r/Rochester • u/HunterDry375 • 16h ago
Other I compared certificate and CD rates around Rochester this week, here is what I found
I spent the last couple days checking CD and certificate rates around Rochester because I needed a safe place to put some savings for 6 to 12 months. Figured I would share what I found since it took a while to pull together.
Best 6-month rates
| Institution | Rate | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| Empower FCU | 5.00% | $500 to open. Syracuse based but anyone in NY can join, and you can open online |
| Summit FCU jumbo | 4.50% | $75,000 minimum. Their rates change every week |
| ESL | 4.20% | This was a rate match they were working on for me, not something they advertise, so you would have to ask |
| Canandaigua National | 4.15% | 7-month special. 4.25% if you have their Optimum Checking |
| Marcus (online) | 4.00% | 6-month CD, $500 to open |
Best 12-month rates
| Institution | Rate | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| Summit FCU jumbo | 4.55% | $75,000 minimum |
| Marcus (online) | 4.50% | $500 to open |
| Family First | 4.45% | 15-month special |
| Pittsford FCU jumbo | 4.35% | $90,000 minimum |
Best flexible savings (no lock)
Pibank: 4.40%, no minimum and no fee.
EverBank: 4.20%, but only for new accounts, and the rate can change anytime.
All the credit unions I checked
| Credit union | Best certificate | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| ESL | 7-mo jumbo 4.15% | $100,000 minimum. Regular 7-month is 3.90% |
| Summit FCU | Jumbo 12-mo 4.55%, 6-mo 4.50% | $75,000 minimum. Regular 12-mo 4.30%, 6-mo 4.25% |
| Empower FCU | 6-mo 5.00% | Also 18-mo 4.50%, 12-mo 4.00%. Same rate no matter the balance |
| Pittsford FCU | Jumbo 12-mo 4.35%, 6-mo 4.10% | $90,000 minimum. Regular 12-mo 4.25%, 6-mo 4.00% |
| Advantage FCU | 7-24 mo 4.25% | - |
| Reliant FCU | 18-mo 4.15% | 12-mo is 3.85% |
| Family First | 15-mo special 4.45% | Their Companion Savings pays 5.00% but only on the first $10,000 |
| Visions FCU | 24-mo 4.00% | 12-mo 3.60%, 6-mo 3.25% |
| Genesee Co-op | 3-yr 3.14% | 1-yr 2.78%, 2-yr 3.03%. No 6-month option |
| Finger Lakes FCU | 12-mo 1.26% | 6-mo 1.01%. Pretty much not worth it |
| First Heritage FCU | 12-mo special 4.34% | Monroe County is not in their area, so most people here cannot join |
Banks with Rochester branches
Canandaigua National: 7-month special at 4.15%, or 4.25% with Optimum Checking. Their 13-month special is also 4.15%.
Five Star Bank: 11-month special at 4.05%. Their regular CDs are basically zero.
Tompkins: 14-month at 3.54%, 6-month at 2.55%.
M&T, KeyBank, Chase, Bank of America, Citizens, PNC, Community Bank, Genesee Regional, NBT: none of them list CD rates on their websites. You have to call or go in, which is annoying.
Online banks and card companies
| Institution | Savings | Best CD |
|---|---|---|
| Marcus (Goldman Sachs) | 3.50% | 12-mo 4.50%, 6-mo 4.00%, 9-mo 4.30%, 18-mo and up 4.60% |
| Ally | 3.20% | 2.90% to 4.50% range, but their term page would not load |
| Capital One | Could not read it | 3.30% to 4.45% range, terms not shown |
| American Express | Could not read it | 3.75% to 4.50% range, terms not shown |
| Discover | - | Part of Capital One now |
| UFB Direct | 4.01% promo | Promo lasts up to 6 months |
| Wealthfront | 3.55% base | Up to 4.45% only with a referral boost |
| Betterment | 4.00% | Cash reserve, new customers |
Anyway, hope this saves someone the legwork. All checked November 21, and these rates move around a lot, so double check before opening anything.