The funniest part is that he'll probably get halfway through the book, discover a memory safety issue, rewrite the entire ownership model, and announce that the release date is being pushed back indefinitely. At least the compiler won't let him publish unfinished chapters
Supposedly they used GRRM's canonical ending, they just dropped everything that GRRM was going to rely on to get to that ending that would make it satisfying: Faegon providing Dany a real reason to go insane, Maggie's prophesy giving Cersei's cause of death, the entire Dorne plot, the entire maester / Old town / Hightower plot, essentially everything useful about the White Walkers.
They dropped all the parts the end needed to finish 2 seasons early, which made the end rubbish and the conclusions unsatisfying.
This is pretty much it. If you look at the other stories GRRM has written having the ending being the super intelligent tree network takes over and rules perfectly is pretty in line with the kind of stuff he writes.
The whole entire story is political intrigue, people controlling information, hiding information, destroying information, backstabbing, front stabbing, and fucking.
Bran's whole magic deal is perfect for ruling Westeros because he'd have dirt on everyone who's dirty, and for everyone who is "noble", he's from a highly respected family. His sister conveniently gained magical powers of assassination, and in the books his mom is going around murdering all their family's enemies. Also, he's apparently able to literally change history, so, that's a hell of a power.
It would take one book for him to place himself into power, and it would make 100% sense in every way.
The only thing that could possibly be more satisfying is Jon Snow having to kill his insane god-king brother for the good of humanity after killing his sister for the good of the kingdom, and then at the end nearly everyone is dead and some random jackass gets to be king and literally nothing materially changes.
Now that would be a glorious anti-fairytale ending.
The only thing that could possibly be more satisfying is Jon Snow having to kill his insane god-king brother for the good of humanity after killing his sister for the good of the kingdom, and then at the end nearly everyone is dead and some random jackass gets to be king and literally nothing materially changes.
Do you mean "aunt", e.g. Daenerys, or "sister" e.g. Arya? I can see why you'd mean the former but struggle with the latter.
For Daenerys, aunt, sister, it's been years, I can't fuckin' remember.
For Arya, if you don't understand that there's more to family than blood, then that's pretty sad. They're clearly family in every way that matters (except the inbreeding part).
I meant killing Daenerys, whatever the relationship is.
Though, after killing Bran, who knows who he'd have to gank next. He'd probably be known as the butcher king, after a series of completely justified murders.
I always thought best ending would be that Bran died the minute Three Eyed Raven took over. That the wall was really made to keep the Three Eyed Raven out. That the Three Eyed Raven was tricking everyone to rule.
yeah, I also liked that concept. The Night King is the guardian/jailer for the Three Eyed Raven, and now the Raven has escaped south in Bran's body, the King has to come south to stop him. It would have been a great subversion when Jon, Arya etc found out that the King's the "good guy" and their brother is now an evil entity.
I would like to read TWOW and ADOS before making such a strong declaration. Mind you, the Raven was close to king himself in his own time, pre-banishment. But I can see why you dislike it conceptually.
Deny going insane was really fast forwarded and made no sense in the way the TV show portrayed it. They sidestepped all the travel by letting the characters teleport there. Just everything was weird about the way they rushed to the ending. Surely another season of the show would've stayed profitable with the crazy numbers of viewers it was pulling in, even non-fantasy viewers were watching it. My freaking grandma was hooked on it.
Debatable that GRRM's intended content would make it satisfying though. The guy has had so much time to finish the series, and for his legacy's sake he's obviously highly motivated to do so. I think the reason you don't finish it is when you can't wrap it up satisfyingly, in which case it's better to release nothing and let people assume it would've been amazing.
I suspect that he's already finished TWOW and ADOS, but after seeing the reaction to the end of AGOT, decided to put them aside for release only after his death, so that he'd never have to know what people's opinion of "his" version was.
Maybe, but I think it's no more than rough drafts, and that every time he has tried to finish one, he's not satisfied with the result and burns out and shelves it again.
I feel like he's caught between a rock and a hard place where what befits GoT is an ending that's messy and inconclusive, but fans are used to neat conclusive endings in all their other fantasy media so they won't like it. Like, I think a good GoT ending is that the White Walkers are kinda defeated but it's kinda still ongoing, and the politics kinda changes but kinda stays the same, and some characters are kinda heroes but some kinda accomplished nothing in the end, etc. People will lose their minds if it's that meaningless feeling of an ending, but they'll also lose their minds if the plots are all conveniently and unrealistically resolved just to form neat narrative arcs.
