r/Reverb • • 22h ago

Scammers or Long time trusted sellers? Who gets punished by Reverb?

0 Upvotes

I want to give two scenarios:

  1. We have a brand new Reverb seller with no proven track record. Could be legitimate or maybe is a scammer. Wants to sell a $2500 item. Reverb has a new policy where the new seller of that item gets paid 1-6 business days after the item is delivered to prevent fraud. This new policy if for items $2500+ Seems reasonable.
  2. We have a long time trusted seller that has been selling on Reverb since the beginning. This established seller has never had a problem, delivers great service, sells expensive items that generates Reverb a lot of money from fees they take in. This a seller Reverb loves having on their platform and wants to keep (you would think). This seller has been paid in a timely manner for 13 years, and now the new policy forces this trusted long time seller to wait several days after the item is delivered to get paid (at least a week longer than normal)

Does it make sense for Reverb to punish the long time sellers with no issues and make them wait a week or more longer than normal receive their own money, when there is very little risk of these tried and true sellers having future issues? It makes more sense to enforce the new policy on unproven new accounts where there is a higher risk of fraud, not established sellers.

There have been many long time, trusted sellers with proven track records that are considering switching to other platforms like ebay, Sweetwater Gear Exchange, or Facebook Marketplace, where there isn't this extended unnecessary waiting period.

If you are a long time trusted Reverb seller, reach out and voice your opinion to any of these people to ask for a fair compromise where the new policy is for unproven sellers and established sellers are exempt :

If you are on Linkedin you can contact Reverb"s execs

  • Ben Stahl (CEO). Reverb's chief executive, who oversees overall marketplace strategy and seller experience.
  • Mark Packham (Senior Manager, Seller Engagement). Directly responsible for keeping active sellers on the platform.
  • Mark Anzelc (VP of Operations). Oversees marketplace operations, policies, and fulfillment workflows.
  • Trust & Safety / Risk Management Leadership. Search LinkedIn for "Reverb" AND ("Head of Risk" OR "Trust and Safety" OR "Product Manager") to message the specific product and risk managers who designed the $2,500+ hold rule.

Here are possibilities for their email addresses:

or if those don't work

Established Reverb sellers that have been paid in a timely manner for the last 13 years and have generated a lot of money for Reverb should be exempt from this new extended payout hold. Especially when other platforms like Ebay, Sweetwater Gear Exchange, and Facebook Marketplace don't have extended payout holds.


r/Reverb • • 12h ago

Buyers - do you pay immediately? (Here we go again with a possible fake buyer...)

1 Upvotes

So I have a listing with direct offers enabled. I sell fairly constantly, usually have at least one listing up at any given time. In my last 4 or 5 listings, this is now the third where a zero feedback buyer has taken the direct offer and it's just sat there.

Granted, it's not been that long, but when I'm the buyer, if I hit accept on an offer, I go ahead and pay right then and move things along. Most of the time as the seller, this is what happens -- buyer pays, I pack and ship, all is well.

But I've had several now where the buyer takes the offer and never pays. I'm not sure what the purpose is. If it was an accident, just say so, and I'll cancel and relist.

On the first one, Reverb canceled it, apparently for a problem/scammer buyer. On the last one, when I canceled, the buyer contacted me and asked why -- and when I said for non-payment they were like "Oh, I thought I paid." I never answered and just relisted it and sold it the next day to a legit buyer.

So here's a third one of these in the past few months. Anyone else seeing these?