r/Professors • • 18h ago

Rants / Vents Professors calling potential students?

I’m a professor at a European university facing declining enrollment. Management now wants faculty to call prospective students over the summer to encourage them to enroll. I consider this admissions telemarketing, not academic work. Is this happening elsewhere? Am I being unreasonable in thinking this is unacceptable?

29 Upvotes

53 comments sorted by

17

u/warricd28 Lecturer, Accounting, R1, USA 17h ago

It’s not normal, but at a small slac in the US I used to work at they were trying to get faculty to send admitted students letters or emails, or call to get them to enroll. I refused to do it.

3

u/No_Project_7739 6h ago

“No one comes to our restaurant! You, go out there, grab customers and drag them in!”

Or improve the menu… maybe?

3

u/Potential-Winner4601 6h ago

It’s a buffet

16

u/Kittiemeow8 Tenure-track faculty, CALC 18h ago

14

u/SoundShifted 18h ago

US perspective: calling seems like a bit much...we do shit like write postcards, though (on a volunteer basis).

7

u/scatterbrainplot 18h ago

Postcards also seem ridiculous, but at least less invasive

4

u/AerosolHubris Prof, Math, PUI, US 7h ago

We are voluntold. It's encouraged, but my chair made it clear we would be doing it.

8

u/nandor_tr associate prof, art/design, private university (USA) 18h ago

i am more than happy to answer questions from prospective students, take part in open houses, do a tour, etc... but calling students over the summer? not a chance in hell.

8

u/the_Stick Assoc Prof, Biomedical Sciences 17h ago

Not an undergrad institution, but we have faculty volunteers who will call a few students once they are accepted. Being a competitive school, most of our applicants are applying multiple places. Marketing has found that faculty reaching out quadruples the likelihood of an accepted student actually enrolling.

Again, this is strictly voluntary and there are some professors who love doing it and are very personable. As an introvert myself, I haven't done it, but I'm not opposed. Also, no professor is calling more than a handful of students (unless they really want to). Students to be called are divvied up so that it takes maybe an hour or two at most if you're really chatty.

8

u/KibudEm Full prof & chair, Humanities, Comprehensive (USA) 16h ago

We're being told to do it, but the university is too disorganized to forward the information to me in time, so I don't do it.

7

u/TaxashunsTheft USA 17h ago

I'm in the US and I call prospective students and I also give tours of our labs. I'm happy to do it because I want more enrollment. I also do fundraising by visiting alumni and asking for endowment funds. It's not my job but I'll do it anyway to help my program be successful. 

13

u/Melodic-Cat-5663 16h ago

We were asked to call students at a for-profit college I worked at years ago. These were extremely awkward phone calls that accomplished nothing, as far as I could tell.

This is a sign that your school is in serious trouble and run by desperate leadership.

2

u/FrankHightower Assoc. Prof, CS, R1 & R2 8h ago

Students that are (or at least have previously been) enrolled, I hope

6

u/jkhuggins Assoc. Prof., CS, PUI (STEM) 17h ago

We did this at our institution for a few years. A few differences: (1) calls were restricted to admitted students, and (2) all employees (including faculty) were asked to participate. I did see several high-level admins (e.g. deans and department heads) participating, so there was leadership by example at work here.

I did it fo a few years when my schedule permitted. I viewed it as largely ineffective; at the times I was asked to call, I probably reached voicemail 90% of the time. Thankfully, we're no longer running the program.

5

u/ProfessorStata 18h ago

Depends how bad enrollment is and if you think your job is secure if you don’t do this.

3

u/Anonphilosophia Adjunct, Humanities, CC (USA) 6h ago

Yeah, it seems like if faculty are being asked to do this - it might be a matter of staying open. If that were the case, I might make a call or two to ensure I have a job. But I definitely don't think it's an appropriate ask of faculty.

5

u/Fantastic-Wind5744 17h ago

My former school made us do this. I just threw my list away and told my DH I couldn't get a hold of any of them so I left messages.

9

u/Longjumping-Owl-7584 18h ago

What the fuck. I would never do this.

4

u/LinuxedApple845 18h ago

I don’t mind it because then I control the message.  End up getting a better crop of students and they seem to understand what’s up and what is expected of them.  

4

u/Huck68finn 9h ago

Yep. Our Dean asked us to do this a couple of years ago. I filed the request under "Trash."

3

u/AmnesiaZebra Associate Prof, social sciences, state R1 (USA) 18h ago

I have colleagues at SLACs in the US being asked to do this too.

3

u/FrankHightower Assoc. Prof, CS, R1 & R2 17h ago

"calling" students used to mean going to their high schools and setting up some sort of event. Closest I've seen to reaching out to a prospect directly is making information on how to transfer from another university more visible

3

u/Acrobatic_Net2028 17h ago

Try to get thrm to ask students to do this, only involve professors if a student has something truly spectacular to offer your field

3

u/SNHU_Adjujnct 7h ago

When I adjuncted for one awful semester at ITT Tech, we were required to call students who didn't come to class. Somehow it always slipped my mind.

3

u/lewisb42 Professor, CS, State Univ (USA) 4h ago

I'm sick with a cold and I had this post on my brain when I went to sleep last night. Thanks for the unpleasant dreams, heh.

8

u/Outrageous_Oven_2114 18h ago

This is 100% not normal. I have never even heard of this. Marketing is done by some other offices, but not by any professors, even at big R1s in the US. You might reply to incoming graduate students, but never cold calling unenrolled people?? I would tell my college to kick rocks or pay me more for serving as a recruiter.

