A thought experiment that keeps nagging at me: what if every physical state has exactly one unit of phase to spend, and it can only spend it in two ways?
In this picture, called the Law of Phase-Budget Conservation, a state splits its fixed budget between internal cycling, which we experience as aging, and relational retuning, which we experience as motion. The split obeys a simple unit-circle rule: internal squared plus (v/c) squared equals one.
That is why nothing can spend 120 percent of its budget. Push more into motion and less remains for aging, so a fast-moving clock ticks more slowly. It is not that time itself is being stretched by a mysterious force; it is arithmetic on a circle. The speed limit c is simply the point where all of the budget is spent on motion and none is left for aging.
A photon is the extreme case. It spends 100 percent on motion and zero on aging, so its clock is frozen. Light leaving a distant galaxy arrives unaged, not because it cheated time, but because it never had any budget left to age with.
Think of a fixed monthly budget split between rent and travel. Spend more on travel and the rent money shrinks by exactly that amount. There is no extra pot to draw from.
Two questions for this community: does this unit-circle framing add anything to the standard derivation of time dilation, or is it just a neat restatement? And if c is a budget constraint rather than a speed limit imposed from outside, what would falsify that view?
This idea is explored in Zero-Metric Phase Theory, available on Google Play Books.
Here is an idea from the second law in my book that I keep turning over: distance may not be a gap that things sit in. It may be a measure of how well two things are in phase with each other.
The proposal is simple. Coupling between two systems follows cos squared of their phase offset. At 0 degrees they are in full contact. At 45 degrees the coupling is half. At 90 degrees it is zero, so the other system behaves as if it were infinitely far away, even though nothing has moved. That is what a causal horizon could be: not a wall in space, but a phase relationship that has gone silent.
Think of two polarized sunglasses. Aligned, light pours through. Tilt one by 45 degrees and about half gets through. Turn it to 90 degrees and the view goes pitch black, even though the lenses are still touching. That is Malus's law, and the claim is that distance works the same way.
The wider picture spreads that displacement across many harmonic channels, each tilted only a tiny fraction of a degree, so flat three-dimensional space can build up across light-years without anything crowding toward 90 degrees. And space is three-dimensional, the book argues, because two-component spinors have exactly three rotation generators.
What would convince you this is more than a neat analogy? If closeness is really interaction strength, what exactly is a horizon? And why three dimensions, rather than two or eleven?
Disclosure: I am the author of Zero-Metric Phase Theory: How Space, Time, Matter, and Gravity Emerge from a Dimensionless Universe by Tim Tian, available on Google Play Books.
Quick disclaimer first, especially for this subreddit:
I am not claiming to have solved the black hole information problem. I am trying to re-express the standard paradox in a very explicit, “tension-based” coordinate system that is easy to audit, simulate, and (in principle) hand to a machine for consistency checking.
The goal is a clean effective-layer language, not a new fundamental theory of quantum gravity.
1. Standard setup, then a reparameterization
Take the usual semiclassical picture: a black hole formed from a pure state, coupled to an environment, evaporates through Hawking radiation. We want unitarity for the global state, but standard QFT on a fixed background gives radiation that looks thermal, so information seems lost.
Very schematically, we have three coarse-grained regions and Hilbert spaces
H_rad(t) : radiation outside at time t (including any bath we decide to keep)
The usual paradox is about incompatible entanglement requirements on these pieces if we insist on:
local QFT in a smooth neighborhood of the horizon
a semiclassical outside geometry for most of the evaporation
a final pure state on H_rad(t_final)
What I am trying to do is define a tension functional that makes those incompatibilities explicit, instead of keeping them as verbal slogans.
2. Tension as a mismatch between three descriptions
Very roughly, for each time t I try to track three objects:
(1) A “unitarity-compatible” entropy profile S_unitary(t; cut) coming from a toy model that enforces global purity (e.g. a random-unitary evaporation model with a chosen cut between “inside” and “outside”).
(2) A “semiclassical” entropy profile S_semi(t; cut) coming from local QFT near the horizon plus Hawking’s calculation, with whatever coarse-graining and greybody factors one wants to keep.
(3) A “geometric” entropy proxy S_geo(t; cut) that only uses geometric data (area of a surface, extrinsic curvature, etc.), in the spirit of Bekenstein–Hawking or island formula inputs.
Then define a dimensionless tension coordinate
T(t; cut) = f( S_unitary, S_semi, S_geo )
for some normalized function f that is:
0 if all three profiles are mutually compatible within chosen tolerances
close to 1 if at least one pair is in sharp conflict (e.g. Page-curve expectations vs strictly thermal radiation)
The concrete version I am currently experimenting with is a triple mismatch score of the form
using a fixed overlap notion (for example, a normalized L2 distance over a time window, or a discrete set of checkpoints in the evaporation).
This is deliberately “low tech” and lives entirely at the effective layer. All microscopic details are buried in how you choose the three input profiles. The value of T is not a new prediction, it is a bookkeeping device that says:
given these three assumptions about entropy flow, where exactly do they stop being compatible?
3. Why bother with such a functional?
The practical reasons are:
It forces you to write down all assumptions that go into each profile S_unitary, S_semi, S_geo instead of vaguely saying “semi-classical” or “unitary”.
It gives you something you can actually simulate in toy models (random unitary circuits, simple evaporation chains, etc.) and compare against Page curve–like expectations.
It is simple enough to encode in text + small bits of code, so one can let a language model or proof assistant check internal consistency and explore parameter ranges, without pretending it knows quantum gravity.
In other words, the “tension-based” language is meant to be a coordinate choice on the space of effective descriptions, not a claim about what the true microphysics is.
4. Concrete questions for this subreddit
This is where I would really appreciate criticism from people who think about black holes more seriously than I do.
Is this “three profiles + tension functional” framing obviously misguided?For example, does it ignore a standard move in the modern literature (islands, replica wormholes, state-dependence, ER=EPR, etc.) that already kills the paradox in a way that makes such a functional redundant or meaningless?
If you had to instantiate this in a toy model you actually respect, what would you pick?
Page-style random unitary evaporation models?
Simple holographic toy models?
Something like SYK or random tensor networks?
The requirement is that we can compute or at least approximate S_unitary, S_semi, and S_geo in some controlled regime.
Are there known “no-go” results for this kind of tension functional?I am specifically worried about cases where:
the distinction between H_in and H_hor is too gauge / slicing dependent to make any coarse-grained functional well-defined, or
islands / entanglement wedge reconstruction make the naive split into H_in ⊕ H_rad(t) too misleading to be useful.
From your perspective, is there any value in having such a functional as a teaching / diagnostic tool, even if it never touches real quantum gravity?For example, in pedagogy around the information problem, would a “tension plot” that shows when different assumptions become incompatible be a useful picture, or just another layer of confusion?
If this framing is fundamentally broken, I would really prefer to know exactly where. Pointers to existing approaches that already do something similar (or prove it cannot be done in a clean way) would be very welcome.
For anyone curious about the broader context: this is Q040 in a larger list of 131 “S-class” problems that I am trying to encode in a tension-based, machine-checkable way.
Full notes for Q040 (black hole information problem) are here: