r/ResearchML • u/hmi2015 • 23m ago
What do you think of deep-ml and tensortonic for ML practice?
r/ResearchML • u/hmi2015 • 23m ago
r/ResearchML • u/statistically_me • 47m ago
I am posting this hoping for someone who maybe was in a similar situation because I'm genuinely frustrated. I am aware I am not an exceptional candidate for research. I do not know every concept or theory in details but there is no way I can prove that as someone who's not from a top university. I recently moved to a french school, a pretty good one, however before I was in my home country where I couldn't do research and my uni was just a random one really. I am really passionate about learning, I am used to always studying and research on my own; in fact I have been carrying my whole academic career on my own but that's not something I can prove with my CV so far since I have no prior research experience in an actual lab. So it's really hard to stand out as a candidate when there are so many who had prior research experience.
I am asking for advice because I am really motivated and passionate about ML and particularly RL with a strong interest in Operational Research as well and would like to know how to show that through my CV if that's even possible. So far I have been rejected from internships from the first screening phase and it's really frustrating because at least if I am given the chance for an interview and I fail then I know it's my fault and I would have a clearer idea on what I need to improve.
r/ResearchML • u/prodigy_ai • 2h ago
r/ResearchML • u/Robonglious • 2h ago
I've been doing solo research for 2 years, largely failing but keeping everything to myself. I'm confident that you're all going to tell me to just stop, but I can't. The questions are too interesting for me to ignore them. For whatever reason I'm not satisfied with what we know about LLMs, and I just can't seem to look away.
I have these huge goals which I generally fail at but along the way I find things that work. Sometimes I see them published by others and for me it doesn't really matter because I'm literally just some guy with no credentials.
This happened again recently with the article below. I can add quite a bit to this story and for me it has some really cool implications.
Neurons as an Interpretable Basis - Goodfire
So, what am I supposed to do? I have a hand full of mechanisms that appear to be new, and I guess I want that to mean something to someone.
r/ResearchML • u/LowAnteater6823 • 10h ago
I read a couple of older posts on ICML still publishing in these kind of cases, but I am interested in knowing more about ICLR and NeurIPS, especially due to issues such as no visa slots from the applicant's country, colliding visa status etc.
I would be really grateful for any information, as I would feel devastated if my paper is accepted in any of these conferences, but I cannot attend the in-person conference.
r/ResearchML • u/Ok-Memory6156 • 16h ago
I just want to respond to the people defending reviewers under the pretext that reviewing is voluntary work. It is NOT, and these people are not doing anyone a favor. It is a trade; you review someone else's paper to get yours reviewed, else yours gets desk-rejected. It's that simple and irresponsible reviewers cannot hide behind the charity argument to justify their recklessness.
r/ResearchML • u/FrequentPosition1279 • 13h ago
A reviewer gave my ICLR 2027 submission a 1 (clear reject) with confidence 2 ("I have broad familiarity with this field but little or no direct research experience on this topic"). After the author-reviewer discussion closed, they changed their confidence to 4 ("I have substantial direct research experience on this topic"). Their rating and review text were not changed.
For context, the other two reviewers gave 3 (weak accept). One confirmed our rebuttal addressed their main concerns, while the other did not respond.
For the reviewer who gave a 1, we added their requests to the revised manuscript (a summary table, ablations, and additional baselines). They replied by restating their original concerns without engaging with our responses or the changes to the paper.
This looks very odd to me, since I believe we addressed their concerns. Is a 2→4 confidence change like this reasonable, or does it look like bad faith? I guess it is unlikely that the reviewer became an expert in this topic over night... Is there anything I can or should do, e.g., ask the PCs to inform the AC? OpenReview no longer allows authors to add or edit comments, and it doesn't show the confidence change in the revision history.
r/ResearchML • u/noticesme • 1d ago
I saw a high school student applying to US colleges who already had several NeurIPS workshop papers (first author). Feels like this is becoming pretty common now.
Is this actually realistic for high schoolers or are we just seeing more AI-assisted autoresearch slop? Genuinely curious what people in ML research think.
r/ResearchML • u/Plastic_Yak_6726 • 9h ago
Title: How Does One Progress from Implementing Existing Research to Conducting Original AI Research?
