r/RPGdesign • u/Maervok • 19h ago
Theory Maybe I'm stating the obvious, maybe it's a hot take but haven't seen it discussed much: Be careful how you work with opinions which are popular here and in similarly oriented communities.
I've been lurking around here for over a year now and at first, I took all the popular (upvoted) opinions and advice here, or at r/rpg, at face value. Over time though, I realised that there's a nuance to it and it may not be as obvious especially to new aspiring designers.
When an opinion receives praise and upvotes here, it's valid BUT it is validated by people who are deeply invested in the TTRPG hobby (at least enough to be participating in discussions here). This is where it gets tricky because more casual player base may not vibe with what's popular here. I'll highlight a few examples:
Classless Systems: When a discussion "Classes vs. Classless" begins here, you will find a lot of excitement for the classless approach. But it's coming from people who spend more time with TTRPG's than your average player. For many people here, having more freedom to build their character is a benefit with no real added difficulty. However, your friends who just want to try a TTRPG will have an archetype in mind - Legolas, Gimli, Hermione, Conan the Barbarian, you name it, and they just want to pick an archetype that's closest to their idea and play.
Levelless Systems: Another popular topic are systems with more natural character progression than a defined set of levels where you make a stop and say "Yey, suddenly you're better!" The arguments against levels is that they feel too gamey, not immersive, and it's true but again a casual player is absolutely fine with levels. They do not care that it feels gamey, it never even crosses their mind unless you outright tell them. People are hardwired to mentally divide time and progression into periods and numbers - there's a reason why we have days, weeks, months, years and so on. We want a defined point we can look forward to and levels satisfy that simple need.
Avoiding Perception / Knowledge checks: This has been a recent discussion here and one that I agree with in many ways. The argument is that using a dice roll, such as a Perception check, to determine if a character sees something, kills roleplay - and it's true. However, a lot of people will not feel the need or be creative enough to roleplay a simple search. They will just want to roll a die and see what the result gives them. Even from the perspective of the GM, who may be tired and just wants to chill with friends, saying "Yeah roll me for Perception" is somewhat easier than finding ways to make an improvised search narratively satisfying.
Now my point isn't to say classless / levelless / perception-check-less systems are not good. My point is that they will draw the attention of a more invested crowd rather than a casual player base. You need to know your target audience. I have 10 people in my close social circle who are interested TTRPG's. Only 2 of them want to read and discuss the rules, the rest just wants to come to a session, spend time with friends, chuck some dice, roleplay some shenanigangs, see a story unfold and go home happy not thinking about the game much until the next session comes. If they do think about the game in the meantime, it's because of the cool funny moments, not because of mechanics and complexity.
If you go to your friends and show them your cool classless / levelless / perception-check-less system it may not be met with as much enthusiasm as with people here. It may be met with confusion and annoyance because the options and depth you offer them is not what they want from playing TTRPG's. And one last warning, your friends may even get excited discussing a classless system but the moment you actually start a campaign and show them a list of your abilities, don't be surprised if they're not bothered with reading through them - they might think they want options but when push comes to shove, they just want a level up and get a single new ability to memorize.
To clarify, I'm only using the things above as examples. The topic relates to many other ones.