r/polyamory • u/CatterSnapple • 1h ago
How to move forward after partner planned a date with a new person without consulting with me ahead of time- mismatched expectations and breach of trust.
Hopefully the title sums it up, but there’s a lot more context. I (f38) have been in a poly relationship with my boyfriend (m42) for about 2.5 years. We’d been peripheral friends for many years before dating, so there’s another layer of trust and familiarity that was already there. I have historically been monogamous. He is polyamorous and had established active long-term relationships before we started seeing each other.
One of those relationships ended this summer, leaving him understandably pretty devastated (5 + yr. relationship and their lives were very intertwined). Since then, I have become the partner he sees most often/regularly. He is married but they live separately and are mostly platonic, and has a comet partner who comes in town a few times a year. I haven’t had another partner since we’ve been together.
So when this breakup happened, he had some other big setbacks around the same time and did not handle it well. From my perspective, he basically disappeared for over a week. Not sure what details are worth sharing around that, but the point is that there was a breach of trust to be repaired. I felt abandoned. It was rough, but things have felt solid and lighter between us since then.
Maybe a couple months ago, I asked if he was okay not seeing any other new people for now. He said yes, that he wasn’t in a place for it and wasn’t looking to add another partner. In the same conversation, I also expressed that for future/hypothetical situations, I would want to know if he was going to go on a date with someone. That wasn’t a given to him, and I remember him replying something like, “oh okay, that’s good to know.” He said he didn’t need me to tell him if I went on a date, but would be happy to talk about it if I wanted to. I said I would want to tell him. I don’t remember the exact wording, this is as clear as I remember it.
So this brings us to the current issue. About a week ago I was asking about his schedule to make plans and he said he was busy one night. Yadda yadda, I find out he has a date with someone. I felt completely blindsided. He says he was going to meet up with them and feel it out, and then tell me after if / when it seemed like it might become something- that he wasn’t sure if it would even feel like a date. We had an argument about it and he’s since acknowledged that this was the wrong way to go about it. I’m sure I’m not fully representing his perspective here. Not defending his choice, but adding the context that I know I don’t make it easy to bring up these kinds of things.
When I brought up our previous conversation, he said that he’s still not looking to add a partner, but his desire to date has changed. He wants to gain confidence back after the breakup, and would like to casually date. He did not remember explicitly agreeing to tell me if he went on a date (which I didn’t think was even a possibility currently). This seems crazy to me, but knowing him, I believe him that he doesn’t really remember it. He does know me well enough to know that though… this initial conversation was at the end of last weekend, and he just went on the date at the beginning of this weekend. I’m devastated. For me, I feel like he made this huge change in our relationship that I wasn’t ready for. To him, it seemed low stakes and isn’t changing anything between us. He says he doesn’t want to push me to the side, see me less, or de-escalate our relationship, which I also don’t want.
He says in the previous conversation he was letting me know where he was at, rather than making a promise- I thought we clearly had an agreement that is now broken. I know it’s kind of a mono/poly dynamic that is inherently imbalanced. I also know that we have different ideal relationship structures- this isn’t new. It’s a difficult thing to reconcile, but we’ve decided repeatedly that we still want to be together regardless. We’ve both put in a lot of extra time and energy to accommodate each other’s needs. I am not looking for just break up with him advice.
I talked with some friends who know him about this earlier tonight, and they were like “so…he cheated.” and they were shocked and angry that he didn’t cancel the date to repair things with me first. The more I think about it, the more upset I am that he still went on the date knowing how much pain this decision was causing me. I know that it’s important to him to have autonomy, and not have a give each other rules/permission dynamic. I don’t really want that either, but it’s important to me to feel considered. and having agreements that we set in place makes me feel more secure.
We are about to have a more explicit conversation about what some of those agreements are, and are starting a weekly relationship check-in moving forward. My hope is that the structure will relieve some pressure, and give us a specific time and space to revisit agreements we’ve made with each other. I haven’t been able to relax or get good sleep the whole last week. I know that it wasn’t sustainable to keep things closed off forever, but I can’t help but feel like what I want isn’t as important. It would have been a hard conversation for us, but it’s so much harder with this added breach of trust.
Especially after the conversation with my friends, I feel extremely uneasy about making too many accommodations for him and think his decisions were selfish. I know he cares for me deeply, but his actions are showing me that his needs come before mine. He has told me that he does plan to see this person again, but does not have another date currently planned. I’ve been dragging my heels on setting up dates for myself because it seems scary and hard, but also because he meets most of my needs most of the time. But I know he can’t meet all of my needs forever, so that would make sense for me to start trying.
I want to request that he put future dates on hold until we repair things between us. Maybe for a few weeks? Curious what y’all think about that. Do you think this was cheating? Am I asking for too much? What can I do to be supporting myself through this? What else needs to happen for both of us to feel supported and at ease with each other again? First time posting and in a way still newish to polyamory…please be kind. Thank you!