So I took proper inventory of my products about a month ago , and have decided to do an analysis of each category. For me, Project Pan is about understanding why I have too much in some categories and getting that behaviour down so eventually I am left with only what I actually want rather than just buying whatever, so this is my personal review and audit of my skincare stash.
- Pic 1: flat-lay taken October 18th
- Other pics: Items I own that aren't in the flat-lay (were either at my boyfriend's or new since).
- Final pic: the status now. ❌ = Finished, ⏰= in progress, ❤️= gave to my boyfriend
The need and routine: Skincare is something I do daily. I use a face wash while showering, then moisturiser after. At night before bed I do the whole shebang: cleanser, toner, serum, eye cream and moisturiser. If I have worn makeup I will also use an eye makeup remover. Dots for spots/ spot stickers and nose pore strips are used as needed.
There are products listed here that are just not part of my routine though, usually because I didn't buy it. I'm not a face mask person, but a friend gave me these. I'm going to see if I can just use these on a night in or try and give away otherwise. The blemish sticks I got for use as needed, but TBH I don't know that I'm seeing much from them, so they're not really part of my routine and likely won't re-buy
Background and context: I travel a decent amount (my boyfriend lives in a different city and sometimes we also visit his family when doing so) plus we go on holiday 2-3 times a year. I therefore have both a home set (the regular size items) and a minis set (smaller sizes, which I keep in a separate toiletries kit that I can grab and go when packing). I learned that hard way that not having stuff at his was triggering purchases, but trying to put things in mini containers like I do for holidays was causing me to either forget certain categories (and hence shop at his) or caused certain products to go bad if left long-term in my travel containers. The minis are actually designed to hold the product for up to 12 months from opening and so work much better as a grab and go option for me.
Goal: I'd like to have only 1-2 spares max per category & size and only for items I love as my go-tos to be here.
Current status: I actually think that other than moisturiser, I am at my goal for the regular size. I typically only open one item at a time (e.g. for cleanser I would have one regular toner ongoing and one mini ongoing), so a lot of what is here is unopened and ready to grab when the existing runs out. Minis is where there's been a bit more experimenting due to grabbing whatever was available at my boyfriend's in the past. I know what most of my faves are now but I need to work on and use the ones I don't like so I can get them out of my inventory.
Where I have gone wrong and how I am correcting:
- For regular, it's just moisturiser that's the issue, though there is also one toner there I don't really want. This was due to "emergency buys" at my boyfriend's house - before I had the minis kit, I grabbed these to leave there but then eventually took them home. I also had a couple of times I thought I was about to run out of moisturiser or didn't have one, used a bit and then took the remainder home 🤦🏿♀️Now that I carry a minis set, this isn't an issue, but there's therefore this backlog to use.
- For minis, this is where things are a bit mad. I got packs of cleansing wipes so I would have a non-liquid option (recently did a work business trip). Again, moisturiser is my weakness though. As you can see I even recently got this Tatcha one, though TBH that was because I for some reason thought Body Shop was about to stop stocking the Vitamin E mini I usually use. I'm not too fussed overall, but need to use these wipes up lol.
Next steps: just doing my routine as usual, but going to force myself to use up the bits that aren't my faves. To prevent temptation and shopping, I have asked for the items I love that have run out or are about to as Christmas gifts. I usually struggle since I just buy these things myself and then have no gift ideas, so my wishlist has been really easy this year 😂
Finally, a review! 😡 = Not a fan, 😐 = okay, 😍 = love, 🤔 = pending use/ review
Cleanser (top row)
- Garnier micellar water (Vitamin C, yellow lid) 😡 - Basically am hate using to finish thus up. This one is frustrating - I usually use the green lid (combo skin) but the yellow was on offer and I didn't think anything of it. In reality , the Vitamin C is way too harsh on the skin in my opinion - it basically does it's job just a bit too well. Occasionally using other products after it will cause my skin to feel slightly burny where those products are usually fine, and that's only happened since using this cleanser. I obviously won't buy it again.
- Garnier micellar water (combo skin, green lid) 😍 - this stuff is perfect and what I usually use. I have also tried the sensitive (pink lid) one and love that too.
- Superdrug Micellar water 🤔 - only used once so far, it's in the minis kit. Seems fine so far.
- Body Shop cream cleanser 😐 too oily for my skin type. My boyfriend has dry skin though, and it's great for him. So effectively decluttered because it's his now.