Body:
I'm interested in understanding what separates someone who can implement existing machine learning models from someone capable of conducting original research.
I'd like guidance on:
Which research skills should be developed early, and which should come after mastering the fundamentals?
What books, research communities, journals, conferences and resources would you recommend?
r/ResearchML • u/OT-FasterScience • 1d ago
Are you interested in using AI tools with trusted scholarly content, including publications available through your institutional library?
We're trying to better understand how researchers use AI to find, read and analyze scholarly literature, and where improvements could be made.
We would really appreciate 3-5 minutes of your time to complete this short questionnaire. Your feedback will help us improve how researchers work with scholarly content using AI.
https://forms.gle/wzgqtYfURSUJiqGA6
Many thanks for your help!
r/ResearchML • u/No-Mud-1902 • 1d ago
My paper got initial scores of 2 2 3 and reviewers that wanted a bunch of experiments but who did not answer. One of them just increased one of their sub-scores (I think the soundness one) in the last rebuttal hour (without any feedback) in what am guessing is an attempt to show they did something.
Does it make sense to contact the program chairs about this? I know this is quite common in this ICLR edition but am thinking maybe this will put my situation on their radar.
Thanks!
r/ResearchML • u/No_Difference9752 • 1d ago
Reviews deleted. Reviewers recommending clear reject without understanding the paper: and ghosting. Reviewers writing LLM written reviews and then not updating scores. Reviewers asking for a complete rewrite and then saying we don’t have time to read. Reviewers not updating scores even when they have nothing legitimate to complain about.
Is this anymore a legitimate conference?
I am a final year student pending acceptance on multiple papers that seem hopeless. Should I just withdraw everything and just send it to poorer conferences?
r/ResearchML • u/BorntobeaWarrior • 1d ago
I’m curious about how feasible it is to reproduce an existing machine learning research paper, introduce meaningful improvements, and publish the results as a new paper.
I’ve come across discussions suggesting that building upon existing research and making incremental improvements can be a relatively straightforward path to publication.
For those with research experience, how difficult is this in practice?
What level of novelty or improvement is generally required for a paper to be considered publishable, particularly in reputable conferences or journals?
r/ResearchML • u/Puzzled-Ant5209 • 1d ago
Hello, I am a second year undergraduate and I am interested in doing AI/ML research.
I am interested in working on a research project to allow SLMs (less than 100M parameters) to be trained with much larger vocabularies under a fixed parameter and compute budget, perhaps with some compressed representation of sorts. Because at model sizes that small, the embedding layer takes up a significant number of parameters making vocab size a bottleneck. It also appears that this is a topic that is not yet saturated with research. Will such a research project provide any value and is it is worth pursuing at all?
Also feel free to DM me if you have any interesting ideas and want to collaborate on this project.
r/ResearchML • u/Important-Spirit-912 • 1d ago
r/ResearchML • u/RadioEconomy8481 • 1d ago
Quick question about ICLR 2027: Can reviewers still change their scores on OpenReview during the reviewer-AC discussion period? And if they do, can authors see the updated score in real time, or is everything hidden until decision day?
r/ResearchML • u/caesar______ • 1d ago
a reviewer responded to my rebuttal and said that they would raise their score from 2 to 3, but they still haven't updated it :'( now my paper shows 233 with an average of 2.67, but based on the reviewer's response, the actual scores should be 333!
would the AC take the reviewer's response into account, or would they only consider the officially submitted score of 2?
r/ResearchML • u/Icy_Ad9766 • 1d ago
r/ResearchML • u/Muted-Thought8181 • 2d ago
One of the official reviews on my ICLR submission now shows up as “[Deleted].” The part that surprised me is that the reviewer had replied to my rebuttal saying they were keeping their score. That reply is still there, but the review itself is gone. My paper now has two visible reviews.
I’ve emailed the program chairs and so far I’ve only received the automatic acknowledgment. I saw a few people mention something similar here. Has anyone heard back from the chairs, or actually seen a replacement review appear? I’m trying to understand what happens next for papers in this position.
r/ResearchML • u/TopWeakness9146 • 2d ago
Some papers are being desk-rejected, and some reviews are being deleted from OpenReview after the rebuttal period has ended. Does anyone know what’s going on?
r/ResearchML • u/impatiens-capensis • 3d ago
Yes, the review process is broken. Yes, we all hate it. But I'm going to propose something that sounds mean upfront, even though it's a hard truth that will make you a better researcher: your work sucks, too.
