Hello!
I am sure I am but a minority, but RuneScape's audio world has been with me through all of it and it has been criminal that the launch of RuneScape 3 outright nuked the early game's audio identity. Don't get me wrong, I do not hate the new and reworked music tracks, quite the opposite in fact! I understand why a decision had to be made to sweep the old thing under the rug for good but along the way came the aforementioned problem that the game still didn't bother addressing at the slightest.
Currently there is no real unique identity of Lumbridge/Varrock/Edgeville/Barbarian Village/Dwarven Mine, south and north Asgarnia at all!
These all are shuffled into a singular playlist, devoid of the diversity that Old School RuneScape has for example created. I have some issues with their system (example Lightness should *not* play around Goblin Village but north of Grand Exchange and Spooky is replaced with Scape Soft and Lightness in Modern mode after playing once within Draynor Manor fenced area) but I digress! Getting back to RuneScape, the identity problem should be resolved properly once and for all.
Previously Yesteryear, Book of Spells and Busy Night were part of the playlist, the former two are now back to Lumbridge Swamp, the latter has been oddly reduced to the mines south of Varrock to play with the returned and reworked Still Night.
Attempting for a proper, best of both worlds solution requires tearing up some scarred wounds left by RuneScape 3's launch to see the full amount of casualties left by that era and the little that has been changed since then on this front ever since then.
First up is restoring Lumbridge.
This is probably one of the easier ones to be done already without doing much damage.
- Harmony - The majority of Lumbridge south of the farms (still unlocks in Lumbridge)
- Harmony2 - In the Lumbridge Castle basement (currently not reworked but still plays there)
- Autumn Voyage - Northeast of Lumbridge in the chicken coop
- Dream - In the forest between Lumbridge and Draynor
- Yesteryear - In the Lumbridge Swamp south of the cemetery
- The Duke - 1st floor[*UK*] of Lumbridge Castle
- Book of Spells - The swamp south of Lumbridge
The odd one out are
This is what we are left with after cleaning Lumbridge.
Up next is Misthalin's capital city the one and only Varrock!
And look at the abandoned tracks
- Adventure (Varrock Palace)
- Cellar Song (Varrock West bank vault) - currently not updated
- Parade (Jolly Boar Inn/Paterdomus Path)
- The Trade Parade (Grand Exchange) - this one is actually confirmed to be making a comeback by Mod Nixon on 12.02 update in the livestream!
Now take a look at what we have left.
Varrock stole the identity by a quite large margin but that is not all the pattern that is left.
Sorting these out will give a clear answer the main purpose of these tracks were supposed to be that they ultimately failed on delivering because they never stood a chance of standing out as their places identity.
Barbarian Village:
- Barbarianism - the former main music of Barbarian Village that has been gone since 2013
- Gunnarsgrunn - a variant of Barbarianism unlocked upon completing Gunnar's Ground but actually plays only in around Rellekka and has actually been reworked in 2015.
- Village Life - the supposed main music of Barbarian Village since 2013
Edgeville:
- Forever - the former main music of Edgeville before 2013
- Village Fate - the supposed main music of Edgeville since 2013
And we are now down to only three music pieces for reminder of Asgarnia as we are now.
- Horizon - The former main music of Taverley, the iconic theme of reaching and entering the famous gate as it now unlocks automatically... for members thats it.
- Wander Waltz - This track unlocks to the south of Falador, replacing bunch of other tracks at once.
- Village Dance - the supposed main music of Dwarven Mines since 2013.
And this concludes the first half which is how I should sort this weird experience of having no clear identity Should these tracks get an update and sorted out you could try to do some neat splitting into said areas and regain lost identity without turning your back on the newer ones.
Let's slowly get into the more difficult cases where it'd be harder to commit to identities even via a remaster, starting with easier subjects.
Musa Point of Karamja:
This is arguably the easiest to handle, Jagex just gotta rework and return Sea Shanty I and Jungle Island to this part of the island instead of just having Sea Shanty II and Player owned ports music occupying it, might be something worth doing as a side update to the Karamja update of 2027 perhaps?