When they'll be mad at you either way, just leave notes and let people believe you had a perfect ending in mind and that it was the people who wrapped up your book after your death who botched it.
I think the plot of the television show was not the problem, but rather the execution of that plot. Dany's transition into insanity was EXTREMELY rushed, which made it subvert the audience's expectations in the bad way when the destruction of King's Landing happens.
If he did that same plot, but in long novels where a gradual descent into madness can happen then it could be excellent imo. It needed better writing, better foreshadowing, and some time to breathe.
The fact that HBO wanted season 8's content to be split into two season (seasons 8 and 9), but the showrunners didn't want to do another season, tells us a lot about the mindset of the showrunners. The showrunners just wanted to be done so they could move on with a new project.
"Here's where I went wrong: I wrote a massive tangle of confusing plotlines across more than 20 characters that set up so many world-defining mysteries, I couldn't possibly resolve them all to satisfaction. In order to fix this problem, I have now rewritten the entire story to no longer encompass the complex world politics surrounding the War of the Five Kings, and instead just tell a small localized tale of a guy called Dunk and his friend Egg."
The winds of winter howled across the frozen fields of Winterfell. The dead were marching. The living were falling. And hope, once a blazing flame, was nothing more than a dying spark in the darkness.
Then, from beyond the gates, a stranger arrived.
John Wick.
He had crossed worlds, survived impossible odds, and faced armies of killers. But this time, he wasn't alone. By his side walked his most loyal companion: his dog.
Together, they entered the battlefield.
The Night King's army descended upon Winterfell like an endless tide of death. Swords shattered. Dragons screamed. Heroes fell. And then, through the chaos, the Night King himself appeared.
With a single, merciless strike, he killed John's dog.
Time stopped.
John dropped to his knees. He held his beloved companion in his arms as the life slowly faded from its eyes. A tear rolled down his cheek, falling onto the frozen soil of a land that smelled of blood, ashes, and death.
Then came the sound.
One last, faint...
"Au... au..."
Silence.
John closed his eyes.
He had lost everything before. His peace. His home. His wife. But this... this was different.
Something inside him broke.
And something far more powerful awakened.
His hands clenched. The earth trembled. A deafening roar erupted from his chest as an enormous golden aura exploded around him, illuminating the battlefield.
His hair turned golden. His eyes burned with fury. Lightning danced around his body.
JOHN WICK HAD ASCENDED TO SUPER SAIYAN 2.
The armies of the dead stopped.
Even the Night King took a step backward.
Across the battlefield, Arya Stark looked up. Her face, once consumed by despair, began to change. For the first time that night, she smiled.
Hope had returned.
Not because the living had found a way to defeat death.
But because death had just made the biggest mistake of its existence.
John slowly stood up. He wiped the tears from his face, reached into his pocket, and pulled out his most trusted weapon.
A pencil.
The Night King raised his blade.
John looked him straight in the eyes.
"You killed my dog."
And then...
HE VANISHED.
A golden flash crossed the battlefield. The ground exploded beneath his feet. The Night King's army was swept away by a shockwave of pure, unfiltered rage.
Before the White Walker King could even react, John Wick appeared behind him.
One final movement.
One pencil.
One perfectly executed strike through the Night King's chest.
The ice cracked.
The blue eyes faded.
And the King of the Dead shattered into a million frozen pieces.
Every White Walker fell. Every wight collapsed. The darkness disappeared.
Winterfell was saved.
John stood alone in the middle of the battlefield, his golden aura slowly fading.
Arya approached him.
"Who are you?" she asked.
John looked down at the pencil in his hand.
"A father."
He walked away.
The camera slowly rises above Winterfell as the sun breaks through the clouds.
The music swells.
CUT TO BLACK.
AFTER THE CREDITS
A mysterious underground vault.
A massive steel door slowly opens.
Inside, a silhouette stands before an enormous collection of weapons, medals, and martial arts trophies.
A hand reaches for a black belt.
The camera moves closer.
A familiar face emerges from the shadows.
CHUCK NORRIS.
He puts on his black belt kimono, adjusts his sleeves, and looks directly into the camera.
With a calm, almost disappointed expression, he says:
"Fine. I'll do it myself."
