r/PokemonRomhackDev • • 4d ago

Discussion Weekly HDQ Thread (Help, Discussion, Questions)

4 Upvotes

Hello! Welcome to the Weekly Discussion Thread. This is the place where you can:

  • Ask help for quick questions
  • Discuss ideas you have for your ROMhacks
  • Ask quick questions that you feel don't warrant a post.

Make sure to browse our sub resources:

Sub Wiki: https://www.reddit.com/r/PokemonRomhackDev/wiki/index/

How to ask a question: https://github.com/pret/pokeemerald/wiki/Getting-Help-with-the-Decomps


r/PokemonRomhackDev • • Oct 09 '26

Discussion Romhacking, AI/LLM use, and Rule 7

39 Upvotes

Hello, everyone. This is Ruby, and I wanted to make this post as a discussion board for people to, well, discuss. Over the past two weeks, we've been reckoning a lot more with the presence of AI in our space, and if you've been on other social media, likely saw it in other modding communities as well.

This post will mostly be a diagnosis; it will list down the status of tools across every generation, and see what the reach of AI in our toolchains actually is. This will focus on the bases themselves, as extending it to every tool will take my forever. There will be two exceptions, which I hope will make sense once you see them.

ToolGenerationStatus
pokered, pokeyellowGeneration INo explicit policy. Any contribution likely requires meeting the project's quality standards.
pokecrystalGeneration IINo explicit policy. Any contribution likely requires meeting the project's quality standards.
pokeemerald, pokefireredGeneration IIIDoes not explicitly disallow AI assisted or generated contributions. Contributions are merged in at maintainer discretion, provided it meets quality standards of the repository.
pmd-redGeneration IIINo explicit policy. Any contribution requires meeting the project's quality standards.
pinball-rsGeneration IIIAllows AI assisted or generated contributions, provided it is disclosed. All contributions are sent through a stringent review process in order to meet quality standards of the project. The project also has a usage disclaimer here.
HexManiacAdvanceGeneration IIIAllows AI assisted or generated contributions, provided it is disclosed. All contributions are sent through a stringent review process in order to meet quality standards of the project.
pokeemerald-expansionGeneration IIILLM assisted or generated contributions are disallowed. Read this for their full policy.
pokeplatinumGeneration IVAI generated contributions are disallowed. AI assistance is discouraged.
hg-engineGeneration IVAllows AI assisted or generated contributions, provided it is disclosed. All contributions are sent through a stringent review process in order to meet quality standards of the project.
DSPREGeneration IVDevelopment is assisted with agentic engineering. All contributions are sent through a stringent review process in order to meet quality standards of the project.
pokeblackGeneration VRecently started. Disallows AI generated contributions as a whole.
Frost's Gen 5 EditorGeneration VOriginally created with assistance from AI; has since abstained from its use since.
PokewebGeneration VMade with no AI assistance.
Pokeweb-ServerlessGeneration VPorted from original Pokeweb project with the assistance of agentic engineering
HackdexCross-genOriginally developed with Cursor. While the original pledge was to keep development AI free, after some life circumstances of its developer, development assistance with Cursor, and later instead with Codex+Claude, resumed.

Given this spread, the overall opinion is the same: while not explicitly disallowed, contributions in projects must meet a quality threshold before they are merged in. There are a few standouts still, with some outright rejecting and disapproving use of AI in its development process. This list also doesn't delve into other external tools also used in development, such as for music, scripting, mapping, and so on.

As a tool in itself, AI has progressed much in its skills in programming that it can create competent code that can be improved by the human using it, or explain code enough to a new programmer. What this is means is, unlike other creative spaces, AI has found enough of a niche for itself in a programming pipeline to be useful.

Assistance from AI in programming still has its downsides of course, both pragmatic and ontological. Pragmatic, as there can be serious atrophy/stunting of learning should a developer rely on it, and ontological, as it was built upon scraped knowledge and sustained at the expense of marginalized communities and the Global South.