South Asgarnia genre restoration:
This is more about how you distribute these if you remaster/rework them
- Attention - unlocks at coastline by Rimmington
- Emperor - unlocks around Melzar Maze
- Long Way Home - unlocks at Rimmington
- Nightfall - unlocked automatically since 2013 (previously unlocked south-west of Falador)
- Miles Away - unlocked automatically since 2013 (previously unlocked at Crafting Guild)
- Tomorrow - unlocked automatically since 2013 (previously unlocked at Port Sarim, from around the prison)
- Wander - plays by the Falador farm to this day
- Wander Waltz - this track unlocks to the south of Falador, replacing Nightfall and Miles Away
As you can see two of these are up to date with standards which prevents a proper genre from being able to boom there again and it also raises some questions? Do you remaster Tomorrow and add it to Port Sarim's genre? Do you remaster Attention, Long Way Home and Emperor and add it to the already distinct Rimmington genre? Even if they don't return to the towns itself they can fill out the inbetween so you don't get something called Misthalin Mood play in Asgarnia or keep hearing music that should only play in Varrock by default.
North Asgarnia genre restoration:
Without much genre disruption this is the most straightforward way I could think of in terms of identity regaining in this area.
- Horizon - the former main music of Taverley, it does give these positive upbeats needed for this area already.
- Scape Soft - the former north Asgarnian music replaced by Second Harmony should be restored with the latter moved to Lumbridge genre.
- Splendour - another former music from Taverley and the wine stealing days of the captured temple.
- Dwarf Theme - definitely reserve it for the camp area where the dwarves are.
- Village Dance - the supposed main music of Dwarven Mines since 2013, but could be easily added to the North Asgarnia genre in general for more variety.
Burthorpe and little bit of Troll Country:
Mod Nixon previously thought about returning Principality to be Burthorpe's main theme, before you start doing quests, then it'd shift to the more serious music it currently has. Competition could also play there in that part before switching to the more serious Burthorpe set of musics on the surface at least. Troll Country is getting some touch ups next year as part of the Remastered Journey so might as well do so while at it!
- Hermit - should return to the genre or the caves of Death Plateau
- Kingdom - currently the moment you set foot in the free to play era of Troll Country its radio silent.
Wilderness restoration:
The current Wilderness roster is missing certain amount of tracks that should be brought back to life. These are the ones currently in rotation not counting Mage Arena and Pirates of Peril which are area locked:
There is at very least 15 more tracks (I am excluding Moody from RS3 because it has been reworked into a firmly West Ardougne music) that have been gone from this land that could be remastered and returned to normal playlist (along with some spicing up to the current Wilderness in general)
Born to Do This should also be brought back to Daemonheim in some way and Knightmare be found a usage somewhere inside or beneath Black Knight Fortress.
Draynor Village:
One of the most difficult in terms of coming up with an ideal answer, one thing is certain: Spooky needs a return to Draynor Manor so it can regain it's identity back without alienating the current one it has:
Now when it comes to the old one, it is not me who has had a headache dealing with it, Jagex has been troubled too
- Start - this one has been reworked since 2013 but it has not found its place yet, Lumbridge forest/east of Draynor might be decent placement currently.
- Unknown Land - awaiting rework/remaster.
Al Kharid:
Another very difficult one to handle while trying not to be disrespectful to the new tracks that took an identity post-rework. The current roster includes:
Outside north and south of the city:
Former music of this area are:
- Al Kharid - this should obviously play in Al Kharid remastered
- Arabian
- Arabian2 - still plays in resource dungeon but haven't been reworked yet
- Arabian3
- Egypt - actually reworked and plays farther south now.
- Shine - Magic Training Arena should get this remastered so it isn't just repeating Wizard's Tower music 1:1
TzHaar City:
The 2012 supplemented most of the music there in favour of more ambience. Should the old ones be remastered and found a way to be used again?
Only few of these nuked tracks have been reworked and found a place since 2013, that list includes Royale, Arrival, Mudskipper Melody and lastly, the White Wolf Mountain rework brought back Ice Melody without doing away Scape Dark for example. Should this be applied here? Which of these should be top priority? And this concludes my thread, thanks for having read it and drop your thoughts below!