Hi there! There is a lot of gacha on the market... so many that it's hard to find THE perfect one.
What would be the ideal gacha if you have to mix only the existing ones?
As for me, I only played Reverse1999, HSR and NTE but I do know the other most popular games (thanks to you and thanks to friends playing it).
-----
🎨 Artistic direction: Reverse1999 (the artstyle, the illustrations and the UI design). Arknights' and Morimens' are really great too.
🧝🏾 Charadesign: Reverse1999 for the fashion sense and style / Sword of Convallaria for the variety (good ratio, senior people-)... and and I'd love more melanin so yeah Re1999 again and I think that Granblue has good variety too? So more variety in melanin and body types (enough with the 3 sizes of boobz and 2 heights for women), no free goonz and waifu who have the same face/same haircut/same dress syndrome. uwu"
Bonus mention if the MC is stylish (so are Vertin from Re1999 and Munin from Silver Palace).
💥 Animation & 3D environment: 100% WuWa, the 3D landscapes are beautiful. ZZZ also does have good animation.
🎮 Battle gameplay: i love turn-based RPG so maybe HSR, Another Eden or Chaos Zero Nighmare. If it's action RPG, I don't know, I only played NTE and it was indeed fun but I do think WuWa and ZZZ look more dynamic. For the stuff and farm, something easy like Reverse1999 is great (only one weapon that you can get in events and you can level up other things).
🏢 Exploration gameplay: NTE's exploration is really fun to do, not frustrating and easy to climb buildings and co. Love the urban setting too. WuWa's exploration seems great too, the new mecha thing looks amazing!
🎼 Music & Sound design: hmm I don't know much but I do love Reverse1999 ost and EP. "Goodbye" rent free in my head... + Another Eden OST too!
✍🏼 Writing: Reverse1999 again. The cultural research they do is so on top and it reflects in their way of writing. BUT the quality can be variable, it depends of the chapter. I did hear that Limbus Company's writing is good too, I will try later! I also love the story of Another Eden but the writing is also variable.
🌎 Lore: I did love the idea of HSR's lore (space setting with us going planet to planet) BUT it's badly done. SO I'd go with Reverse1999 again and its time travel lore and Chaos Zero Nightmare seemed cool too with its horror vibes (only the LORE okay, I really don't like the goonz).
🎲 Gacha mechanics: the rates in Re1999 are generous and I love the fact that NTE doesn't have 50/50. Not predatory, not paying to get the best team to complete endgames. Spending 15$ for a beautiful skin in Re1999 seems fair to me too (they're really top quality, changing the 2D animations too).
-----
As you can see, all games have a PERFECT element... buuuut aaah the flaws can be too much, preventing me from playing the games T_T ... (I don't even play gacha games anymore for now). It's too bad...
At first, Silver Palace had my hopes up for it to be THE perfect gacha (dynamic action RPG x stylish female MC x detective setting x Reverse1999 vibes???) but I'm really not fond of some of the designs (body types, not-so-much victorian setting...) and their ads are cringe so... I will try it but it won't be THE PERFECT gacha.
The mic is yours, queens~