Hey everyone!
I'm looking for some help with a rather frustrating problem in my freshwater aquarium. I've been dealing with persistent white, fog-like cloudy water for months, and I can't seem to figure out what's causing it.
First, some background, because I think it's important to understand what happened.
The aquarium used to be a completely healthy, self-sustaining ecosystem.
For over a year, I had a natural, low-maintenance aquarium inspired by the Father Fish approach. It had a natural substrate, plants, rocks, leaves, microorganisms, shrimp, snails and fish.
Everything was doing great. The plants were growing and spreading on their own, the shrimp and fish were healthy, and there was an entire little ecosystem developing inside the tank.
I barely had to intervene. I wasn't constantly cleaning the aquarium, adjusting things or adding products. I mostly just let nature do its thing, and the aquarium maintained itself surprisingly well.
Then I decided to start over.
I wanted a completely different layout, so I decided to renovate the aquarium almost from scratch:
Changed the sand and redesigned the layout.
Rearranged the rocks and decorations.
Kept some of the original substrate underneath the new sand.
Added natural river water.
Reintroduced the livestock, including over 100 freshwater shrimp.
Unfortunately, after this renovation, the water became extremely cloudy.
The current situation:
Approximately 15 gallons.
Natural sand substrate, rocks and leaves.
Aquarium filter running 24/7.
Air stone running 24/7.
Standard white LED lighting.
Freshwater shrimp and one Cobitis loach.
The water has a very distinct white/milky appearance, almost like smoke or fog suspended throughout the aquarium. It's been like this for months, with practically no improvement.
A few shrimp died shortly after being transferred, but the remaining shrimp have been healthy and active. The loach also seems perfectly fine.
I've performed partial water changes and cleaned the filter, but the cloudiness persists. I also washed the filter sponges under tap water at one point, which I now realise might have affected the beneficial bacteria.
One particularly interesting observation:
When I leave the aquarium lights OFF, the white cloudiness gradually starts to decrease over several days. It never completely disappears, though.
When I turn the lights back ON, the cloudiness seems to become more intense again.
The water isn't visibly green. It's white, almost like a bacterial bloom, but I'm not sure.
What I'm trying to figure out:
Could this be:
A persistent bacterial bloom caused by disturbing the original substrate and ecosystem?
Free-floating microorganisms or microalgae?
Extremely fine organic or mineral particles?
Something related to the introduction of natural river water?
One important thing about my approach to fishkeeping:
I'm really not a fan of using chemical products, water clarifiers, algaecides or constantly adding bottled bacteria and other treatments.
My goal is to maintain a completely natural aquarium, where microorganisms, plants, bacteria and the animals establish their own balance.
The previous version of this aquarium worked beautifully for over a year without practically any intervention, so I'd really like to understand what went wrong and restore that natural balance.
I'm not necessarily looking for a quick fix. I'd much rather understand the underlying cause and find a natural, long-term solution.
Has anyone experienced something similar after restarting an established natural aquarium?
I'd especially appreciate advice from people experienced with natural, low-tech or self-sustaining aquarium ecosystems.
Thanks in advance!