. because you're being told to lower your gaze through 40 minutes of the exact thing you're told to look away from..
nothing in it will give you something you can't get from a seerah lecture, and the seerah lecture won't leave you with a crush and a bad sleep schedule..
so for the men, no, and i'm not your mufti so take it to one if you don't like mine.. but don't come to me with "it's bringing me closer to Allah" while your salah is still where it was before episode 1.. if it was really bringing you closer, that would be the thing moving, not your screen time..
now go study, all three of you