r/ProMusicProduction • • 6h ago

Sound engineers: What's the weirdest, funniest or most ridiculous thing a client has ever asked you to do?

5 Upvotes

I'm a sound engineer with over 20 years of experience, and I've come to realize that working in audio production can expose you to some absolutely unbelievable situations.

I'm collecting real stories from sound engineers, producers, recording studio owners and live sound technicians.

I want to hear your most ridiculous experiences.

Some examples:

\- What's the weirdest request a client has ever made during a recording or mixing session?

\- Has anyone ever asked you to do something technically impossible?

\- What's the most absurd thing someone has said about their music, recording or equipment?

\- Have you ever had a client who made you question your entire profession?

\- What's the funniest disaster you've witnessed in a studio or at a live event?

\- Have you ever received a mix revision that made absolutely no sense?

\- What's the most embarrassing thing you've personally done during a session?

\- What's the strangest excuse a musician has given you?

I'm particularly interested in stories that sound completely made up but actually happened.

No need to name names, studios or clients. Keep it anonymous.

The more bizarre, awkward, unexpected or hilarious, the better.

And if you have a story that you still can't believe happened, I definitely want to hear it.

Thanks!


r/ProMusicProduction • • 22h ago

Debate: Who is the Producer?

5 Upvotes

I don't know what else to do but ask what other people in the music industry think about this. I am upset because I want the credit where the credit is due. I produce music using Ableton Live. I use the DAW to arrange, mix, and master. I also use it to create midi tracks for the drums and melody. My friend is an artist who raps, writes his own raw lyrics, has the ideas for adlibs, sound effects, and has great vocals. My friend and I are having a disagreement in the studio. He distributed the music we made together to all platforms. Which is fine, but he credited me as the Beatmaker, DAW Engineer and Co- Producer. He credited himself as the producer. He should be next to the title of the song and known as the artist. I believe I am the producer.

Me

"Since you're uploading the master to streaming platforms under your artist profile so it reaches your fanbase cleanly without splitting streams or triggering duplicate/Content ID clashes, I just want to make sure my official producer credit—along with our agreed master and publishing splits—is locked in on the release metadata. Having my credit listed directly helps listeners and industry folks click through to my catalog while keeping everything organized and automated on the backend. and my royalty split for any profits the track makes. Setting up our percentage splits through the distributor and registering the publishing ensures we both get paid automatically and cleanly as the song grows. And my royalty split for any profits the track makes. Setting up our percentage splits through the distributor and registering the publishing ensures we both get paid automatically and cleanly as the song grows"

Friend

"Yea bro it ain’t making anything it cost me money, that I fronted bro to pay for that service"

Me

"Yeah ofc you have to pay distrokid"

Friend

"There not gunna recieve anything I put them there cause they helped make the track Ur names on the one u did as well I thought u wanted me to say u used a daw ? That counts as mixing and sound design ??? I have the chain of custody for all lyrics and everything I’ve ever did bro obv I’d hook u up if it takes off u do anything with the other joint I sent u two days ago?? Or just the freestyle "

Me

Paying DistroKid a subscription to push a track onto streaming platforms doesn't make you the producer. it just makes you a customer with a card. Distribution is just uploading a file and getting it onto apps. producing is actually building the music from the ground up. You paid for a distributor plan, not a producer credit.

Friend

Are u saying I didn’t produce my work right now ? Well I was in the room with u the whole time and everything else i produced with my vocals ? And placing exact timestamps and sound affects

Friend

When I direct placement verbals sound affects isn’t a customer at the counter that’s creative control witch is the part that actually defines authorship the room where in happened well we were bolth in it is what tells the story bro

Me

I'm just saying this because I play your music at my house all the time and the songs you made pops up and people were asking why there was a difference

DAW to a Music Producer is like Water to a Swimmer. You need it. You dont need it but it's the main tool, you cant replace it.

Friend

When I direct placement verbals sound affects isn’t a customer at the counter that’s creative control witch is the part that actually defines authorship the room where in happened well we were bolth in it is what tells the story bro

That’s fine bro the mics on the way where suppose to work together I just don’t get what ur saying ?

Ur also listed as co producer incase u didn’t realize that as well as daw engineer

Me

Your work is the Artists job. You are 100% an artist. A producer is a completely different job title.

Calling yourself the producer because you gave vocal cues, placed ad-libs, and paid for distribution is like calling yourself the chef because you ordered takeout, pointed at the hot sauce, and paid the delivery driver. Directing your own performance and getting a song uploaded makes you the artist running your release, not the producer who actually built the record from scratch—and putting a 'co-producer' tag on it doesn't turn an artist's job into a producer's credit.

Friend

I did the vocal takes That’s the performance U can unsing what I already sang And the performance is what copy right also protects but I just don’t get what ur saying Or why ur saying it Ur missing the whole point I was in the room me saying you produced it isn’t a credit We bolth produced it bro I didn’t send u vocals and say work with these I was in tbe room with you picking sounds and where to drop the beat and what sounds to use I don’t hand u files and say make this a record That’s the difference bro I was there I tried to do that with the other audio file last night and idk u haven’t said anything about it You produced the beat I’m not taking that from u bro did but sound affects and adlibs are what bring the song to life as well bro that’s the difference between a demo and a record Tools don’t make the artist the ear does and the industry is using it and lying about it most people do I just keep it real and I have never had it write a single lyric for me and never will so I don’t feel the need to hide it Bro ur names in the title did u not peep that ?

Me

How else are you going to get a wav file of good quality audio without a daw?You cant "produce" any actual quality sound without one You cant "produce" any actual quality sound without one

Friend

And this is the other thing I paid to distribute my work bro and from scratch would be from nothing I have vocals and structure I just feel that this conversation is getting old brother featuring you in the title is honestly even more then most beat makers get bro do u want me to take u out the title then I don’t get what ur trying to say brother that im just an artist ? I have a hand in production on every single record I’ve made.

* What do you think about this

I don't know what else to do but ask what other people in the music industry think about this. I am upset because I want the credit where the credit is due. he I produce music using Ableton Live. I use the DAW to arrange, mix, and master. I also use it to create midi tracks for the drums and melody. My friend is an artist who raps, writes his own raw lyrics, has the ideas for adlibs, sound effects, and has great vocals. My friend and I are having a disagreement in the studio. He distributed the music we made together to all platforms. Which is fine, but he credited me as the Beatmaker, DAW Engineer and Co- Producer. He credited himself as the producer. He should be next to the title of the song and known as the artist. I believe I am the producer.


r/ProMusicProduction • • 1d ago

Macbook air m1 💻 good enough to make beats?

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/ProMusicProduction • • 1d ago

Studio speakers

2 Upvotes

Are studio speakers worth it? I am currently using headphones the dt 990 pro. But my problem is that whenever I finish my track or what I made, when I play it on my phone or car speakers, or anything other then my headphones, the whole track ( well not the whole track but some) sounds different. Like sometimes the kick is too quiet but on my headphones sound good, and other stuff.

I’m still a beginner so it may actually not even be my headphones.


r/ProMusicProduction • • 1d ago

Which Mac Mini for Music and Video Production

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/ProMusicProduction • • 1d ago

Tape round trip. Make sense?

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/ProMusicProduction • • 4d ago

Best studio headphones for music production?

2 Upvotes

Looking to take the next step in my musical journey by investing in to some good quality studio headphones. Any suggestions? No true limit on price range for me - just looking for best value / bang for my buck! Thank you!


r/ProMusicProduction • • 4d ago

Mastering et mix en live

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/ProMusicProduction • • 4d ago

Looking for participants for a short study on vocal balance (10–15 min)

1 Upvotes

Hi! I’m Rasmus, a student at Umeå University. I’m conducting a listening study on how people balance vocals in a mix, and I’d love your help.

You’ll set the vocal level in three short tracks, then listen to six mixes from other participants and rate how the vocal sits in each.

It takes about 10 minutes. All you need is headphones or studio monitors and a quiet place to listen. Participation is voluntary, and there’s no signup or download.

Here is the link: https://visual-feedback-study.vercel.app/

If you take part, please keep the explanation at the end out of the comments until recruitment closes, so others can go in fresh.

Thanks for lending me your ears!
Rasmus :)


r/ProMusicProduction • • 6d ago

Question Do CPU and Power Settings Really Affect Revorded Vocals

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/ProMusicProduction • • 6d ago

Vocal repeat stutter effect

1 Upvotes

Hi there I’m trying to figure out how these stutters in the vocals are made it’s all through this song but but like the bit at 30secs where it almost seamlessly blends into the main vocal, I’m not sure this is just cut up as it all feels too slick if I cut up vocals it always sounds less smooth anyone have any ideas?

https://open.spotify.com/track/1MMJBmtFLwHZG6D0HOmx4f?si=VhqoS99SS6W4u9uGGaV0Jw&utm_source=copy-link

This artist has loads of other tracks using this technique if anyone needs more references:)

So my goal is to be able to take a vocal sample and inject these stutters that’s in an easy to control way if that’s possible cheers for any help


r/ProMusicProduction • • 6d ago

Anyone knows how to mix screams on a metalcore song? Need Advice

Thumbnail reddit.com
2 Upvotes

r/ProMusicProduction • • 6d ago

Print-through or something else?

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/ProMusicProduction • • 8d ago

Audeze MM-520 B-stock versus DUNU Arashi headphones

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/ProMusicProduction • • 10d ago

Help!

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/ProMusicProduction • • 10d ago

Muziek mix-app idee?

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/ProMusicProduction • • 11d ago

Mixing vocals

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/ProMusicProduction • • 11d ago

Why is mastering so important?

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/ProMusicProduction • • 11d ago

What is "Youtube for Artists" for?

4 Upvotes

Came across https://artists.youtube/ as an artist myself and I haven't heard of anyone else that's used it in any capacity.

If you've used it, what have you used it for? Does it work well? I wasn't sure what to make of it from the website


r/ProMusicProduction • • 11d ago

How do music producers and audio engineers manage versions, revisions and feedback?

2 Upvotes

Hey everyone!
I’m exploring an idea in the music production space and wanted to get some honest opinions from producers, mixing/mastering engineers and studio owners.
When working on a music project, how do you currently manage things like:
Multiple versions of the same track (v1, v2, final, final_final 😅).
Feedback coming from artists through WhatsApp, emails and voice notes.
Keeping track of why certain mixing or production decisions were made.
Managing revisions and knowing which exact version has been approved.
Handing projects over to another engineer without losing context.
I’m exploring the idea of building a platform that brings all of this together, with project management, version history, collaboration, approvals and AI-powered music intelligence.
The idea is to work alongside existing DAWs like Ableton, Logic and Pro Tools, not replace them.
I’d love to hear from people who actually work in music production:
Are these genuine problems in your day-to-day workflow?
What tools do you currently use to manage projects and revisions?
What’s one thing about your current workflow that you wish was easier?
Would a platform that solves these problems be useful to you?
I’m still exploring the idea, so honest feedback and criticism are very welcome. I’d rather understand the actual problems before building something nobody needs!


r/ProMusicProduction • • 11d ago

Question mac studio m5 max or ultra w/ logic / protools?

4 Upvotes

need to upgrade my main studio workhorse.. looking at the new studio series.. but dont see them listed as compatible by Avid.. running an HDX card in a tbolt chassis, protools HD, avid HD i/o 16, also running logic.. kontakt.. large libraries.. lots of plugins.. sometimes working to picture.. 16 in and out , etc

anyone have experience here?


r/ProMusicProduction • • 11d ago

Sync Licensing Discussion/Advice

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes