Y'all help me explore options and make a decision here
About me
I'm 31M. I've lived in Cincinnati for 5 years now. Before this, I've lived in the TN boonies, Chattanooga, and Raleigh. I originally moved to Cincinnati for a PhD program, but have since left academia. I also was married when I moved here and am no longer (complicated story). Given that I have very little reason to be here and haven't really bothered to put down roots in a place that was always meant to be temporary, I'm in a place where I'm looking to make one more move and settle into some place and really put down some roots finally, after years of moving around.
I have a BA and MA and worked in higher ed for most of my 20s (teaching, research, grad degrees, admin work). After leaving academia, I've worked in technical writing/content management/content strategy/info systems type of work, with experience in tech, higher ed, and financial sectors (fintech or edtech would be my ideal next transition, rather than strictly working at a legacy financial or banking firm, but I'm pretty flexible and like my environment fine at my current company).
What I'm looking for
I don't have a specific place calling me. I think the things I want at this point in life are fairly foundational. I want:
- Large urban metro (2mil+ population, ideally) with generally blue local politics (state level is a concern, but I've lived in NC and OH, so I can tolerate a lot)
- Walkable/bikeable urban neighborhoods (not necessarily fully car free, I don't mind a 20-30 minute daily car commute if I can live somewhere I'm doing a reverse commute, currently I do 20 minutes with nearly zero traffic issues because I go south out of downtown against incoming traffic).
- Job prospects beyond just the one job I take to move there. If I need to move jobs again, I want a big enough local market to do it locally without needing to move to a new city again in 5 years.
- Volunteer opportunities and other ways to get involved locally in a way that helps me feel invested in my city. I've done some work with urban farms and a recycling nonprofit that takes materials that the city won't recycle. But things like tutoring, running resume workshops at a local library, or doing public land cleanup projects is what I am looking for here.
- Dating prospects (I've struggled a little with this in Cincinnati as a transplant, it's kind of an insular culture). I am not 100% set on remarrying anytime soon, but I'd like a pool of artsy-leaning, has their shit together professionals with independent lives.
- Housing that I can afford within the next 5 years on a sub-$110k salary (townhouse, condo, SFH are all options for me). $110k is relative, since I'm basing my assumptions on rust belt cost of living and salary bands right now.
- Milder winters where the winters don't make me want to jump off a roof. I get pretty bad seasonal depression in Cincinnati, and the winters here are pretty mild compared to further north. I quite like the snow, actually, but the grey skies for 6 months just get me in a funk.
- Access to hiking and wooded outdoors activity with at least a little elevation change within a 2-3 hour drive for weekend trips. I need to fuck off and be alone in the woods a few times a month.
Basically, I just want to go to the gym, bike to the grocery store on the weekends, cook good food in my apartment and drink local beers, and make a few friends in a place that I feel rooted to and invested in.
Where I'm considering moving to
A small caveat: I'd like to be closer to where my core parents live. They are aging, and my grandparents are nearing end of life. However, most of my friends and family have dispersed. I have folks in Nashville, Knoxville, Boston, Atlanta, Tampa, and Dallas. My parents live in the middle of nowhere in TN, and the nearest metros are not the best fits for me for different reasons (Nashville, Chattanooga, and Huntsville are the close options). However, anywhere longer than a 6ish hour drive feels basically the same in terms of the air travel required to get home, so if I don't land somewhere within 6ish hours, I might as well open up to literally any options. Preferably, I'd like to stay east of the Mississippi (idiosyncratic preference).
Here's where I'm thinking about. I'm looking for thoughts on these options, given my stated needs, as well as suggestions for places I might be overlooking.
- Atlanta has been my target for a long time, but I'm concerned about the traffic and about a lack of job opportunities in my area. I have visited a few times and really like it. I have a cousin who lives there and is a big fan. It's the biggest city and closest to home for me, about a 4 hour drive to where most of my family lives, and about 6 from my sister and BIL (my closest family connections). I also have a good friend in Knoxville I'd be fairly close to with this option.
- Chicago is another serious consideration, but the winters and distance are my main concerns. There are things I could do to address the winter seasonal depression. I don't hate the cold or snow. It's the lack of sun and grey skies that get me down. Housing would likely be constrained to condos long term for me here.
- Boston is an option I've seriously considered because my company has their HQ there, and I might be able to transfer internally to a position based in Boston, which would negate the need to find a new job and lose the benefits of what I've built. I also have a cousin and her wife who live there, and they're big fans. The main concern is getting a transfer that is actually based there, and the increased cost of living compared to what I'm used to. I've only lived in the south and rust belt, so I'm used to cheaper life (and lower salaries).
- Northern Kentucky is something I'm considering. The Cincinnati/NKY area does have a lot of the things I listed as wanting (minus compatible dating prospects and winters). And sometimes I wonder if an internal transfer at my job and a move across the river to NKY would be enough of a change to settle into. I'd like to live in either Newport or Covington, and an actual house might be in budget in those locations (plus my taxes would go down since I live in Ohio but work in Kentucky, meaning I double up on taxes right now). There are also lots of places to live a secluded woodsman life but still be like 15 minutes from downtown Cincinnati. But I'd be constrained to only the job that are being offered at my local office.
- Philadelphia is a wildcard for me. I have a long time family friend who is in a PhD at Temple, and she and her partner love it there. I hear good things on Reddit of course. My friend's mom has asked me why I don't consider it, and I don't have a good answer. I just don't know much about the place.