r/ScienceBasedParenting • • Mar 26 '26

Meta Post Spring 2026 Updates - Required Reading!

40 Upvotes

r/ScienceBasedParenting - Spring 2026 Updates

Welcome! This is a community dedicated to parenting questions, answers, and discussions grounded in up-to-date research and expert consensus. We aim to foster a vibrant, respectful, and strictly evidence-based environment for parents, scientists, and healthcare professionals alike.

The Moderation Team: To keep the sub running smoothly, we have a team of volunteer moderators (a mix of scientists, healthcare professionals, and parents). We rely on the community to submit reports to help us keep things operating smoothly - with hundreds of thousands of active members we can’t catch everything without your help. The quickest way to bring posts that violate our rules to our attention is using the report button. We are constantly working to improve the subreddit. Please send any questions or suggestions via modmail.

Notable Updates & Changes

  • No AI-Generated Content: We have implemented a strict ban on AI-generated submissions (ChatGPT, Claude, etc.) to ensure authentic human discussion. (See Rule 9)
  • No Political Content: Posts and comments must remain focused on evidence-based parenting. Political content—including advocacy, partisan framing, culture war topics, or policy debates—is not permitted. (See Rule 13)
  • Clarifications on Flair/Link Evasion: Intentionally bypassing flair requirements or automod link checks will result in immediate removals and a ban. (See Rule 3)
  • Strict Source Definitions: We have clarified what constitutes "Expert Consensus" (e.g., non-profits like La Leche League do not qualify). (See Flair Explanations)

Use the Weekly General Discussion Thread!

What this thread is for: Use this space for questions or topics that are unlikely to have strong scientific evidence or consensus. Not every parenting question has a study-backed answer. Common examples redirected here:

  • Personal advice (“What should I do about…”)
  • Product recommendations/reviews
  • Book/media suggestions
  • Experience-based questions
  • Open-ended or opinion-driven topics

Core Subreddit Rules

1. Be Respectful Discussions and debates are welcome, but must remain civilized. Inflammatory content is prohibited. Do not make fun of or shame others, even if you disagree with them.

2. All Posts Must Include Appropriate Flair Please choose the right flair for your post to encourage the correct types of responses. Check the wiki on post flair descriptions for more information. Posts cannot be submitted without flair, and posts using flair inappropriately or not conforming to the specified format will be removed or the post flair changed if appropriate.

3. No Flair Evasion All posts and comments must follow the correct flair format. Deliberately evading flair types, encouraging flair evasion from others, or reposting a thread removed for not following flair types will result in removal and a ban.

  • Top-level comments must meaningfully engage with the post and any sources shared. “Link for the bot” or similar low-effort link drops are not allowed. If you include a link, you must clearly explain the research/resource and how it relates to the original post.
  • Comments that use irrelevant links, mischaracterize sources, or otherwise attempt to bypass top-level comment requirements (including “link for bot”–style comments) are considered flair evasion and will be removed, and may result in a ban.
  • This subreddit is not for personal advice or anecdotal responses outside the weekly General Discussion thread.

4. Read the Linked Material Before Commenting Make sure you know what you are commenting on to avoid misunderstandings.

5. General Discussion/Questions Belong in the Megathread This includes anything that doesn't fit into the specified post flair types. The General Discussion Megathread will be posted weekly on Monday.

6. Linked Sources Must Be Appropriate for Flair Type

  • All top comments on “Question - research required” threads and all comments directly refuting top comments must contain links to peer-reviewed research.
  • All top comments on “Question - Expert consensus required” threads and all comments directly refuting top comments must contain links to peer-reviewed research or links to expert consensuses.
  • Please reference the wiki for further information on flair types.

7. Do Not Ask for or Give Individualized Medical Advice General questions such as “How can I best protect a newborn from RSV?” are allowed, however specific questions such as "What should I do to treat my child with RSV?" or “What is this rash?” or “Why isn’t my child sleeping?” are not allowed. Nothing posted here constitutes medical advice. Please reach out to the appropriate professionals with any medical concern.

8. No Self-Promotion This community is a not a marketplace. Avoid posting links or mentions of your own products, services, websites, or media (including books and podcasts). We are not currently hosting AMAs or research recruitment. Recommendations or inquiries for specific products are restricted to the Weekly General Thread. Mentioning products elsewhere may be flagged as stealth advertising and removed.

9. No AI-Generated Content All posts and comments must be authored by a human. Submissions created primarily by AI tools (e.g., ChatGPT, Claude, Gemini) are prohibited to ensure authentic discussion.

10. No Meta or Mod Commentary in the Main Sub We do not allow meta-commentary in the main subreddit. Please address any subreddit or moderation concerns via modmail.

11. Keep Reddit's Rules Please adhere to all of Reddit's rules and guidelines for posting.

12. Keep Comments Relevant Please keep the discussion on topic. All comments that do not pertain to the discussion at hand will be removed.

13. No Political Content Keep discussions evidence-based and focused on parenting. Political advocacy, partisan framing, and policy debates will be removed.

Explanation of Post Flair Types

1. Sharing Peer-Reviewed Research

  • Purpose: For sharing a direct link to a study and discussing its implications.
  • Format: Title must be a brief, objective description of the findings of the linked research.
  • Requirement: Must link directly to the published research, not a press release about the study.

2. Question - Link To Research Required

  • Format: Title must be a generalized question, not advice on a specific situation.

    • Acceptable Example: "How do nap schedules affect infant nighttime sleep?"
    • Unacceptable Example: "Should I change my infant's nap schedule?"
  • Requirement: Top-level answers and refutations must link directly to peer-reviewed research (scientific journals, Cochrane Reviews).
  • Source Restrictions:

    • Refrain from linking directly to summaries from governmental organizations unless the linked page includes citations of primary literature.
    • Parenting books, podcasts, and blogs are not peer-reviewed. You may mention them if relevant (e.g., "If you are interested in X, I found Y's book interesting"), but you cannot cite them as scientific evidence ("Author X says Y is the way it is").

3. Question - Link to Expert Consensus Required

  • Format: Title must be a generalized question.
  • Requirement: Top-level answers and refutations must link to sources containing expert consensus (e.g., CDC, WHO, AAP, ACOG) or peer-reviewed research.
  • Source Restrictions: * Blogs or news articles written by a singular expert are not permitted.

    • Non-profit advocacy or support organizations (e.g., La Leche League, Environmental Working Group) do not count as expert consensus.
    • All sources must come from a recognized medical/scientific organization (e.g., AAP, ACOG) or governmental health body (e.g., CDC, WHO).
  • Note: Peer-reviewed studies are still the gold standard regardless of expert opinion. Additionally, expert consensus may disagree from source to source and country to country.

4. Scientific Journalism

  • Purpose: For the discussion and debate of published scientific journalism.
  • Requirement: Must link directly to the articles in question. Title should reflect the title of the article.

r/ScienceBasedParenting • • 5d ago

Weekly General Discussion

2 Upvotes

Welcome to the weekly General Discussion thread! Use this as a place to get advice from like-minded parents, share interesting science journalism, and anything else that relates to the sub but doesn't quite fit into the dedicated post types.

Please utilize this thread as a space for peer to peer advice, book and product recommendations, and any other things you'd like to discuss with other members of this sub!

Disclaimer: because our subreddit rules are intentionally relaxed on this thread and research is not required here, we cannot guarantee the quality and/or accuracy of anything shared here.


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • 1h ago

Question - Research required Probiotics and allergies - specifically FPIES

2 Upvotes

Our 8 month old baby has multiple-trigger FPIES (3 triggers so far, hoping there isn’t more but due to how early we’ve discovered these 3, and because one of them was a supposedly ‘low risk’ food, we’re proceeding cautiously with food introductions).

The NHS allergist we’re working with (in the UK), who has been great, has recommended we start some probiotics. She specifically recommended the Optibac sachets.

As FPIES is an allergy that is based in the gut, it makes theoretical sense to me that a probiotic might be beneficial.

