A perfect storm... Did I get scammed for this collectors box?
Sold a sealed MTG collector box on Facebook Marketplace. Buyer says it was resealed. What would you do?
This part I am only mentioning for context, and to warn people against using FB Marketplace:
I sold a Secrets of Strixhaven Collector Booster Box for $480 through Facebook Marketplace checkout. The app said the USPS label was prepaid, but when the clerk scanned the QR code, they said postage hadnât been paid. I paid for a new label myself, kept the receipt, and sent the buyer the new tracking number in Messenger. Facebook wonât let me replace the original tracking number, so the last time I checked, the order still said âShipping label createdâ and was at risk of being automatically canceled. The support form kept erroring out, but I finally got a case submitted through the mobile app.
The buyer has now confirmed they got the package, but says the box was resealed and had baseball cards and bulk cards inside. Theyâre asking for a refund and offered to send it back. I took photos before shipping: the box was closed and the wrap had Wizards logos. The wrap is a little loose and wrinkled at the top, but I donât see an obvious cut or tape. The buyerâs photos show the box already opened, so I canât compare the seal as it arrived.
I donât know what happened between packing it and the buyer opening it, and I havenât issued a refund. For people who sell sealed MTG: does this wrap look suspicious to you, or is that amount of slack normal? And has anyone gotten Meta to manually fix tracking or successfully disputed a claim like this? What evidence actually helped? Is there any hope in going to Wizards?
For context, I received this box directly from Wizards for winning a Magic Arena Direct win-a-box.
Assuming this isn't just a straightforward scam on the part of my buyer... I see no reason to keep spending money on Magic Arena (I probably spend several thousand annually) if I can't trust their sealed product to be sealed. What am I supposed to do, unseal it and check it myself?
(Sealed photos I took, unsealed photos are from the buyer)
Edit: consensus seems to be buyer is scamming me and I should not use FB marketplace. It seems like the same thing could happen on ebay or similar "better" sites, no?