what scale do you use when you log your own energy?
i made a small energy diary for myself; as i'm an engineering student, i wants to do my hardest work when my energy is at it's best. it notifies me a few times during the day, i tap one of 4 energy levels. over time it builds up my energy curve so i can use the info for making better schedule. it also tells me when the pattern is changing. but i thought this might also be useful for people here who already track themselves, maybe more than it helps me for finding patterns in their own data.
btw, i'm not trying to sell anything or make any money with the app, made it for myself and thought maybe it could help other people as well.
The Result: A single-participant, blinded trial showed a statistically significant benefit of a supplement blend for sleep (+4.6 pts on a smartwatch sleep score; active 74.3 +/- 7.5, placebo 69.7 +/- 7.5, p = 0.03). Tinnitus symptoms did not show statistically significant improvement, though were close enough to be interesting.
The Real Takeaway: Observer bias. A prominent contributor in the self-experimentation world recently was questioning me whether blinded trials are worth the extra effort over standard (“open-label”) “buy-and-try” experiments. This trial is my answer. Blinded trials, in some circumstances, can be critical.
How Intuition Failed: The participant actively tried to guess the blind and was convinced he knew which was active, even when he flipped his guess midway, and then back again. Had he done a standard unblinded “buy-and-try,” he easily could have concluded a placebo was working and kept buying it indefinitely.
Sleep score by day.
Background: I had recently posted about a blinded, controlled trial on a colleague of a four supplement blend for tinnitus that failed to show any change at all (see link in comments). While we were running that trial, another colleague overheard and asked for a similar trial. The ingredient list looked interesting for tinnitus and for sleep. His doc recommended dropping magnesium from the original formula, so we used a 3-ingredient different blend: melatonin, B12, and zinc.
Placebo (Randomly assigned to Bottle B): Microcrystalline cellulose
Dosing: 1 per day, taken one hour before bed
Duration: Four periods (ABAB), each 2 weeks long, 56 days total.
Daily outcome tracking:
Ear ringing volume (0-5) (primary)
Ear ringing discomfort (0-5)
Smartwatch sleep score (0-100)
Smartwatch sleep duration (0-1440 minutes)
The participant was blinded throughout, but I was not. I spoke with the participant intermittently during the trial while trying to minimize ways that could have led the participant to infer which material was active. The trial was conducted before our automated trial software was built, and that had some unfortunate but fascinating consequences that will be detailed below.
Trial Execution: When Protocol Meets Reality I handed both bottles to the participant and thought I told him: “Take A once daily for 14 days, then switch to B for 14 days, then back to A and back to B again later.” A few days into the first period, I checked in. He indicated something akin to:
“Wow. I know that I’m blinded and you’re not going to tell me which is which, but this bottle [A] sure seems like it must be the real thing. My sleep is much better than it has been, and I think my ears are doing much better too. I know this might all be a placebo effect, but it sure doesn’t feel like it. I hope it’s real so I can get this benefit after I’m done with the trial. I printed out a calendar and am writing all the data down on it and can hand it to you when we’re done.”
In retrospect, he was right. A was the active. At the time, I tried to offer no hint of bias in my response, and simply encouraged him to continue.
Around Day 30, I checked back in, as he should have been two days into his third period (back on A). Instead, he had never switched, was still taking A and hadn’t opened the B bottle. Somehow our wires got crossed. We agreed to swap him over to B immediately, but also extend that B period to a full 30 days to help balance the dataset.
Around Day 38, I checked back in again. He should have been a week into his first B. Again, I was surprised:
“I know I had told you A was great, but this B stuff seems even better. Boy, the placebo effect must either have been strong on the A or stronger yet during B here. If I were to bet, I’d say that B must be the real thing.”
Now that he had switched his guess, he was wrong. A was the active, not B. Again, I attempted to stay neutral and simply recommended we continue. Around Day 53, thinking he should be deep into a 30 day B period, I re-inquired and got a bigger surprise that either of the previous:
“I’m already back on A. My sleep was getting bad and you had said your original intent was roughly two week periods, so I swapped back to A early. Is that okay?”