The vault doors slam shut.
A single roundhouse kick echoes through the darkness.
COMING SOON.
All The Ways Game Of Thrones Set Up An Epic Battle Of Winterfell | Cinemablend
THE FINAL WAR
JOHN WICK vs. CHUCK NORRIS
TWO LEGENDS. TWO UNSTOPPABLE FORCES. ONE IRON THRONE.
WHO WILL SIT UPON THE IRON THRONE?
One fights for his dog. The other fights because he can.
The end might have been good if it wasn't rushed into a short season when it should have been multiple. The problem was the show was so detailed and drawn out -- then boom done and things didn't make sense. The White Walkers literally marching for a decade of real show time and then gone in one episode? Wild.
Sadly, disappointment is often left without reference and gets garbage collected. No conscientious effort are made to free it properly like for C or Rust.
Same here, and I didn't even discover his books until after he passed. I've read the entire Discworld series about half a dozen times since then, though.
Happy to! Actually, there have been specific events where this happened.
The main point is that a lot of people in the .NET community are not particularly happy about the fact that Microsoft seems to be very actively avoiding eating their own dog food, by creating various .NET technologies and then using something from a different tech stack internally for the most exciting and important new projects. For example, they created the .NET MAUI UI toolkit, but they pretty much just used React for half of Windows 11.
The most recent iteration of this controversy is that several serious, important Microsoft projects have been "won" by Rust or Go.
A big part of this drama started a while ago, when Typescript's compiler was rewritten in Go. A bit of context: Microsoft has been pushing something called NativeAOT for a while. NativeAOT was supposed to be .NET's response to Go, it's a new compile target for .NET languages that outputs native executables, without need for a dotnet runtime. The fact that Microsoft created their response to Go, but clearly didn't feel confident enough to actually use it over Go when it mattered, made a lot of people question if it was even worth investing in NativeAOT.
And I get the outrage, actually. If not even Microsoft uses it, why should you? I like C#, but I use Rust or Go for things like small command line utilities for this reason exactly. I completely understand why Go was chosen for the TS compiler and the set of reasons is good. That also signals, however, that Microsoft knows their "Go killer" isn't good.
Most recently, the headline came out that Rust became a "Tier-1 language at Microsoft", who has been rewriting a ton of stuff in Rust, not C#. This was a repeated blow, and many .NET developers have started to question whether Microsoft is actually serious in stewarding their own programming language for performance-critical use cases, of if the new narrative about runtime performance improvements, memory-safe unmanaged code support and NativeAOT is mostly the usual checklist for them to say "look! our tech stack does this too!", but without ever being seriously supported.
(EDIT): SOMETHING IMPORTANT I FORGOT! On top of that, Microsoft has had a habit of pushing and then basically abandoning various .NET technologies over the years. So, joining the outrage, there are plenty of .NET developers who are rightfully bitter, because the technology they had invested in was abandoned.
TL;DR: Microsoft has been making bold claims about committing to making .NET competitive for use cases where Go and Rust usually dominate, but their effort is being seen as u serious unserious by the .NET community, since the fact that Microsoft does not seem to use their own technologies for anything that matters themselves does not inspire faith.
I mean, still... .NET has been rewritten and released under a free software license, using it for MSR projects would help this rebrand feel more believable
Rust literally brought new type theory from academia into an industrial language to eliminate whole classes of bugs that previously had been uncheckable in systems languages. It brought the safety of a managed language to an unmanaged setting. It really is a step up beyond previous languages. To deny that because you think it is a “cult” is not a criticism in technical grounds, and is a pretty silly position.
You can write memory safe code without Rust my dude. You can also write buggy code with Rust because of the complexity: logic errors, race conditions beyond data races, panics, unsafe code, FFI boundaries, and rare type-system or lifetime edge cases.
You sound like one of those cultists. It is always the dev and the discipline and never the platform/language.
I’m not saying you can’t write buggy code with rust. I’m say that it’s impossible to write memory errors in (safe) rust. Of course it’s possible to write memory error free C++; people even do it occasionally . But it’s not humanly possible to write memory error free C++ continually. Fortunately computers can check that for us in other languages. rust is the first language that allows this without a garbage collector. That’s a monumental step forward. If you don’t understand how that is, in a real, technical sense better than C++, you’re being deliberately obtuse.
