r/SGU • u/sdwoodchuck • 21h ago
This Week's "Name That Logical Fallacy"
To recap, the question was what logical fallacy is at play when a person looks at a piece of art that seems functionally simple, and asserts "I could have done that," by way of suggesting that the art is something lesser.
Steve touched a bit on the matter by pointing out that there's something of an unstated premise, and he might have mentioned equivocation, but I think we can hammer it down to two more specific fallacies.
The first is the Incomplete Comparison, which asserts that two things are alike in a general or unexplained way, when doing so more completely or specifically would reveal the ways that they are different enough to matter. So by saying "I could do that ('painting' a blank canvas)," it is making an incomplete comparison between the simple physical action of putting an image to canvas with the artistic expression that informs the decision.
But more specifically, we're looking at a variation of the Doorman Fallacy (from Rory Sutherland's wikipedia page:
The doorman fallacy refers to the error of reducing a person's job to its most basic function and replacing it with a cost-effective automation while disregarding the broader, not directly visible, value they provide.
The example provided in the book is about a hotel that decides to replace its doorman. One may consider their singular function to be opening and closing the door which is easily replaceable by an automated door. This overlooks the doorman's indirect functions, such as guest-recognition, security and status signalling. Retaining the doorman would signal the hotel's premium status, allowing them to charge more, meaning the potential cost-saving measure might end up costing the hotel more than it saves.
Essentially, the speaker is judging the art by the most basic visible outcomes that they experience of an artist's output, without considering the wider contexts that artistic creativity involves.