With the Agility rework coming, Construction and Dungeoneering updated, plus new methods for Divination, Runecrafting, and Thieving added, a lot of RS3's worst offenders for dull or unrewarding skills have been targeted.
Skilling is definitely in a better place than it was a few years ago, but there's still room for improvement. So what skills would benefit the most from updates? For me, a few have stood out while playing my iron:
Archaeology, Herblore, & Smithing: These three are rewarding but annoying to train. For Archaeology and Smithing, they are pretty dull. I don't think the existing methods are bad, but I hate how there are no active alternatives. You have to commit to days of AFK grinding to progress, which sucks if that's not the experience you are looking for.
Herblore doesn't have this problem but is still annoying due to the lack of QoL options. The biggest chore is creating unfinished potions, which you either do manually or wait until 90/114 Invention. Even then, there's still no active option that doesn't suck. OSRS solved this with Zahur, and I'd love to see RS3 do something similar, especially since herb runs are way better in this game.
Firemaking: A remarkably useless skill. How this has remained so bad for 25 years is kind of impressive, even after getting a 110 update! Incense sticks are fine, but not really worth training the skill for, making War's Retreat campfire unironically the biggest benefit. Surely we can do better and give it some overdue attention.
Summoning: Not hard to train and eventually rewarding. So why is it here? Because 90% of familiars suck. Progressing through this skill in 2026 on a new account, it's crazy how few familiars you use. Outside of BoBs, Bunyip, Hellhound, Waterfiend and maybe Magpie, nothing below 70 is really worth considering. In its current state, most of this skill's output is balanced very poorly.
I made this thread to provide some big-picture feedback targeted at the early/midgame, and I'd love to hear what you think too. Feel free to talk about methods, rewards, or just how boring you find whatever skill. All feedback is important and can help shape future updates for the better.