TL;DR: A close platonic friend who is also polyamorous began feeling neglected when I started dating someone new and had less time available. I understood why she was hurt and tried to accommodate her requests for more structured time and communication. However, over time, the expectations began to feel difficult to maintain, and I started feeling like our friendship had become more about meeting specific obligations than spending time together because we wanted to. Eventually, the friendship ended over text, and I was so emotionally exhausted that I just let it drop without fighting for the friendship. Now I’m wondering whether I was being unfair or whether we simply had incompatible expectations of friendship.
I had a friend who became one of my closest friends very quickly. We actually met through dating and went on a few dates before realizing we weren’t romantically compatible. We decided to remain friends, and that friendship became incredibly meaningful to me.
She was a wonderful friend in many ways. She supported me through difficult situations, both emotionally and practically, and I tried to do the same for her. I helped her navigate family issues, work challenges, and medical situations. From my perspective, the friendship was reciprocal, although I recognize she may have experienced that differently.
For context, we’re both familiar with polyamory, but we approach relationships somewhat differently. She was in a hierarchical polyamorous relationship where her partner had another primary relationship, and she was his secondary partner. They generally saw each other once or twice a week.
I personally don’t prefer hierarchical relationship structures, but I respect that other people choose them. I did once express concern that she might not be receiving the level of attention or support she wanted from her romantic relationship. That led to an argument, and I realized my perspective wasn’t particularly helpful or welcome, so I stopped offering unsolicited opinions about it.
I do wonder, in hindsight, whether our friendship had become an especially important source of companionship and support for her, replacing the romantic intimacy she really wanted. But I also recognize that I’m making an assumption about her needs, and it’s possible she simply valued our friendship and expected more consistency from me.
Just to give me a fair shake here though:
ANYtime he was available suddenly she would cancel or reschedule our plans to go see him — it didn’t happen often because he was often so unavailable- but 100% of the time when she had a choice between me or her boyfriend she chose her boyfriend and THAT WAS FINE BY ME because I knew I didn’t own her and I wanted to offer flexibility and understanding to her, especially since I knew how little she got to see him. I mention this because it almost feels hypocritical that she would be mad at me for some of these things below when she so explicitly prioritized him or other men she was dating over me (which didn’t bother me because if she wanted to get laid I knew I couldn’t help in that department 😂)
Where things started to change:
Eventually, I met someone and began a new romantic relationship. I was definitely experiencing NRE, and I recognize that I was probably less available and attentive than I’d been previously.
Around the same time, I changed jobs and had more work-related travel, so my schedule became significantly busier so it wasn’t just the NRE. My whole life was becoming destabilized and I was locking into work and had very little free time.
My friend expressed that she felt neglected and deprioritized.
I took that seriously. I cared about her and didn’t want her to feel that our friendship mattered less just because I was dating someone. Looking back I wish I had been honest about my capacity because it wasn’t just because I was dating someone new. I was being stretched at work (10 hours a day minimum) and only had so much energy to give to others.
We had several conversations about what she needed from me, and I made an effort to adjust.
However, some of the expectations we established eventually started to feel uncomfortable or difficult for me to maintain.
Here are a few examples:
1. She was hurt that I took my new partner on a trip and not her.
I had to travel out of state for work and had enough credit card points to cover my new partner’s flight, so I invited him to join me. We shared a very small hotel room with a twin-sized bed.
My friend was upset that I’d offered this opportunity to someone I’d only been dating for a few weeks rather than to her.
From what I understood, she felt that she’d invested significantly more time and energy into our relationship and was hurt that I prioritized someone so new.
I can understand why that might have brought up feelings of being replaced, especially given how close we’d been.