I did a bit of my own research on this and it’s hard to not go down a hole. I find the whole area extremely confusing. It seems like there is some research that suggests some bifidobacterium strains are lower in children with FPIES. But there is no research that proves having a probiotic improves outcomes (probably very hard to study).

The Optibac sachets don’t have any b. Infantis strains which most of the research for probiotics in infants seem to suggest is beneficial. However it seems like a lot of the research is funded by bodies that sell the probiotics so it’s hard to know what to trust. A lot of people in the FPIES community seem to go with the Smidge probiotic as it includes a few b. Infantis strains and is free from other allergens. The Evivo one is also really popular, it includes one very specific strain (B. infantis EVC001). I’m just feeling extremely sceptical and it’s wild to me that as consumers we’re either expected to unpick this complex web of theorising / early research or just blindly trust the makers of these products.

Has anyone else looked into this / does anyone have any advice? Research based or anecdotal, I don’t really mind at this point.

She was born at term, vaginally, and is breastfed. She hasn’t had any antibiotic exposure apart from a bit of antibiotic eye ointment when she had conjunctivitis at around 12 weeks. We’ve not given her anything so far, but I’m worried that by not giving her anything she’s potentially missing out on some benefit.


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • 3h ago

Question - Expert consensus required What’s the impact of one parent going on phone infront of baby/ has tv on (but not the other)?

2 Upvotes

I know the overall studies of screen time and how it impacts babies, and same with phone use infront of them as you have the “blank” stare which I believe can stress them out?

But the situation I’m in is I am mostly around our almost 6 month old baby. Now all day I’m talking and interacting with her, no screens (though I also let her have some “me” time so I’m not always entertaining her). However my partner tends to be more likely to have tv on in background when he’s home or be on his phone scrolling in front of her and not realize it. They definitely still talk and play though but in general he’s more likely to do those things.

What im curious about is how that might impact her development overall if one parent is more into screens and looking down at their phone while interacting with her? She’s tracking when it comes to language (eg connecting sounds and “bababa”s as well as recognizing baby sign language like milk where she’ll get excited when I do it). But could it impact how she develops socially? Is this a case of moderating and small bits here and there isn’t detrimental?

I’ve brought up the research and we’re on the same page as a couple but he tends to slip back into those habits and I don’t want to keep nagging if it’s not that crucial as it’s not all the time.


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • 10m ago

Question - Research required Does stopping formula supplementation early increase the risk of CMPA?

1 Upvotes

Hi, first time dad here. Our 4-week-old daughter was combination-fed (breast milk + formula) from birth due to my partner having a hard time breastfeeding shortly after birth. With support from our midwife, we were gradually able to do exclusive breastfeeding as my wife's milk supply has increased.

A friend recently mentioned that introducing cow's milk formula early and then discontinuing it might increase the risk of cow's milk protein allergy (CMPA), and it is recommended to continue exposure to formula in some amount to reduce the risk. In the country where I live there is no such recommendation, and our pediatrician said this probably won't be necessary in our case, given we don't have any history of allergy.

I'm wondering whether there's any strong scientific evidence supporting this? Has anyone had experience going off formula early on?


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • 22h ago

Science journalism https://www.cbc.ca/news/health/lancet-retraction-motherisk-gideon-koren-study-codeine-breast-milk-9.7430487

41 Upvotes

I just saw this article this morning and I am honestly shocked to learn how flawed Gideon Koren’s methods were and that this influenced postpartum pain management for thousands, if not millions of women.

Edit to provide the clickable link: https://www.cbc.ca/news/health/lancet-retraction-motherisk-gideon-koren-study-codeine-breast-milk-9.7430487


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • 3h ago

Question - Research required Cosleeping vs sleeping in a different room

0 Upvotes

Hi SBP! I had this argument with my GP a few weeks ago about baby sleeping arrangements. She asked me how we're sleeping and I admitted that we co-sleep in the same bed, but following the SS7 strictly. She disapproved intensely, I said it was the only way for me to get any sleep and that I was exhausted before we started co-sleeping (literally, I was running on 4 hours of sleep every night, it was brutal). She then suggested that I'd get more sleep if I put the baby in a different room or if I wore earplugs so I couldn't hear him. Anyway, I ignored that advice, especially as my health visitor had no problem with our arrangement. My baby was 10 weeks old at the time.