I genuinely don't think the anger and frustration with the conference process is about doing good science. We all know that to get a big bucks FAANG job, you need top-tier papers. And we all want that money. So, we submit our work, get mediocre reviews, and try to put the blame elsewhere. We're not trying to truly contribute to science. We just want the checkmark on our resumes. And that is making science worse. Why should we expect reviewers to put in substantial effort when the work and knowledge we generate is meaningless?
If your work is actually good, it can be consequential without ever being accepted. Take "Distilling the Knowledge in a Neural Network" by Hinton and others. It has 37,000 citations, yet it was never accepted into a main proceedings. It was rejected from NeurIPS for being incremental and an engineering hack. Still, the work is extremely consequential.
The problem is, your work isn't consequential. And the reason I know that is because my work isn't any good either. We're all in such a rush to push our slop into conferences for those big paychecks that we've basically made it impossible to do good science.
So I'm begging you... slow down and take more time to really go deep. You will produce fewer but more consequential works. The problem isn't the conferences or reviewers. It's that our work is garbage to begin with.
r/ResearchML • u/Ok-Ebb6307 • 2d ago
Hi everyone!
My name is Virginie, and I'm a third year PhD student based in France, researching how people interact with generative AI.
About a year ago, I had the opportunity to share a study with this community, and I would like to thank you again for your help and participation!
I'm happy to share the resulting dataset with you, which is now publicly available on Mendeley Data. The associated article is currently under submission. The dataset is publicly available on Mendeley Data: Lepont, V., Fleury, S., Gorisse, G., & Christmann, O. (2026). Who Wants Human-Like AI_DataSet (V4). Mendeley Data. https://doi.org/10.17632/br95hv3bt8.4. The associated article is currently under submission.
I'm currently conducting a short, anonymous online study (around 7 minutes) and would really appreciate your participation.
If you're 18 or older and have been using generative AI tools like ChatGPT, Replika, Claude or similar platforms for at least 6 months, you're eligible to participate.
The study has been approved by my university's ethics committee and all responses are anonymous.
I'm aiming to collect at least 1000 responses so every contribution makes a difference!
If you'd like to participate, you can find the survey link : https://virginie-lepont.limesurvey.net/555958?newtest=Y
Thank you for your time and for helping with my research!
Virginie
r/ResearchML • u/a-kemeklis • 1d ago
I achieved order-of-magnitude performance improvements by training a small language model on a constrained version of the TinyStories dataset (https://zenodo.org/records/23306194): a ~10x smaller model trained on ~10x less data (constrained to a smaller world with less unique places, objects, adjectives, etc.) (~100x less compute total) achieved comparable LLM-as-a-judge story output quality scores to the original TinyStories-33m param model, just within the smaller world. Also, what the model knew about (specific places, objects, adjectives, etc.) could be controlled. I believe this is scalable up to trillions of parameters and tokens for order-of-magnitude performance and safety gains. If you are interested helping me scale up, please message or comment below!
r/ResearchML • u/Visual-Intention-318 • 1d ago
Ever since that MIT CSAIL paper on Weight-Space Programming dropped, people have been arguing if LLMs actually understand neural net weights or if theyre just brute-forcing it.
So we built WeightBench and locked Claude 5.5, GPT-6.1-sol, and DeepSeek v4-flash in a strict CPU sandbox so they cant cheat with hidden forward passes or gradient descent.
The Good: GPT-6.1-sol and Opus 5.5 can literally working game-playing networks (Breakout, Go) from all zeros, without ever running the model.
The Bad: They still suck at fixing bugs in LLMs without breaking other stuff, cant compress models for hardware, and basically guess at random when given impossible tasks.
Overall scores (out of 1.0):
GPT-6.1-sol: 0.57 | Opus 5.5: 0.55 | Sonnet 5.5: 0.49 | Haiku 5.5: 0.43 | DeepSeek v4-flash: 0.23