What does this mean for the community at large? Well, it's hard to say, because the level above it (the wider tech space) has not itself settled on where AI sits in the long term. It has widespread use, with each individual programmer having varying uses and engagements with the tool for a multitude of reasons, from personal use to hitting token use objectives set by management. For the most part, the bases at least are still overwhelmingly made with human effort. Most of the effort to create them came before the proliferation of AI, and their continued maintenance are still mostly made with human effort.

Lastly, there are also efforts such as the friend-safari, who are seeking to create a toolchain free of AI, to the best of its contributors abilities.

This is where I share my own opinion, which will also guide the extended description for Rule 7.

Rule 7's description will be thus:

> Creations and projects made with overwhelming AI assistance and generation will not be tolerated. Any projects built off of existing bases as of 10/10/26 will be allowed on the site.

For me, the most pragmatic decision would be to strike down anything egregious, and anything grey will be up to my discretion. Given the state of the romhacking toolchain now, it'd be the death of the subreddit to forbid anything with any AI in it's toolchain. As with any policy, this will be subject to change according to the needs of the community at large. I put the date there, should any forks or rombases with a gigantic amount of AI in its decompilation pop up (as it has in other communities).

And for anyone that may be looking for advice, for some reason, all I can give is this: do what you think, at the end of the day, feels right. Curate and contribute to projects that you feel align best with what you believe in, and do your best to foment cultures that create the kinds of projects you want to see.

As Gen 3 hacker, I'll personally try my best to support both friend-safari and Expansion myself. You do what you feel is right.

EDIT: This post has been periodically edited to reflect corrections given by various developers about the scope of AI in their projects.


r/PokemonRomhackDev • • 23h ago Bravo

pokeemerald-expansion has now banned all LLM assisted contributions going forward

Post image
482 Upvotes

Text:

The pokeemerald-expansion maintainers have updated their policy around LLM (AI) usage within the respository. The full policy and our rationale behind it can be read here. If you would like to give feedback, a form can be found within the rationale. This update will be reflected in the issue template, PR template, and CONTRIBUTING.md shortly.

too long didn't read

  • All LLM usage is banned going forward.
  • Currently open contributions will not be subject to this rule.
  • If a maintainer believes a contribution violates this policy, it will be closed.
  • Repeat violators of this policy will be banned.

r/PokemonRomhackDev • • 1d ago

Help [GEN 3][DECOMP] Thoughts on a side project

1 Upvotes

I've recently started making an evangelion mod for Pokémon emerald that I hope can add the angels as Pokémon and all the main characters as npcs in a fully explorable nerv hq. I'm working on sachiel first and I was wondering if there was any references I could add for the shiny and if not a reference then just a cool colour scheme. What sort of thing would be fun for the player to work towards finding sachiel?, I'm thinking an exploration task where you find clues to unlock sachiels chamber. Any input helps, thanks!


r/PokemonRomhackDev • • 1d ago

Discussion Hackdex Questions

2 Upvotes

Hello, I've some questions regarding Hackdex. I noticed in recent days, couple of romhacks being disappeared from the website... If anyone from Hackdex staff in here, please tell me what could be the reason?

Also, an another request if Hackdex could provide their own public Discord server or another exclusive subreddits, where we can discuss about ROM hacks, achievements, recommendation and several things, it'll be really really amazing.

I apologise if I posted something irrelevant in here, first time in ROM hacking community and English is not my first language. Thank you for understanding.


r/PokemonRomhackDev • • 1d ago Popcorn

Showcase Pokémon Extreme Yellow V2 – Breaking the Limits of Gen1! (Announcement Trailer)

Thumbnail
youtu.be
2 Upvotes

Hi everyone! I'd like to share the announcement trailer for the V2 of my hack, Extreme Yellow!

I first started working on Extreme Yellow almost 4 years ago. Now V2 is close to release, and brings a ton of new stuff on top of the already pretty vast scope of V1.

Live a grandiose adventure in a game that defies what's possible in a Gen1 hack:

  • two full regions! Explore the Sevii Islands
  • day/night cycle
  • diving
  • shiny Pokémon
  • multi-slot save
  • and A LOT more that should stay a surprise for the time being ;)

Pokémon Extreme Yellow is a difficulty ROMhack featuring harder battles, deeper plot, more complex dungeons, restored contents, expanded roster and movesets, and so much more.

V2 is coming this Winter!

[Discord server](https://discord.gg/QAX4c4xMJY)

[Latest release (V1.4)](https://github.com/RainbowMetalPigeon/ExtremeYellow/releases)


r/PokemonRomhackDev • • 1d ago

Recruitment Looking for Play Testers and Feedback [(Gen 3)]

3 Upvotes

r/PokemonRomhackDev • • 5d ago

Showcase Pokémon Generation 3 Evolved - One Week Later | 1,025 Pokémon, Kanto + Sevii + Hoenn, 32 Badges, and 23 Updates

Thumbnail gallery
10 Upvotes

r/PokemonRomhackDev • • 6d ago

Showcase [GEN 9] [Scarlet Violet] Adding ORAS Méga evolution

Thumbnail
gallery
28 Upvotes

Added Oras mega evolution in Scarlet and violet, the transformation animation is laggy but will get fixed.


r/PokemonRomhackDev • • 7d ago

Help Hg engine compatibility with DSPRE [GEN 4] [OTHER]

4 Upvotes

I’m working on a fairly major hg project that would add some fairly big changes to the way the game works, I’ve started off in hg engine working on the more complicated stuff but later on I’ll want to work on some more simple stuff like wild encounters and gym leader teams which would be easier for me to do in dspre (I think). I’m wondering if it would be possible for me to migrate to dspre once the more coding based stuff in hg engine is done?


r/PokemonRomhackDev • • 7d ago

Discussion Small Update to my Emerald Decomp Nemesis System

Thumbnail
imgur.com
4 Upvotes

r/PokemonRomhackDev • • 9d ago

Showcase A first look at PokéRogue - Game Boy Version.

15 Upvotes

r/PokemonRomhackDev • • 9d ago

Help [GEN 4] [OTHER] Tips for beginners with no coding experience

2 Upvotes

As the title says I’m looking to start working on my first Rom hack, nothing crazy overall but I want to make a HGSS Rom hack that adds some features mostly prettt simple and I’m probably looking to work on it over an extended period of time so I’m not in a rush to make something wild

I know it’s probably easier to start with GBA but idk I just want to do this because HGSS was my first Pokemon game I’m not even sure if I would do another one even if I managed to make this fully working

I only just found out about decomp vs binary and think I’d probably end up using both if I did get all the way to the end


r/PokemonRomhackDev • • 10d ago

Claude's AI Starts Refusing To Assist With Pokémon ROM Hack & Fan-Game Development

Thumbnail
retrododo.com
94 Upvotes

r/PokemonRomhackDev • • 11d ago

Discussion Weekly HDQ Thread (Help, Discussion, Questions)

3 Upvotes

Hello! Welcome to the Weekly Discussion Thread. This is the place where you can:

  • Ask help for quick questions
  • Discuss ideas you have for your ROMhacks
  • Ask quick questions that you feel don't warrant a post.

Make sure to browse our sub resources:

Sub Wiki: https://www.reddit.com/r/PokemonRomhackDev/wiki/index/

How to ask a question: https://github.com/pret/pokeemerald/wiki/Getting-Help-with-the-Decomps


r/PokemonRomhackDev • • 12d ago

Discussion Pokemon Nemesis System

Thumbnail
imgur.com
7 Upvotes

r/PokemonRomhackDev • • 16d ago

Help [GEN3][Other] SRAM Locations for Secret bases?

6 Upvotes

Hi, I had an idea for a GBA emulator feature that would allow players to exchange Secret Bases without using a link cable.

The idea is that the emulator reads the SRAM to retrieve your own Secret Bases and uploads them to a server. It then downloads random Secret Bases from other players and writes them into your SRAM.

Have the SRAM/RAM locations for Secret Bases been researched and documented?

What do you think of this idea?


r/PokemonRomhackDev • • 18d ago

Discussion Weekly HDQ Thread (Help, Discussion, Questions)

3 Upvotes

Hello! Welcome to the Weekly Discussion Thread. This is the place where you can:

  • Ask help for quick questions
  • Discuss ideas you have for your ROMhacks
  • Ask quick questions that you feel don't warrant a post.

