r/PhysicsStudents • • Aug 05 '20

Meta Homework Help Etiquette (HHE)

161 Upvotes

Greetings budding physicists!

One of the things that makes this subreddit helpful to students is the communities ability to band together and help users with physics questions and homework they may be stuck on. In light of this, I have implemented an overhaul to the HW Help post guidelines that I like to call Homework Help Etiquette (HHE). See below for:

  • HHE for Helpees
  • HHE for Helpers

HHE for Helpees

  1. Format your titles as follows: [Course HW is From] Question about HW.
  2. Post clear pictures of the problem in question.
  3. Talk us through your 1st attempt so we know what you've tried, either in the post title or as a comment.
  4. Don't use users here to cheat on quizzes, tests, etc.

Good Example

HHE for Helpers

  1. If there are no signs of a 1st attempt, refrain from replying. This is to avoid lazy HW Help posts.
  2. Don't give out answers. That will hurt them in the long run. Gently guide them onto the right path.
  3. Report posts that seem sketchy or don't follow etiquette to Rule 1, or simply mention HHE.

Thank you all! Happy physics-ing.

u/Vertigalactic


r/PhysicsStudents • • 4h ago

Need Advice What book do i follow for electromagnetism?

4 Upvotes

I am from India, i have qualified for the Inpho exam most likely, I am stuck between Griffith and purcell to follow for electromagnetism, I have only done EM from Halliday resnick krane 5th ed, do i go with purcell or griffith or some other book?


r/PhysicsStudents • • 5h ago

Need Advice Should I study in physics for undergrad or should I choose a different major?

2 Upvotes

So, during my high school years, I've found out that I love physics and knowing how the nature works on fundamental levels. Sometimes I enjoyed going a bit deeper when learning physics concepts compared to what my academic curriculum offers. Academically, I've done well in physics and mathematics compared to other subjects, though I never explored beyond academic learning for mathematics. I've been also interested in astronomy since I was a kid but that's irrelevant in deciding what subject I should study in, I think. Being born in a 3rd world country, my family wants me to get an engineering/CS degree as it seems like a more viable option to sustain myself financially. But I think I'm more interested in the theoretical part than application of physics. I've also been interested in CS slightly when I was in middle school, but I got less interested in it as I started learning more physics. My family isn't rich either so I'm more likely to carry majority of my study costs in future.

I'll apply to some unis, both home and abrod, soon. But at this moment I'm really confused about what subject should I opt for, should I listen to my gut and choose physics or should I go for CS or some engineering degree (I've shortlisted electrical engineering and mechanical engineering there as they cover a good chunk of physics compared to other engineering degrees, except for engineering physics, which isn't offered in any unis in my country from what I found)?


r/PhysicsStudents • • 9h ago

HW Help [Experimental Physics I] Question about Homework

Post image
1 Upvotes

Translation: Calculate a first-order taylor-approximation of the gravitational acceleration for small heights h (relative to earth's surface). Use this approximation to find the relative change in gravitational acceleration (between h=0 and h=160km).

We are supposed to view earth as a ball with radius R and homogeneous density \rho, as well as total mass M.

I'm just completely confused, because in lecture the professor explicitly stated, that the potential outside a homogeneous ball with total mass M is the same as the one of a point mass M. This should mean that the force in question is just Newton's Law of gravity, but that would make a taylor-approximation completely redundant (because we then would know g = GM/r^2 where r ist the distance from the center, i.e r=h+R)

So what am I missing here?


r/PhysicsStudents • • 17h ago

Update Physics problem of the day - RAMANUJAN CLUB

Post image
3 Upvotes

r/PhysicsStudents • • 18m ago

Meta Gravity app simulator. Ai instructions for build. Copy paste into Ai ask them to follow instructions.

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/PhysicsStudents • • 1d ago

Need Advice Math exercise book recommendations

3 Upvotes

hi! i’m a second year physics student and i’ve been wanting to do some extra calculations before bed. i’ve always tried to journal, but i never got immersed in it. sooo i thought maybe doing some integrals, complex number calculations or anything really, would be just the thing i’m looking for. so please give me ur recommendations for some exercise books, that wouldn’t be too simple, but also not too difficult where i would go to bed an hour later than planned. thank you!


r/PhysicsStudents • • 20h ago

Need Advice Need help for finding lecture playlist for fundamentals of physics(Halliday, Resnick and Walker)

1 Upvotes

Can someone provide me a playlist? My exams are knocking at the door . That's why I am requesting.


r/PhysicsStudents • • 20h ago

Need Advice Marine vet starting school for a career in space science and instrumentation. Looking for feedback on my plan from people in the field

1 Upvotes

I'm 25, recently separated from the Marine Corps (CBRN defense specialist), and I start community college near Chicago in January before transferring to a 4-year university. I'll be a full-time student.
Where I'm starting: essentially from scratch. My work experience doesn't carry over academically, and math is my biggest challenge, so I'm rebuilding it now ahead of my placement test. What I do have is a genuine passion for science, which keeps me motivated. I learn best by asking questions, working through examples until I understand the why, then practicing until it sticks, and I plan to use tutoring regularly.
Goal: a career studying space. I want to work in research labs with data from space telescopes and satellites, contribute to theory, and help develop the instruments behind missions like Hubble and JWST. I also want degrees that open many doors, not just one narrow path.
Plan:

  • Baseline: BS in astrophysics.
  • If my VA Vocational Rehab (VR&E) application is approved: expand to a dual BS in astrophysics and electrical engineering. I see the science and the engineering as complementary, and I want the hands-on skills to build instruments, not just use them.
  • Computer science throughout: as many CS courses as my schedule allows, plus independent coursework in the summers. I see it as essential to modern instrumentation and as a solid fallback career path.
  • Humanities: philosophy and poetry.
  • Long-term: a PhD in astrophysics with an instrumentation focus.

Funding:

  • I have 36 months of Post-9/11 GI Bill.
  • If VR&E is approved and I use it first, it can fund up to roughly 48 months without drawing down my GI Bill. That makes the dual degree realistic.
  • If VR&E isn't approved, the GI Bill covers about four years, and I'd cover anything beyond that with savings or student loans before applying to PhD programs.

What I'd value from people working in astronomy, astrophysics, aerospace or instrumentation:

  1. What would you recommend adding, changing or cutting to make me as competitive as possible for PhD programs and for lab or research positions?
  2. Which skills or experiences are actually in demand in your field, and which matter less than students tend to think?
  3. Any related advice at all to help achieve my interest?

Thanks in advance. I'd appreciate any honest feedback.


r/PhysicsStudents • • 20h ago

Off Topic I need help with some Physics topics

0 Upvotes

Hey guys I have an entrance exam in about 20 days and I really need to get prepared for it. Can anyone help me with these topics? I speak english arabic and Russian, though my Russian isn't good enough.

The topics:

MECHANICS

Motion in one dimension. Displacement, velocity, acceleration, motion diagram, freely falling objects.

Vectors and two dimensional motion. Displacement, velocity, acceleration in two dimensions.

The laws of motion. Forces, Newton's first, second and third law. Forces of friction.

Energy. Work. Power. Kinetic energy work energy theorem. Systems and energy conservation. Kinetic, gravitational potential and spring potential energy.

Momentum and collision, conservation of momentum.

Rotational motion and the law of gravity.

Rotational equilibrium and rotational dynamics. Torque and the conditions for equilibrium.

Solids and fluids. States of matter. Density and pressure. Archimedes principle.

THERMODYNAMICS

Temperature and the Zeroth law of thermodynamics. The kinetic theory of gases. Thermal expansion of solids and liquids.

Energy in thermal processes. Heat and internal energy, specific heat. The laws of thermodynamics. Entropy.

VIBRATIONS AND WAVES

Hooke's law. Elastic potential energy. Simple harmonic motion. Motion of a pendulum.

Waves and interference of waves. Frequency, amplitude and wavelength.

Sound. Characteristics of sound waves. Doppler effect.

ELECTRICITY AND MAGNETISM

Electric forces and electric fields. Electric charges. Insulators and conductors. Coulomb's law.

Electrical energy and capacitance. The parallel plate capacitor.

Current and resistance. Ohm's law. Temperature variation of resistance.

Direct current circuits. Resistors in parallel and series. Kirchoff's laws. RC circuits.

Magnetism. Magnetic fields. Motion of charged particles in magnetic field.

Induced voltage and inductances. Faraday's law of induction.

Alternating current. Resistors and capacitors in AC circuits.