4

u/scatterbrainplot 18h ago

And as a student calling me would've absolutely not make me more likely to do anything except consider whether I'm at the right place. And I feel like calling has only become even more ridiculous of a thought since I was a student.

4

u/Outrageous_Oven_2114 17h ago

Yeah if I was an unenrolled student I would be super confused and want to know how they got my contact info and it would be off putting no matter what they said to me on the phone.

4

u/Think-Assignment-861 Full, Phys. Sci., R1 (US) 17h ago

Not completely correct. About 2 decades ago, I was in charge of grad admissions and I called the accepted students a number of times. These days not so much, though we get our current students to contact them.

3

u/FrankHightower Assoc. Prof, CS, R1 & R2 17h ago

OP is talking about calling students who haven't been accepted yet

4

u/Think-Assignment-861 Full, Phys. Sci., R1 (US) 17h ago

Ah, I misunderstood. No, we do not contact applicants until they have been accepted. Though, we do set up booths at our prof society meetings to recruit.

2

u/scatterbrainplot 17h ago

Do the grad students email or call? Because giving my phone number to a grad student without my consent would not be ok, and either way I still don't want them to call.

If this isn't a phone interview of some sort (in which case why isn't it a video call through the internet and not relying on minutes as well as being specific to a phone), they have no reason to call me. And those calls should be scheduled anyway.

Otherwise, no, I also don't and didn't want faculty (or staff) to call, and doing that before I'd accepted would be a consideration when deciding which offer to accept. As I'd see it, clearly the program and/or people in it lack boundaries and consideration.

1

u/wedontliveonce associate professor (usa) 17h ago

You give your the phone numbers of your incoming students to your current students without their consent???

4

u/Think-Assignment-861 Full, Phys. Sci., R1 (US) 17h ago

We had (and still have ) office phones. The application forms asked for a contact phone number of the students, and we ask them to check a box if they are willing to be contacted by current members of the dept if accepted. No one has ever objected. Our current students are better recruiters than we are.

1

u/wedontliveonce associate professor (usa) 17h ago

If I were an accepted student I would not interpret "current members of the department" to mean grad students.

1

u/Think-Assignment-861 Full, Phys. Sci., R1 (US) 17h ago

Given that no won has ever complained, I do not see an issue. In fact, most are happy to be contacted. And you must be in a weird dept if grad students are not considered its members.

1

u/scatterbrainplot 16h ago

Of course they didn't complain, regardless of what they thought.

And what I think of grad students and what a prospective student who's never been in grad school things should not be assumed to be the same.

1

u/wedontliveonce associate professor (usa) 16h ago

Perhaps it's semantics. Where I work "members" of a department are defined by policy.

If it's only grad students making the calls, why not just say that when asking for a contact number?

Do you compensate your students for their recruitment work?

1

u/Think-Assignment-861 Full, Phys. Sci., R1 (US) 16h ago

Because the first call is made by the DGA, then the grad students take over.

And the grad students are volunteers. This whole scheme emerged because they wanted it. They are not required to do anything, they do it if they want to, generally those who were at the same undergrad institution as the prospective student are keen to do so.

1

u/wedontliveonce associate professor (usa) 16h ago edited 16h ago

So you don't actually "get our current students to contact them"?

By "take over" do you mean the director hands over the phone, or do you mean they make a 2nd call? Because if it's the former the grad students don't actually need the phone numbers.

I think it's very beneficial for prospective students to communicate with current grad students. If for no other reason than to get the low down on which profs to avoid as advisors.

It's the sharing their personal information with other students, when they probably think "members" means profs, that I would not do.

2

u/TrainingLow9079 17h ago

I knew a college having faculty do this years ago. It's not calling random students, it's calling students interested in your major. Not that I think faculty should be expected to do it...

6

u/Junior-Dingo-7764 18h ago

This is nuts.

If you are on a 9 month contract, this would be unpaid labor.

7

u/AmnesiaZebra Associate Prof, social sciences, state R1 (USA) 18h ago

I don't know any European unis with 9-month contracts

2

u/Junior-Dingo-7764 18h ago

Interesting. Maybe that's mostly an American thing.

4

u/Edu_cats Professor, Pre-Allied Health, M1 (US) 18h ago

We did this one year when it was some administrator’s boneheaded idea. I think we connected with one student out of our list. Like they really want to talk to us.

4

u/PhDapper 17h ago

This was something we were asked to do at a prior institution. It was pointless. It’s was as stupid then as it is now.

4

u/macademician 18h ago

It is one thing to extend time to admitted students (especially graduate students), or accept an email to help them figure out if your institution is the best fit.

But undergraduates? Or prospective, rather than admitted students? No, that’s not reasonable.

2

u/popstarkirbys 17h ago

I work at a PUI and we meet with prospective students and help with recruitment at university events. We don’t call students though.

2

u/newtothissendhelp 5h ago

We are asked to a for profit university. It’s students that are already enrolled though but it’s so incredibly weird. I would try to get out of there.

3

u/Apprehensive-Carob43 18h ago

Whattt? That is not your job

2

u/mulrich1 17h ago

Enrollments are declining. If students don’t come our jobs go away. I’d want some faculty input on how these calls work but I think it’s fair to ask us to participate. 

-1

u/Toepale 13h ago

Leave academia.