So I just finished playing this ROM hack which I stumbled across on twitter. If I'm honest it left me with mixed feelings
TLDR: it does have some issues and is unpolished but as a fully playable game from start to finish and as a port of a GBA game with it's full story, maps, scripted events, post game and mechanics into the NDS black 2 engine, it is extremely impressive and it makes me wonder about the future of ROM hacks and fan projects.
Here's the conclusion of my review from my video for anyone who is short on time:
Honestly, I've found this a surprisingly difficult game to review.
And I don't say that lightly.
On one hand, Pokémon Emerald has an incredibly special place in my heart.
It's the first Pokémon game I ever owned, and seeing Hoenn recreated in a Nintendo DS engine is something I've wanted for years.
This project gave me the opportunity to revisit that adventure with updated graphics, modern quality-of-life features and the Generation 5 battle engine.
And I genuinely enjoyed playing it.
But on the other hand, I can't ignore the problems.
The mapping is inconsistent, the environmental textures can look unfinished, and some of the visual issues detract from moments that should otherwise be spectacular.
I also think there's room to improve the level balancing, expand the use of newer Pokémon and polish some of the recreated locations and events.
So where does that leave us?
Well, despite everything I've said, I still consider Pokémon Emerald NDS something of a masterpiece.
A flawed masterpiece, certainly.
But a masterpiece nonetheless.
And I want to explain exactly what I mean by that.
I'm not saying this is one of the most polished Pokémon ROM hacks I've ever played.
It absolutely isn't.
We've been spoiled over the years by some incredibly polished fan games and ROM hacks, and judged purely on presentation, this project still has a long way to go.
But putting my opinion to one side, there's definitely something to reflect on and appreciate with what has been accomplished here.
This is a playable recreation of Pokémon Emerald, from beginning to end, built using the Black 2 and White 2 engine.
It includes the main story, the scripted events, the underwater exploration, the optional activities, the postgame content, the Battle Frontier, and so many of the quirky little mechanics that made the original 2004 Game Boy Advance game special.
And all of that exists in a custom recreation of Hoenn, with updated visuals, soundtrack options and modern gameplay conveniences.
When I consider the sheer scale of that achievement, particularly knowing how difficult DS ROM hacking can be, I find it genuinely remarkable.
Of course, my nostalgia plays a part in how much I enjoyed the experience.
I don't think there's any point pretending otherwise.
But even allowing for that, I think the work that has gone into this project deserves recognition.
And that's why I'm comfortable calling it a flawed masterpiece.
I would love to hear what you think of this game and also I'd be interested to hear your feedback on my reviews and whether they resonate with you or not