My question is, is there any evidence that compares co-sleeping in the absence of any hazards (like smoking or alcohol) and baby sleeping in a different room for SIDS? I know neither of those options are recommended by the Lullaby Trust under 6 months, but I'm curious as to which one is less risky.


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • 13h ago

Question - Research required Book recommendations for first 3 years

6 Upvotes

Hello,

I’m twin father. They are premature and they are already three months old.

I have read until now:

* The birth partner
* The Cribsheet
* The Whole-Brainchild

So far I like the three books. Though, I think The Whole-Brainchild it’s not 100% scientifically backed, I still really liked the activities it proposed.

What next books would you recommend? In your opinion. If you would ask me about which is my area of interest I would say education. But more important, I prefer to read books that are scientifically backed, rather than mere opinions as they are all valid.

Anyway, what books or information (videos, podcasts, etc) would you recommend?


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • 8h ago

Question - Expert consensus required Can baby’s flat head become round again without a helmet if it’s not a severe case?

1 Upvotes

My baby was born with a perfect shape but it became pretty severely(imo) flat around 3 months. Dr told us it was pretty flat too during the 3 mo appnt. Now that she rolls and sleeps on her belly, the flatness has gotten better but still somewhat flat. In our latest appnt, the dr said she has some flatness but that it is mild. I see that over time we’ve seen improvements but can the shape come back to as round as it was when she was born without a helmet?


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • 23h ago

Question - Research required Nearly 5-month-old twins suddenly rolling onto their tummies to sleep

15 Upvotes

As the title says, my twins have just discovered rolling from their backs onto their tummies, and they absolutely love it! As soon as I put them down, they roll over. The problem is that they do it at night too and they can’t roll tummy to back yet.
Last night, I decided to see how many times I could put them on their backs before they rolled onto their tummies again. The answer? Trillions! They don’t even hesitate and a second after I roll them to their back they roll back to their tummy 😭.

Obviously, I can’t stay up all night turning them back onto their backs, but I’m terrified of just letting them sleep on their tummies. For context, they’ve had terrible reflux, which might be why they’re so determined to sleep on their tummies.

I’m lost and very very tired. Any advice? Should I just stay awake ?

Last night I eventually had to leave them be and wake up regularly to check they were breathing and to feed them when I knew they were hungry.
They are both exclusively breastfed and were born at 36w3d.

Thanks


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • 9h ago

Question - Expert consensus required Are sultanas as good or nearly as good as fresh fruit for children?

0 Upvotes

My 5 year old wants sultanas for school lunch, but I don't want to sacrifice fresh fruit for sultanas if the health benefits are not similar. It's too exhausting trying to separate fact from fiction in google anymore so I would appreciate some help from a place I trust. Thanks!


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • 9h ago

Question - Research required Is there any research regarding the safety of starting a GLP1 while still breast-feeding a toddler?

0 Upvotes

Also open to relevant advice regarding weight loss in general.

Ive been trying to lose weight for an about three months now. The first 10 pounds came off pretty easily, and then I’ve plateaued for about a month. More recently - I’ve been discouraged, so it’s been harder for me to keep my routines and to log my food accurately.

I lost 50 pounds about 10 years ago and it was sooo much easier in my 20s pre-baby (duh). The holidays is coming up make it extra daunting.

My son is 18 months old, and I am wondering if adding a GLP1 would help but last I heard breast-feeding was considered a contraindication.

Logically, I feel like the amount that would transfer to whatever my son takes a day would be minuscule. I want know that for sure before I start scheduling an appointment/seeking a prescription.

I’m not really willing to wean yet since breast-feeding is something that he and I both still enjoy and I do not want to cut that short unnecessarily.


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • 1d ago

Question - Research required Tylenol? Is there a real concern for kids or is this fake?