Meaning he switched his guess again and was convinced A was the active and changed the protocol attempting to get its benefit! Unlike the way a traditional trial administrator likely would have tackled this, I offered:
“It’s your trial, and your health, so it’s totally your call. I’m just here to help you as I can. If you want to terminate, let me know and we can do that at any time. I can always tell you what’s what and let you get on with it. But if we’re trying to do this cleanly, we need to pick these times ahead of time and stick to them. But it’s your call.”
He wanted to continue.
“Ok, let’s then keep you on this cycle of A to finish out the 14, then switch back to B for 14 but throw in another AB pair to get some more data at the end of that.”
He subsequently did that to finish his trial.
Results and Interpretation:
Prior to digging into the analysis, a few issues needed attention.
No-dose Days (Days 29-31). Recorded as if A had been continued, but excluded any outcome data. (Introduces a minor error into autocorrelation calculations, etc.)
External Confounders. The participant encountered a family health issue that introduced acute sleep disruptions, and some nights triggered use of a prescription sleeping pill. Nights that were either particularly disrupted or had a sleeping pill used were marked for exclusion at the time of the event. Because such challenges could have multiple day effects that exceed the exclusion, and because the selection bias of using this only bad nights, both of these could still affect results. I’m inferring neither seems likely to change our interpretation, but leave the audience access to the raw data to run alternative analyses.
Period Distortions. Shortening the first B because the participant sought to switch back to A early introduces risk for bias. We have done nothing to correct for that other than extending the trial through a pair of additional periods at the end (switching from a 4-period ABAB trial to a 6-period ABABAB trial).
Missing data. Several days were marked for exclusion or missing for reasons that were not recorded. These were noted but left unadjusted.
Shifting Endpoints. Originally, I had been under the impression the participant was primarily interested in tinnitus. However, at the end of the trial but before analysis, the participant said their primary interest was their smartwatch sleep score. We have performed the analysis with sleep score as the primary.
Scale Drift. Prior to trial start I had been of the impression that the tinnitus scale was going to be 0-5, but on the paper print out sheets used for data acquisition, the score range was marked 1-5. No measurements of 0 were made.
Inferring the Blind. Trying to guess the blind increases placebo effect risks. Here that was in part mitigated because his guess flipped twice.
Results:
Trial results table
Our standard statistical analysis was performed: an autocorrelation corrected, variance-weighted, crossover-averaged, Generalized Least Squares effect size estimation. A washout period of 0 days (no washout/onset delay was used), and the participant chose to use a 90% confidence threshold for analysis.
Sleep score: A +4.6 point difference (p = 0.03, 90% CI [1.1, 8.1]) in sleep score (active 74.3, placebo 69.7) was observed.
Tinnitus symptoms: The observed effect size (-0.2) on a (1-5) scale (treatment 2.2, placebo, 2.2)* didn’t meet the threshold for significance after a Holm adjustment (padj = 0.23), though would have been close for a 90% confidence threshold at p = 0.11 in the absence of that adjustment. If real, a -0.2 effect would have been of interest to the participant.
Sleep duration: The observed effect size (+2.7 mins) (treatment 404.3, placebo 397.5) didn’t meet the threshold for significance (padj = 0.23) after Holm adjustment.
(Note, the tinnitus and sleep duration difference, though not statistically significant (either unadjusted or Holm-adjusted) appear to be significant if using various washout periods other than the 0 day that was presumed prior to the trial.)
Conclusion and Takeaways:
The participant was shown the results and was thrilled. The participant indicated an intent to continue using these supplements in the future, was happy to hear this summary was going to be offered to others in case it might help them, and immediately started a new trial on a new supplement for a different outcome.
