In September I saw a charge on my Paypal account I didn’t recognize. I literally had no idea what it was and thought my Paypal got hacked.
Couldn’t find anything in my inbox and didn’t remember ever signing up for it. It was a music-making service (Musecy) and I have two left feet and zero ability to compose shit.
I quickly terminated the subscription and my bank didn’t pay it.
Instead of letting it go, Paypal decided to pay for it on its own volition, leaving my account with a negative balance.
I contacted the merchant and asked for a refund, saying it was a fraudulent charge and I never signed up or received anything in exchange.
They never got back to me so I opened a case with Paypal saying exactly that (dispute reason- no goods or services received).
Since opening the case, I’ve had multiple conversations with Paypal explaining that I got scammed.
As it turns out – after LOTS of digging – Musecy engages in a scam where when you download a free program, they sign you up for a subscription. I did download a free program at some point which had a different name.
E.g. https://www.reddit.com/r/Musescore/comments/1h5pwt0/avoid_musescore_at_all_cost_read_the_internet/
https://www.trustpilot.com/review/musescore.com
While the case was ongoing, the merchant finally replied to me saying they would process a full refund if I closed the dispute. Paypal told me not to do it because 1) there was no guarantee that they would make good on their promise, 2) if i did close it, I wouldn’t be able to reopen it if they didn’t refund me.
They also assured me that it looked like all the facts were in my favor and I just needed to sit tight and wait for the refund.
Today, Paypal closed the case in Musecy’s favor saying that there was no “unauthorized activity” on my account.
I never claimed that there was unauthorized activity. I clearly said multiple times that I got scammed.
I literally don’t have an account with Musecy. There are no invoices. They never send me any marketing or activation emails or a renewal notice. There is no product.
It’s so maddening.
I am at a point where I am looking to close my account after 15+ years of using it.
I don’t want the negative balance to affect my credit score but I am not about to give money to some scammers.
What can I do?