85 Upvotes

We just got done with an appointment for my 20-month-old and the nurse practitioner suggested Motrin for pain for him. I told her I had baby Tylenol and children's Tylenol at home. She said that I shouldn't give him that anymore and should give him Motrin instead.

Honestly, I have never heard that. Why would she say that? Is it the current administration confusing recommendations? I saw the AAP does not echo her sentiments.

My other kids are medically complex and have had surgeries and always had Tylenol after surgeries as standard of care, as well as used for treatment of fevers. What's the deal here? Is she just believing a load of poop or is there real research that backs her claim? Thanks so much.

ETA she also said he shouldn't get the flu shot. When I told her he absolutely would be because his siblings are immunocompromised, she said okay reluctantly.


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • 4h ago

Question - Research required Worried about my 9-month-old’s development – could these be early signs of autism?

0 Upvotes

Hi everyone!

My baby is 9 months (8mos adjusted), and lately I’ve been spiralling about her development and wondering whether some of her behaviours could be early signs of autism.

**Here are some things I’ve noticed:**

\- Doesn’t maintain much eye contact when I’m holding her, but does when she’s at a distance or someone else is holding her.

\- Inconsistent response to her name, especially when we’re playing on the floor together.
Sometimes repeatedly slams her hands against her thighs.

\- Stiffens her legs and shrieks when in her stroller.
Loves tags and straps.

\- Mostly explores toys by putting them in her mouth.

\- Very active and constantly wants to move.

Sometimes scrunches her face.

\- Occasionally zones out when sleepy.

\-Randomly shouts or squeals.
\- Doesn’t consistently follow my pointing, especially when the object is far away.

\-On the positive side, she smiles, laughs, enjoys peekaboo, babbles, sometimes looks back at me while playing and shows interest in people.

For parents whose children were later diagnosed with autism:

  1. Did you notice similar behaviours around 9 months?
  2. Did inconsistent name response and eye contact improve with age?
  3. Were some of these behaviours also present in babies who weren’t autistic?

I’m not looking for a diagnosis, just some perspective and real-life experiences. I know every baby develops differently, but it’s hard not to overthink everything as a first-time mum.

Thank you! ❤️


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • 1d ago

Question - Research required Newborn at home and considering pulling 3 year old from daycare to prevent illness

43 Upvotes

We’ve just welcomed a new baby into our family. On the 2nd day home, our three year old presented very minor cold symptoms. We kept them apart as much as possible without being overly diligent. We opened windows, turned on air purifier and practised washing/sanitizing hands often and always before touching baby. On our baby’s 8th day of life, she presented a stuffy nose which quickly spiraled into a work of breathing leading to an airlift out of our small town for city hospitalization. We’re now reconsidering if we should keep our toddler in daycare for the next while.

Questions:

- at exactly 36 months: what are the social and developmental implications of skipping out on day care
- what are the positive implications for our toddler staying home w mom and baby even if that means slightly less enrichment
- how long should we be tremendously careful with baby’s immune system? A month? 3 months?
- i imagine daycare is the highest risk at bringing infection/disease into our home. What are some moderate and low risk options? We live in the wet cold PNW of Canada.
- any other considerations?

All family vaccines except Covid are up to date including mom getting RSV and flu shots in late third trimester. Full term healthy baby. Semi rural local hospital not equipped with paediatric care, training or facilities - city hospital only accessible by air overnight or ferry during the day.


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • 8h ago

Question - Research required Baby exposed to vape

0 Upvotes

My newborn (not even 6 weeks old yet) was in the general facility of a stupid man that was vaping. They were in a garage and the man was about 10 feet from my baby. He took 3 puffs and I’m absolutely spiraling. Does anybody have any insight into whether or not there may be health implications as a result from this?


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • 1d ago

Question - Research required How to bring baby to peds appointments with measles going around?

23 Upvotes

I have no issues avoiding public places with my baby for the foreseeable future, but how can I keep him safe bringing him to his appointments?


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • 1d ago

Question - Research required USA measles outbreak and international travel

2 Upvotes

I am currently in south east Asia and planning to return to US with my 10mo in two weeks. I fly to boston and baby was given early MMR vaccine before I left with him when he was a bit over 7mo.