Blinding can beat “buy-and-try.” Even conscientious self-experimenters can underestimate the importance of observer bias. Had this participant picked up Bottle B at a store and been told it helps with sleep, he likely would have sworn by it. Blinding cuts through noise.
Real life self-trials run into real-life problems. Automated prompts via a smartphone on future trials will help in the future.
A hint at individual heterogeneity? Our previous tinnitus trial showed ZERO effect size on someone else. This closely related trial showed a sleep benefit and got close to (but did not) show a statistically significant tinnitus benefit. What works for others may not work for you. We’ll explore this more in a future write-up.
*For those reading closely, the tinnitus difference of -0.2 isn’t a typo. The average during A and B was each 2.2, but our model still predicts an average effect size of -0.2. A natural instinct is to think the modeled effect size should just be the difference between the two period averages, but our model actually looks at crossover sizes, using variance weighting and autocorrelation correction, and here shows the substantially different estimate that results from the simple global average difference. We think this technique offers a foundational advantage over a typical global average model.
Press started as a fitness planner I made just for myself. The more I used it, the more I wanted it to actually do something with my training data, not just store sets and reps. It slowly turned into a proper tracking app, and now I want to share it with everyone else who trains.
What it does with your numbers:
Fatigue Map**:** Each logged set feeds into a per-muscle fatigue estimate, so you can see what's recovered and what's still cooked before you plan the next session.
EMG-backed exercise data: Exercises are weighted by how much they actually work each muscle, based on EMG research, rather than a simple "chest day" label. It also accounts for things like incline angle.
1RM estimates: Instead of a single formula, it fits a ridge regression across your recent sets, so the estimate is less thrown off by one bad or great day.
No gamification: No streaks, badges or rings. Just the data and the programming.
It's early days and I'm looking for a handful of people who track their training seriously to try it and tell me where the model's wrong. I'm especially interested in whether the fatigue estimates match how you actually feel.
It's on the iOS App Store as Press: Fitness Planner & Log. Happy to answer anything about the methods in the comments.
I built this on WHOOP, but it can run on any tracker with an API. Every morning my strain, recovery and sleep become an alien world, posted to Instagram automatically as a video. I call it State Zero.
The art is AI-generated and free to run, because it uses Google Flow.
Want it on your tracker? Point your coding agent at the repo and ask it to swap WHOOP for yours.
It doesn't have to be alien worlds, either. Ask for something else: a daily trading card, a creature that changes with your sleep, a poster for your week.
I try to put together an updated version of this post once a year. The goal of this post is to find the most accurate wearable for each metric, using multiple validation studies that test devices against medical-grade equipment, mostly from independent researchers.
It covers sleep, HRV, resting and exercise heart rate, blood oxygen, steps, calories, VO2 max and breathing rate. The summary table is first, then the data for each metric, with caveats and linked sources at the end. Brand-funded studies and early research are marked.