At the same time, I viewed traveling with a romantic partner differently from traveling with a platonic friend. I didn’t think that inviting him meant I valued her any less, and I felt uncomfortable with the idea that the length of a relationship should determine who I invited on a particular trip. Also the hotel room had a twin sized bed and basically the trip was meant to be a romantic sexy trip. I didn’t want to share a twin bed with a platonic friend that I wasn’t romantically attracted to… it wasn’t a friend trip. It was a sexy trip lol also it felt resource-guardy and possessive. Like, I’m not some resource you need to covet.
2. She asked for new communication expectations.
My new job involved being in meetings for much of the day, which meant I couldn’t text or take calls as frequently as I had before.
My friend was understandably frustrated by the change in our communication.
To address this, she said that she would stop initiating texts and that I would be responsible for reaching out whenever I was available. Full stop.
I agreed to try it, but the arrangement felt unnatural to me.
I missed the spontaneity of our previous communication, and I began to feel pressure around initiating contact rather than simply reaching out when I had something to share. Also because I was already so stretched thin we just didn’t talk as much at all.
I understand that she may have been trying to avoid feeling rejected or disappointed when I couldn’t respond. But the arrangement didn’t feel particularly sustainable to me. Basically she was like “I’m done initiating. It’s your turn” but it felt like I was being asked to chase a friendship and like the energy invested previously was all ignored. Like, what happened to the year prior of trust built?
3. We scheduled weekly time together but there were a lot of rules around scheduling.
Previously, we’d spent time together more spontaneously. Because my availability had changed, she asked that we establish a standing weekly hangout.
I thought that was reasonable enough, and I agreed but honestly looking back I was so afraid to lose the friendship I would’ve agreed to mostly anything .
However, she also asked that if I needed to cancel, I would be responsible for proposing a new time and she would basically never suggest a spontaneous hang again.
I understood the reasoning: she wanted to feel that I was actively making an effort to maintain our friendship instead of leaving all the planning to her.
But as these expectations accumulated, I started feeling anxious about the friendship.
What had previously felt like a natural, supportive relationship began to feel like something I was constantly trying not to get wrong. I felt like she was my parole officer, not my friend.
It also just didn’t align with how some of my best longstanding relationships are and I realize that now. The best friendships I have are ones that leave space for life changing. One of my best friends used to call me every day. She moved in with her now-wife so she doesn’t call me at all anymore because she has a different schedule and relationship dynamic but instead we send voice notes back and forth. Another friend got a new job out of the country. We literally don’t talk for 11 months out of the year but then I visit her and it’s like nothing has changed. I haven’t fully thought through what this is but do you guys get what I mean? Bend ability in relationships = durability IMO
How things ended:
Eventually, the tension between us became difficult to resolve.
From her perspective, I think she’d been expressing her needs clearly and asking me to demonstrate that our friendship was still a priority.
From my perspective, I was genuinely trying to accommodate those needs, but I was also struggling with the growing sense that I couldn’t meet her expectations without sacrificing my own preferences and capacity.
Eventually, she ended the friendship over text.
By that point, I was emotionally exhausted and didn’t feel capable of having another difficult conversation about it. I just accepted it and tried to move on. I genuinely think she expected me to cry and beg for her back because she complained to others in our circle about how terrible of a person I was but I’m just like — I genuinely feel like I tried my best to meet her needs. She ended the friendship with me and I’m not one to disrespect someone’s request for space so I didn’t ask her to reconsider.
I can 100000% understand her feeling hurt about my lack of availability.
At the same time, I can’t help but to feel like she was using me to replace her boyfriend who wasn’t giving her the attention she wanted and then she locked me into this weirdly rigid dynamic that there was no winning in.
I don’t think she was wrong for wanting more consistency, and I don’t think I was wrong for having less availability. But I’m struggling to figure out where reasonable friendship expectations end and where they become obligations that neither person actually enjoys.
So what’s the deal here? I am admittedly sensitive about this because I feel like I did the best I could but I DO want to learn if there’s some poly theory or learnings here that I am totally missing and I don’t want to screw up another friendship if I am missing a big thing here.