Make sure to browse our sub resources:

Sub Wiki: https://www.reddit.com/r/PokemonRomhackDev/wiki/index/

How to ask a question: https://github.com/pret/pokeemerald/wiki/Getting-Help-with-the-Decomps


r/PokemonRomhackDev • • 19d ago

Showcase Soaring Dream Latios Ride in Pokemon Scarlet and Violet.

Post image
34 Upvotes

Someone is literally pushing scarlet and violet to it's limit


r/PokemonRomhackDev • • 19d ago

Help [GEN 5][OTHER] Editing Phenomenon Encounters

2 Upvotes

Is it possible to edit and remove the wings from the shadow encounters on Driftveil bridge so that it is just Ducklett encounters?

If so, would you be able to point me in the direction of some information or programs that could help me with this?

Would this be possible with Frost?


r/PokemonRomhackDev • • 19d ago

Discussion What are your biggest wants out of a Sinnoh centered rom hack?

9 Upvotes

I'm not talking about a gen 4 rom hack or a nds rom hack specifically, and im also not talking about just simple QoL hacks like Renegade Platinum. Theres always a big emphasis on Kanto, Johto and Hoenn for rom hacks. Story wise or gameplay or just a fresh new take. At most what you see for sinnoh is QoL, difficulty and base Sinnoh in the gen 5 graphics.

I want to make something. Not something huge or revolutionary, I've never made a rom hack before. But I love Sinnoh, its the region i grew up on and I want to practice or attempt to make a rom hack based around it in more then just an improved platinum experience. I dont know what i'd do yet. maybe a new story. Maybe new pokemon. I see some people make rom hacks specifically based around their favorite pokemon, and mines Luxray so I might even do something small based around luxray.

But, from the community, what do you want out of a sinnoh rom hack? What story or gameplay changes or characters do you think should be explored? Do you think there should be a sinnoh equivalent of experiences like seagrass or ghost grey? Anything you have in mind for a sinnoh idea or think can be expored in sinnoh.


r/PokemonRomhackDev • • 21d ago

Showcase Swapping ride pokemons in Scarlet & Violet

Post image
19 Upvotes

It has few bugs but still impressive.


r/PokemonRomhackDev • • 23d ago

News Mega evolutions are NOW in Paldea [ Scarlet and Violet]

Thumbnail
gallery
31 Upvotes

This is beyond kino, Uhuru devs now added Mega evolutions in Pokemon Scarlet and violet.


r/PokemonRomhackDev • • 23d ago

Tooling DSPRE 3.0 In progress - Type Chart Editor showcase

47 Upvotes

DSPRE 3.0 is coming along nicely, we have move to .Net 8 and switched from WinForms to Avalonia allowing us to have native linux builds and as soon as we fix a thing mac builds too via github build pipelines

Wanted to show one of the new editors, the tyep chart editor to edit type interactions alongside the patch for allowing to expand it into the synth overlay (based on all the already done research in the ds wiki and years of knowledge of the discord server)

We don't have a release date just yet for 3.0 but we have some trusted people testing stuff to make sure it is 100% robust before we release it 😄

Oh yeah, dark mode too

AI Disclosure: We have created a like automated testing pipeline thing that runs all game versions + languages we have available ran by an agent that verifies all UI screens dont break, controls work, and some other tests such as export imports not have any binary changes, we COULD have done this by hand, by it would genuinely take hours and this allows us to focus on IRL or other stuff while the tests are prformed. Additionally we have used AI to help with scaffolding of UIs and their connected elements with avalonia, the gui editor for it has its limitations and is very annoying to use. Any and all research is human made. Sometimes we may relly on ai support for helping debug an issue, noticeably with the kind of "nobody seemsto be able to reproduce but one tester" kind of bug. For anyone that feels this is too much 2.3.4 our latest stable release had no AI involvement other than if I recall a bug or two we could not figure out at all. We understand this may put some people off so 2.3.4 will remain as is for them.


r/PokemonRomhackDev • • 23d ago

Recruitment Pokémon: Celestial Bronze - Seeking Development Team

Thumbnail gallery
5 Upvotes