LIGHT AND OPTICS

The nature of light. Reflection, refraction. Total internal reflection.

Polarization of light waves.

Mirrors and lenses. Image formation of flat mirror and thin lenses.

MODERN PHYSICS

The speed of light.

Einstein's principle of relativity.

Atomic spectra, the exclusion principle and the periodic table.

Binding energy, radioactivity.

Nuclear fusion and fission.

Elementary particles and fundamental forces.


r/PhysicsStudents • • 1d ago

Update Why is the change in momentum 20 and not 4 when a ball bounces back?

Post image
6 Upvotes

r/PhysicsStudents • • 2d ago

Need Advice 18y, going to university this fall deeply divided btwn taking undergrad physics and engineering

18 Upvotes

As I said I wanna do a undergrad in physics but I am scared whether I’ll find it different from wut I wanted and I won’t like it ,and so I wonder whether I should take engineering cuz I’ve had hands on experience in mechanical engineering (I’ve built a go-kart with my friends for my science exhibition) and I do like it…
Anyone doing physics undergrad do u have any opinion… anybody??


r/PhysicsStudents • • 1d ago

Need Advice Struggling in AP Physics 1 Help

2 Upvotes

Hello!

I recently took a physics test for AP Physics 1, and I scored really bad (4/20) despite studying several hours. I watched the videos and understood every concept, but when the test happened I froze and was not able to approach any of the problems especially in a short time.

Anyone have any advice to help with this, I hope to be an engineer one day and I'm worried I might not be able to handle it.


r/PhysicsStudents • • 1d ago

Update Daily problems in Physics: Ramanujan Club

Post image
1 Upvotes

r/PhysicsStudents • • 2d ago

Rant/Vent ai-induced purpose crisis rant

9 Upvotes

For me a large part of doing physics before AI came into the picture in the way that it did this year was knowing that not only was I doing something that I love, but also knowing that if I get to do research, a project or an assignment, it will be mine and only mine, and that getting to the forefront of knowledge on a topic meant that you could contribute to the knowledge base of humanity in the most efficient way possible. That there was a purpose behind what I was doing beyond the enjoyment of it. Of course this component remains to some extent, but it's vastly weakened by the uncertainty of not knowing the dynamic that we'll be left with in academia when the dust settles. Will physics research be relegated to some kind of AI-milking, trying to reach every last drop of new knowledge that can be discovered out of it? I say AI came into the picture this year because it's the year in which I think we get to say that AI is definitely and permanently better than all humans in known physics and mathematics. You're welcome to argue against this, of course. Anyway, the point is that since I came back to university from the summer vacation I've felt that every written assignment or task that had to be carried out at home was absolutely futile. It's as clear as day virtually everyone across all steps of academia is using AI models for most tasks, if not to have it carry out the assignment, to check their results against it, which in my opinion is the best possible scenario to still get some learning out of AI. It's not inherently bad that we get assignments to do at home, in fact I think it's perfectly necessary, but I just believe that it doesn't make sense anymore to grade students based on the assignments if the objective is to test their knowledge. Of course the professors aren't using AI any less, and assignments also feel AI-written, with different notation than that used in class and questions that honestly just feel like the kind of questions you get when you ask AI to test you on something you're learning. What are we playing? It feels like student and professor are just intermediaries for different instances of AI generating assignments, completing them and grading them. And of course, if you get a bit rebelious and try to complete an entire assignment without AI, you're at a disadvantage, like it or not, because you shouldn't doubt that your classmates are going to turn in perfect work and hence the bar is systematically raised. Even then, the professor will still suspect your work is AI-generated because that's just the state of the matter. Just my take.


r/PhysicsStudents • • 2d ago

Need Advice I'm going to major On physics next yearrr 🥹

6 Upvotes

hi im on high school and since I was in elementary school till now I love physics and college is next year so I decided I will major in physics, I will try to be the best student ever because THIS WILL BE THE BEST DECISION IVE EVER MADEEEEEEE🥹🥹🥹🥹🥹 anyways I need advice


r/PhysicsStudents • • 2d ago

Need Advice how shall i approach physics !!!!!!!!!!!

3 Upvotes

I am 18 m and i am always been curious about physics and i do want to pursue it in future and i dont know what approach shall i take for it and the other thing is im being forced to become a doctor due to certain family reasons so is there any way i can pursue physics tooo ??? and if so what shall my approach be !!


r/PhysicsStudents • • 2d ago

Need Advice Does anyone have Gate Physics study material from coachings like Fiziks or Career endeavour ?