I also built a free page that goes deeper into the data and lets you compare brands side by side. Full disclosure, it’s my site but I don't paywall anything and don't run ads: https://www.kygo.app/tools/wearable-accuracy
MASTER SUMMARY TABLE
Biometric
🥇 Winner
🥈 Second
🥉 Third
Sleep Stages
Oura (0.65 agreement)
Apple Watch (0.60)
Fitbit (0.55)
Sleep Timing
Fitbit (-3 min, 68% of wake caught)
Oura (-9 min, 69%)
Apple Watch (+8 min, 52%)
Nocturnal HRV
Oura (5.96% error)
WHOOP (8.17%)
Garmin (10.52%)
Resting Heart Rate
Oura (1.94% error)
Polar (2.71%)
WHOOP (3.00%)
Exercise Heart Rate
Apple Watch (2.51 bpm off)
Garmin (2.93 bpm)
Fitbit (3.89 bpm)
SpO2
Apple Watch (2.2 points off)
Samsung (3.8)
Garmin (4.1)
Step Count
Garmin (+3%)
Apple Watch (+7%)
Samsung (10.5% error)
Calories (weight training)
Fitbit (41.7% off)
Samsung (84.5%)
Apple Watch (112.2%)
VO2 Max
Garmin (6.7% error)
Google Pixel (8.65%)
Apple Watch (13.2%)
Respiratory Rate
Fitbit (within 1 breath/min)
WHOOP (+0.1)
-
DETAILED DATA BY METRIC
1. SLEEP STAGES (agreement on a 0 to 1 scale, 1 = perfect)
Device
Agreement
Deep Sleep Caught
REM Caught
Oura Ring Gen 3
0.65
79.5%
76.0%
Apple Watch Series 8
0.60
50.5%
82.6%
Fitbit Sense 2
0.55
61.7%
67.6%
WHOOP 3.0*
0.44
62%
66%
Samsung Galaxy Watch 5*
0.42
47.5%
62.7%
Polar Vantage V*
0.28
33%
49%
Garmin Forerunner 245*
0.25
28%
50%
Source: Robbins 2024 (top 3), 35 adults, one night in a sleep lab, Oura-funded. Others: Miller 2022 (WHOOP, Polar, Garmin), Lee 2023 (Samsung)
Note:*From separate studies, so compare loosely. An independent preprint also ranks Oura first.
2. SLEEP TIMING (does it know when you were asleep vs awake)
Device
Total Sleep
Wake Time Caught
Fitbit Sense 2
-3 min
68%
Oura Ring Gen 3
-9 min
69%
Apple Watch Series 8
+8 min
52%
WHOOP 3.0*
-12 min
56%
Polar Vantage V*
-1 min
51%
Garmin Forerunner 245*
+44 min
27%
Source: Robbins 2024 (top 3), Oura-funded. Others: Miller 2022
Note:Ranked across six timing measures. Fitbit and Oura are very close. *Separate studies.
3. NOCTURNAL HRV
Device
Error (MAPE)
Agreement (CCC, 1 = perfect)
Oura Ring 4
5.96%
0.99
WHOOP 4.0
8.17%
0.94
Garmin Fenix 6
10.52%
0.87
Polar Grit X Pro
16.32%
0.82
Source: Dial 2025, 13 adults, 536 nights vs a chest strap. No industry funding
Note:The Oura vs WHOOP gap was not statistically significant. Apple wasn't tested.
4. RESTING HEART RATE
Device
Error (MAPE)
Oura Ring 4
1.94%
Polar Grit X Pro
2.71%
WHOOP 4.0
3.00%
Source: Dial 2025 (same study as HRV)
Note:Polar and WHOOP are within noise of each other. Garmin was excluded due to a data issue.
Note:The top four are within a few percent. Samsung came last in a separate treadmill test, so it misses the top 3. WHOOP 4.0 was 8.52% off on a treadmill.
Note:No watch is FDA-cleared for blood oxygen. Oura and WHOOP have no peer-reviewed test.
7. STEP COUNT
Device
Overcount or Error
Garmin
+3%
Apple Watch
+7%
Samsung Galaxy Watch 4
10.5%
Fitbit
+15%
Polar Vantage V / M
72%
Source: Paluch 2026 meta-analysis of 59 studies (Garmin, Apple, Fitbit); Hong 2024 (Samsung), Henriksen 2022 (Polar)
Note:Garmin, Apple and Fitbit figures are average overcounts; Samsung and Polar are error figures from single studies. Oura's step figures predate its 2025 algorithm update, so they aren't ranked.
Note:Ranked on weight training and cycling; Samsung's lower treadmill figure comes from the abstract-only study. No wearable is a precise calorie counter, especially for lifting.
Note:Garmin's error was far higher without a chest strap. The Pixel study was Google-funded. Apple reads low.