- Superdrug Micellar cleansing wipes 😐 - will do for a non-liquid option, which is why I bought them, but don't beat using the actual water
- Superdrug cleansing facial wipes 🤔 Not tried yet
Toner (row 2)
- Body Shop Vitamin E toner 😍 - my absolute go to, as you can see I have it in mini too. It feels soothing and hydrating, and it's crazy expensive. Works for me.
- Boots Vitamin C toner 🤔 - not used, kinda dreading given how vitamin C cleanser has been.
- Superdrug mini toner (pic 4) 😐 - don't think anything is wrong with this, but it's nowhere near as hydrating as the Vitamin E one. Was a mini I bought at my boyfriend's house years ago so have just collected it to use up, but obviously won't re-buy.
Spot stickers (row 2 and pic 3)
- Dots for Spots 😍 - cheap in TK Maxx, seem to do the job. They don't necessarily do in one hit, so not sure if they're the best out there, but happy with them.
- Mighty patches 😐 - These were a travel size so in my minis kit. They do the job same as the Dots for Spots, but are more expensive and half the pack were the thicker "original" with the other half being the "invisible". Again, the Dots for Spots are all invisible, so I don't see tbe point.
- Starface patches 🤔 - I do really like these and think they perform, but it's annoying that they're in colours and not invisible, so more of an overnight wear only.
Serums
- Body Shop Vitamin E Bi-Phase serum 😍 - Great, it doesn't feel oily and is hydrating. Have asked for a new kne for Christmas haha
- Superdrug Vitamin E Hydrating mist 🤔 - not yet tried, will see how these go.
- Superdrug Vitamin C mini 😍 - actually really like these, they're hydrating and a perfect travel size. I have 2 spare as you can see.
- Superdrug Vitamin E skin oil 😡 - is just too greasy and definitely more an oil than the Body Shop one. It's also double the size of the Vitamin C serum, so takes up more room. Won't re-buy.
Eye cream (also row 3)
- Body Shop Vitamin E eye cream 😐 Does the job, but I actually think I may prefer the Superdrug one? It doesn't stand out to me.
- Superdrug Vitamin E eye cream 😐 I think good for what it is and feels hydrating. No issues buying again but also happy to branch out.
- Superdrug Vitamin C eye cream 😍 Does feel more brightening on the under-eye, would get again.
- Biovene retinol glow eyes 🤔 Not opened yet.
Moisturiser (row 4 and pic 6, plus night creams in row 5)
- Body Shop Vitamin E moisture gel 😍 Love this, it feels very k-beauty. I wanted to add a new one on my wishlist, but I have too many moisturisers and want to reduce them before I do
- Superdrug Vitamin C moisture gel 😍 TBH I actually really like this too and it's similar. Not sure if it's still being sold though. It will be next on the list after I get through the Witch stuff.
- Boots Vitamin C moisturiser 🤔 Not really used, time will tell.
- Witch SPF15 day cream 😐 Like so far, TBH this was an accidental buy because I thought I was ordering the night one! I'm using it in my morning routine at the moment but probably won't re-buy.
- Witch night cream 😍 really like this! I'm not sure I will buy again as I want to just have the one moisturiser I use for day and night going forward, but I would happily get again.
- Body Shop Vitamin E day cream mini 😍 this is perfect for my travel kit, I use it both day and night when doing so. It's hydrating and light, absolutely would get again.
- Simple hydrating moisturiser 😐 I like the formula, but hate the container and size. The container is awkward for getting all the product out, can't be cut open because it's thick, and it's an annoyingly large amount (50ml) for travel. If the container was different, it could be a travel go-to, but the packaging ruins it for me.
- Tatcha dewy milk moisturiser 🤔 I bought this purely because I thought the Body Shop one was about to stop selling (showed as out of stock for a bit). I haven't tried it yet, but doubt I will re-buy given the price point.
Blemish treatments (row 5)
- Witch blemish treatment sticks 😐 don't hate, but not really sure if they do anything. Don't have a need to re-buy.
- Starface pore-clearing nose strips 🤔 have only used once, but think they did do something. Time will tell, I don't need to use these frequently.
Eye makeup remover (row 5)
- Garnier eye makeup remover 😍 I love this, does the job really well and would definitely get again.
- Boots eye makeup remover pads 😍 Great for travel and also love these.
- Superdrug eye makeup remover wipes 🤔 Not opened, time will tell.
Masks: not tried any of these and wouldn't rebuy since I'm not a mask person.
Sorry that was so long! But what are other people's inventories like and lessons learned?