r/PhilosophyBookClub • u/gentleholly220 • 10h ago
Reading Phaedo again brought me to tears
Phaedo was among the first Platonic dialogues I came across, and I really liked it back then. But after spending a lot of time in Plato's world, returning to Phaedo feels quite different. The affection and sorrow Plato has for his teacher really come through.
One of the most easily missed, and to me deeply sad, moments in Phaedo is a brief line early on where Phaedo notes that Plato was sick and so wasn't there when Socrates died. You can almost feel the pain and regret Plato carries in having to pass the story along through someone else.
That, and Socrates' last reply to Crito when asked what should be done with his body. "Why should I care? It's not me." Maybe this is Plato consoling himself; that although he missed the end of the first act, he can still carry on with the show. Not that I doubt Socrates could or would have actually said this, it's just something one might read into it. Overall just a very sorrowful yet consoling piece.