10. RESPIRATORY RATE
Device
Result
Fitbit Charge 4
+0.3 to +1.0 breaths/min
WHOOP 2.0
+0.1 breaths/min (WHOOP-funded)
Note:Fitbit from Hermans 2024, WHOOP from Berryhill 2020. Garmin failed in hospital patients (Knevels 2026, Helmer 2024) and Apple gave no readings (Helmer 2024, AbiMansour 2024). Skin temperature isn't ranked: no brand has an independent sensor test.
IMPORTANT CAVEATS
No single device wins everything. Oura leads most overnight metrics; Apple, Garmin and Fitbit split the rest.
The main sleep study was Oura-funded. Its methods are sound, and an independent preprint also ranks Oura first.
Validation studies often take 1 to 3 years to publish, so tested models usually lag behind current ones. Newer models may do better.
Samples are small: 35 people for sleep, 13 for HRV and resting heart rate.
Calories are weak on every device. Use them as a rough trend.
Skin tone, tattoos, fit and wrist position all affect accuracy.
I'm 31 and switched careers recently. I'm a kindergarten teacher now. Being around the kids all day is the part I didn't expect to like this much. Some days wipe me out. But then it's greeting them at the door, hugs and a bit of encouragement, or one of them telling me I'm their favorite teacher, and the day gets a lot easier.
My last job was pretty stressful. This one's a lot calmer, and I've actually got the bandwidth to pay attention to my own health again.
I used to average around 7h of sleep a night and my scores were often below 60. I've been checking my records more regularly lately, and the latest one surprised me: 9h of sleep, average SpO2 98%, average respiratory rate 18/min, everything marked normal, sleep score 74.
I can't tell how much of it is the job change. I'm just happier and less wound up day to day, and I'm trying not to let my own stuff slide again.
Between shifts and taking care of my mom, most days feel like one long to-do list: Did she eat? When's the next appointment? What do we need to pick up? How's she been doing... It's all just running in my head.
I'm an administrative assistant, so the workdays are busy on their own. I kept telling myself I'd check in on my own health at the end of the day, but by the time I got home I was too wiped to write anything down.Looking at my summary card for Nov 17 put the whole day into perspective.
On the surface, my baseline looked decent. I finally got a solid night of sleep from 23:15 to 06:55 with an 83 sleep score, my average heart rate was 65.75 bpm, and my stress readout still showed Balanced.
Then I looked at the rest of the grid: between rushing across the office, running errands, and walking back and forth at my mom's place, I logged 16,758 steps and ended up stress-eating nearly 2,910 kcal just to keep going. Worse, I had to log a dizziness spell mid-day right after finally remembering to take my own 11:20 medication.
I don't track every single detail obsessively. The last thing I need is my own health, turning into another chore I feel guilty about not finishing. Just seeing the steps, dizziness note, and sleep window side by side made me realize I've been running on adrenaline even on days when I slept okay.
When you're juggling full-time work and caregiving, what small boundary or habit actually helps you slow down before your body forces you to?
Hello guys, do you have any feedback on this app? Personally I am testing it since a while and I have to say that is is really nice. You can log all the activities and metrics from your sportwatch and food as well, all in one app. The app shows you a TON of data for your activities and performances together with your food habits. It even go deeper inside the micronutrients in your blood in any specific moment of the day, see how elements are interacting with each others, ets. You also have priva mode in case you want all the data on the phone. Plus you have a log book for all the feedbacks, bug and improvement with the stuff answering you super quickly. I am also using Sonar and My Fitness Pal but in this case you must have 2 subscription and they have half of the data of fitnessrec. Anyone of you can share their opinion on it? Are you using it?
For those that wanna try i will recommend it for the moment, but I will update you in the future.
Old, but gold speech on radical QS. It seems like it hasn't been posted here before.
Accidentally found this talk on The Quantified Scientist channel many of you are probably familiar with there. He's doing an accuracy test for wearables.
Unfortunately, it seems like he did not continue posting more on this experience.
I have put significant time into collecting all of my medical records and now have 1659 pages from all of my primary care, specialists, blood test, insurance, and more! I think I might be most extensive N=1 random 23 yo on the internet in terms of understanding my own health.