I’ve written rust professionally for seven years. In that time I’m pretty sure I’ve never written a memory errro. In my several years of C++, they were constant.
it’s impossible to write memory errors in (safe) rust
There are still gaps in that and your keyword was "safe". Sure it is harder but a statement like that is what I am talking about with the cult.
Problems like soundness bugs in unsafe abstractions, memory leaks are allowed in various setups (such as Rc/Arc reference cycles or std::mem::forget), and still a chance of out-of-memory (OOM) crashes from large allocations, integer overflow bugs (which can panic or wrap depending on build settings), or logic bugs.
Saying it is "impossible" is probabilistically wrong.
A big problem with Rust is the complexity and that can lead to issues as well.
I'd use Rust for very little but there are areas it makes sense. But if a company is Rust only I know that I would hate working with those devs so they mark themselves. In that aspect I am thankful for Rust.
Microsoft is increasingly doing rewrites of older systems in languages other than C#. First some parts of office in Rust, then TS in Go, then Steven Toub rewrote some github service in Rust too
Someone should model an LLM after him. No matter what goes in and how much time is taken for processing, it will either come up with a result no one asked it for, or random excuses as to why it's unable to complete the singular task it was asked to perform.
516
u/R15H1_3 21h ago
Now he'll spend another 15 years fighting the borrow checker instead of writing.
326
u/PuzzleMeDo 21h ago
Claude, write a better ending than the TV show had. Make no mistakes.
65
u/jakubiszon 21h ago
As a .NET guy I am deeply disappointed.
26
u/SarcasmWarning 21h ago
It's a 50/50 between being able to read The Winds of Winter and getting a usable kernel from GNU.
52
u/Banes_Addiction 21h ago
Terry Pratchett shoulda rewritten himself in Rust. It's memory safe.
17
u/Still_Box8733 20h ago
Dear .Net community, he doesn't C#, thats why he wears glasses.
30
u/chic_luke 20h ago
As someone who's followed that specific referenced drama in the .NET community, I audibly wheezed. God tier meme
3
u/Chunkz_IsAlreadyTakn 21h ago
C# with garbage handling... Not sure if thats a good thing.
17
u/-Animus 21h ago
@ .Net: Cause he's wearing glasses!
8
u/jay_resseg 21h ago
Thought I was in r/rustjerk for a sec
8
u/atanasius 20h ago
Soon he will publish 250,000 pages of The Winds of Winter.
14
u/Streakflash 21h ago
at least the story will not have plot holes
6
u/surykum36 21h ago
Pov: your manager asks for an ETA and you say its almost ready...
5
u/cortesoft 18h ago
Dani would have never forgotten about the Iron Fleet if she had Rust’s memory safety!
4
u/Hefty_Archer_1213 20h ago
He definitely won’t finish writing them in his lifetime.
3
u/7thpixel 20h ago
This guy lost everything in a corrupted WordStar file
2
u/psyfregle 21h ago
😂
2
u/SryInternet101 15h ago
We'll never see Winds of Winter while he's alive. Once he got that HBO money, he stopped writing. It won't be finished until he's dead.
2
u/mercury_pointer 14h ago
If he wrote it in Haskell the ending could be derived during compilation.
1
u/YeOldeMemeShoppe 19h ago
Have you not seen him? He needs to wear glasses.
1
u/Yossarian1993 19h ago
But first he rewrites the previous books in Rust
1
u/zeddash 19h ago
While I enjoy parallel storylines, I feel the limit is 3, and not just throwing rayon at a story and making it 16, that'll be so confusing.
1
u/stick_it_in_your_bum 17h ago
At this point I'll read it even if he writes in assembly.
1
u/herefromyoutube 15h ago
Fuck. I just learned GO.
1
u/sneedss1488 13h ago
rock is this tru?
1
u/Ozymandias_1303 8h ago
Since Duke Nukem Forever actually came out, TWOW and ADOS are the most legendary vapor-ware projects out there.
1
u/Eli_1984_ 19h ago
can he just shut up
1
u/Legal-Software 20h ago
Someone should model an LLM after him. No matter what goes in and how much time is taken for processing, it will either come up with a result no one asked it for, or random excuses as to why it's unable to complete the singular task it was asked to perform.
0
u/Few_Kitchen_4825 14h ago
Sounds like something elon and dhh would say to Martin
0
u/pyaracetamol0mg 11h ago
Ai writing better endings