1 Upvotes

Or have any free telegram channel link for physics study material ?


r/PhysicsStudents • • 2d ago

Need Advice first time ever i imagined suicide, suicidal ideation is going crazy right now

4 Upvotes

i gave up my career in finance to study physics. studying physics is very hard but i manage. im just so afraid of dropping out because at my university we drop out if we fail a course twice. i had around 130k in savings but i gambled 40k away with trading. now i only have 90k left. about to move in with my father after living 5-6 years alone. im almost 30 year old. for the first time im feeling very suicidal now. the ideation is going crazy. how can i possible come back from this mental state. i have to study non stop and i cant work right now. i dont have time to take care if my mental health either


r/PhysicsStudents • • 2d ago

Need Advice Physics Undergrad to Engineering Pathway?

4 Upvotes

Career Advice

Ok so currently I’m at university of Waterloo for an undergrad degree of honours physics and astronomy(In first year). And I just recently realized that I may want a career in engineering instead. Would it be recommended that I finish my undergrad degree here(utilize Waterloo coop) and then do a masters in engineering(mechanical or aerospace) or should I transfer to a undergrad engineering program(honestly my grads this term haven’t been good I’ve been struggling mentally for a while now and when I finally feel like I get something under control another thing pops up). Any thoughts and please be brutally honest don’t give me false hope I feel like I’m falling behind and screwing up my future.


r/PhysicsStudents • • 3d ago

Need Advice 29yo, wanting to go to college for physics, but scared

27 Upvotes

Well, basically what the title says. I went to college 10 years ago to sudy physics but had to dropout and get a job. Been working dead end jobs since, tried to get into software but never managed to get it right and lost all love for the field with the AI boom.

I know physics and math is where my heart really is, but at this age, it feels like a bad idea to start, giving the situation with the AI thing too. I'm not really interested in academia, but i would love to work in the private sector utilizing math and/or physics knowledge.

I'm mostly looking for inspiration from other people that maybe went through something similar. This feels like a bad idea but i don't really have nothing else i want to do with my life, so i'm trying to build up the courage.


r/PhysicsStudents • • 2d ago

Need Advice What do I do if I realized that research isn't for me?

4 Upvotes

Hello fellow physics students.

I am a Canadian student in my third year (out of 5 years) studying materials and nanoscience. it combines chemistry, physics and materials science. Unfortunately unlike most materials science programs, mine is a science degree, NOT an engineering degree.

Majority of people in my program plan to attend graduate school doing at least a masters. Some are definitely able to land jobs before graduating but it isn't nearly as common as grad school. I don't mind doing more school after undergrad, its that my ADHD (diagnosed) is so severe that I don't think I have it in me to complete a thesis (whether it be masters or PhD). My reading comprehension is very poor to where i struggle to get past the abstract of a research paper.

Since Im already in my third year, I feel like Im in some sunk cost fallacy with my degree. I already checked and I know that if I switch majors I will have to restart back to first year which I really don't want to do. I have so much anxiety about my future and I've just been spiralling every single day going on reddit, googling, searching for alternative career plans and pivots I could make without restarting undergrad entirely. I don't have the confidence in myself to be able to land a job with just a science bachelors even if I know other people with my degree have done it before so I feel the need to think of all these backup plans. Its all I worry about.

Since I can't do a thesis masters and I don't want to switch, one thing I thought of was potentially doing a non-thesis masters in something thats slightly adjacent to my degree thats more industry applicable. Even though nanoscience is slightly different to physics, Ive heard of physics bachelors grads doing a masters in: data science, applied mathematics, statistics or finances. Are these viable pathways coming from a materials/nanoscience background? Has anyone else with a similar BSc made a pivot like this into industry? Any advice or insight would be really appreciated. Thanks and have a great day.


r/PhysicsStudents • • 2d ago

Update Ramanujan Club: Daily Problems in Physics

Post image
2 Upvotes

r/PhysicsStudents • • 3d ago

Off Topic Do you guys actually feel as though you are learning more about the universe?

7 Upvotes

People keep saying physics is just a model for predictions. So is it not actually helping us learn about the universe? are they related somehow?