I originally collected these for figuring out how my chronic issues (asthma, allergies, reflux) are related and how to best address them. They have been super helpful for that and I now want to move onto optimizing my health from a longevity POV.
Do you guys have any ideas of things I should look for (well AI will do the looking) or things I should try to track for optimization over all of this data? Thanks in advance!
P.S. I am thinking about making my record collection tool open source so others can use it to collect and look at all of their records. This will be a bit of work though so if anyone is interested lmk and I will work to make this happen.
I started tracking my blood pressure, resting heart rate and workouts after a heart diagnosis a couple of years ago. Over time I’ve noticed some things seem to help and some I’ve learned to avoid, but it’s mostly been me eyeballing patterns.
For those of you who track health stuff alongside exercise, sleep, supplements or whatever else, what have you actually discovered? And how do you tell a real pattern from noise?
Working on a way to track brain health, locally on your computer, using IndexedDB. One of the games is how fast you can tap in 30 seconds. Post your scores in the comments
Between shifts and taking care of my mom, most days feel like one long to-do list: Did she eat? when's the next appointment? what do we need to pick up? how's she been doing... It's all just running in my head.
I'm an administrative assistant, so the workdays are busy on their own. I kept telling myself I'd write it all down at the end of the day. By the time I got home I was too tired to write anything, and I never stuck with it.
I looked back at what I'd actually logged in recently and there was almost nothing there. Today's numbers were 5h32m of sleep, 3,464 steps, sleep score 69.
Sleep's been rough. Mom's been unwell and I worry about her a lot, and work's been hectic too. I can't really tell how much is that and how much is just being overloaded.
I'm still not tracking every day. I'm just trying to make it less of a chore, because the last thing I need is my own health. Turning into another item on the list I feel bad about not finishing.
I'm hoping next month gets a bit steadier, mentally more than anything. For anyone else juggling work and caregiving, what actually helps you sleep when your mind won't switch off?
I've spent the last year building out a fairly instrumented daily tracking setup. Oura for sleep, Whoop for HRV. For most inputs I have numbers and at least a rough sense of whether what I'm doing is working.
However, light is the exception. I go outside in the morning. I dim lights at night. I have no data on any of it. That gap started bothering me when I looked at what the research says we should be targeting. Brown et al. 2022 published consensus recommendations for healthy adults: daytime above 250 melanopic EDI at the eye, under 10 in the three hours before sleep, under 1 during sleep. Melanopic EDI is not the same as lux. Lux measures photopic brightness, weighted to how the eye perceives visible light overall. Melanopic EDI (m-EDI) uses a different spectral weighting, centered on ~480nm, tuned to what the melanopsin/ipRGC system responds to. Two light sources can have the same lux and very different m-EDI values. A 2700K warm lamp and a 6500K cool lamp are a good example: similar lux, different circadian signal. Phone lux apps estimate photopic illuminance using the front-facing camera sensor. The estimates are rough (camera sensors aren't photometrically calibrated), and none of them attempt m-EDI. I haven't found a consumer tool that measures m-EDI at the eye. Research-grade spectroradiometers do, but they cost thousands and nobody's carrying one around.
Then there's UV. A lot of people in this sub track vitamin D through blood tests, but almost nobody measures their actual UV exposure throughout the day. UV-A passes through window glass unevenly, so your indoor UV near a window is more variable than you'd think, and it drops to almost nothing a few feet away. If you're trying to understand your vitamin D picture beyond a quarterly blood draw, real-time UV data would give you a much better sense of how much you're actually getting.
Is the light tracking neccessary in your experience? Where and why would you use it?
Disclosure:I'm the co-founder of Onda. We're building a phone accessory with calibrated sensors for m-EDI, lux, and UV. You place it once, take a reading, get all three channels. Nothing to sell yet. I'm posting here because I want to pressure-test the concept with people who care about measurement methodology