I want to know the risks and find reliable sources to protect my baby during this travel.

Thank you


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • 21h ago

Question - Research required COQ10 while breastfeeding?

1 Upvotes

Sorry if this isn’t the right thread - but wondering if anyone has come across any research/data that suggests supplementing with COQ10 while breastfeeding is safe?


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • 1d ago

Question - Research required Best age to start school?

7 Upvotes

Where I am, children can be enrolled in school when they’re 4.5 as they just need to be 5 halfway into the school year. When I was a child most parents enrolled their kids when they turned 5 or were about to turn 5. However, I’m seeing a trend in recent years of holding kids back until they’re 6.

Our son’s birthday is close to the beginning of the school year so we are deciding whether to send him to school when he would have either just turned 5 or 6. Does anyone know the research on this as to what’s best for the child?


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • 1d ago

Question - Research required How do you actually decide how much UV your 0-6 month old is getting?

5 Upvotes

My daughter is 5 months old and we're outside way more now. Parks, the farmer's market, long stroller walks. And I've realized I have no actual method for UV. I check the weather app, see "UV index 7," and then just... guess.

Is the stroller canopy enough? Is that tree shade doing what I think it's doing? She wears a UPF suit but her hands and face are out. At what point should we be heading inside?


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • 1d ago

Question - Research required Should I have a consistent response to tantrums / misbehaviour?

11 Upvotes

Very firmly in the tantrum / testing-boundaries stage with my 18 month old. I’ve been responding in a few different ways:

- Behaviour that is dangerous or unacceptable gets a calm but firm no, explanation and removing her from the situation (eg “we don’t climb on the coffee table, the table is for books/drinks/toys, we stay on the floor” and taking her off the table / preventing her from climbing). She sometimes thinks my “no” is funny but I keep a straight face, repeat several times, redirect her until she stops (eg “here’s where you can climb”)

- Behaviour that I know is attention-seeking I ignore completely (eg throwing food on the floor and then looking at me to see what I do)

- Tantrums I sometimes use distraction (eg calling out for her favourite teddies and having a look for them together)

- Also sometimes ignore tantrums (eg recently she wouldn’t sit in her high chair for dinner so we let her be mad while we ate dinner until she calmed down and came over to go into her high chair and eat)

- sometimes get down on the floor with her and comfort through a tantrum (eg she is very attached to dad at the moment and if he has to go out without her she freaks out) but I feel like she rarely calms down through this, and typically I end up needing to distract her

- sometimes a bit more firm on a tantrum (eg my husband was in the toilet and she had a meltdown so I just said something like “enough of that, dada is in the toilet, he’ll be one minute”)

Should my husband and I be responding in a consistent way? Is this good/responsive, or is there a risk of confusing her?


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • 1d ago

Question - Research required Baby have trouble falling asleep

3 Upvotes

My son is having a hard time falling asleep at night. He usually doesn't go to sleep until after 9pm. And prior to that he'll fight it and start crying at times. It's possible it might be teething or overtiredness, still trying to figure it out. What is the likely reasoning behind this? And how to fix this? Can I also have supporting scientific articles for this.

Just to add I have been given Tylenol but it doesn't seem to help with the crying and falling asleep.


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • 18h ago

Question - Research required Osteopath versus physio

0 Upvotes

Our baby is 4 months and has a slight head tilt. He also does seem a bit stiff.

We spoke to our GP who referred us for nhs physio but warned that could take some time, so we are willing to pay for a private session to help him sooner.

Ive asked for recommendations and so many people are recommending an osteopath. Im a bit sceptical about Osteopaths and our GP, and also our doctor friend, both warned that its better to see a properly qualified physio. But again when I try to get physio recommendations people keep recommending and swearing by osteopaths for fixing this kind of issue.

Really interested to hear people's experiences and thoughts


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • 1d ago

Sharing research Holidays and the measles

7 Upvotes

would you go celebrate the holidays with unvaxxed family members if you had a baby who is not old enough to be vaccinated? We live in MN.