Hello everyone,
We won't be able to respond to all of the comments on our previous post, but a lot of people are asking for more context about this situation, so we're happy to oblige. There was some local reporting on this issue so we suggest you start there:
https://www.theburnerseattle.com/post/pcc-is-sending-workers-home-over-watermelon-pins-again-this-time-union-branded-ones
https://www.seattletimes.com/business/pcc-union-workers-clash-over-pro-palestinian-pins/
The short of it is, management. sent a worker home without pay and from Greenlake Village PCC and someone there contacted our union, UFCW 3000, who came up with the watermelon design. For a moment it seemed like the issue was resolved, but after our contract was settled back in June a total of 11 employees have been sent home without pay and one employee has been fired explicitly for wearing this pin.
Many workers at the Columbia City store have also been told to remove all sorts of other apparel such as a T-shirt for the band "Grateful Dead", a pin with Marsha P. Johnson's face, a pin that had a trans flag and said "protect trans kids", and a pin that simply said "no war". Management has even taken it upon themselves to remove some union pins from the union bulletin boards, which has already been litigated as an unfair labor practice and a law they've broken in the past. This all prompted workers at the Columbia City store to draft the petition that can be found in the bio of our Instagram page.
PCC management argues this pin isn't allowed because it's a "political" message that "doesn't align with our co-op values." We argue their justification isn't sufficient, and workers right now are being unfairly targeted and disciplined for that watermelon pin when we have several political pins: Trans & Pride colors, pronouns, Black Lives Matter, and so on being allowed and even encouraged to be worn in the store. When we look to our Staff Handbook about what exactly is/isn't in our co-op values we see many contradictory and blatantly absurd statements, such as:
"Black Lives Matter" pins are not political in nature and have been approved for wear.
Staff may wear PCC-branded, UFCW logo'd, or current vendor applied pins or buttons approved by PCC.
Our "Statement and Vision" section reads "PCC is committed to welcoming people of all identities cultures and backgrounds..."
"While Racism and Colonialism continue to play a significant role in shaping food systems PCC is committed to cultivating justice-centered relationships without exploitation."
Many workers we've spoken to see now problem allowing for Israeli and Palestinian pins alike, same as any other national flag, and believe workers should have the right to raise potential misalignment of these values with the shoppers. For instance, there are quite a few Nestle subsidiary products we stock on the shelves. There is a particular brand of wine that is produced in the occupied Golan Heights. Unfortunately management disagrees and responds to this perspective with intense hostility, as you all see in the video.
From our perspective, people who are trying to litigate whether or not this is legally protected union apparel are missing the bigger picture. PCC is supposed to be a co-operative, where management shouldn't have such unilateral discretion to interpret what is/isn't aligned with our values without the input of members, including and especially worker-members. We've spoken with many long-term members at our pickets and they've shared stories of how many important decisions were made back when the co-op was much more true to its actual mission, for isntance a decision about whether or not to stock meat & dairy on the shelves. Today it's taken for granted that this decision will be made by a handful of people in senior leadership and the rest of us simply have to comply or leave.
That said, this is also a legal issue and an active labor dispute. Up until this contract was settled, all UFCW apparel was allowed to be worn in the store, as was specified in the staff handbook. Now suddenly they have changed the enforcement of the policy and are using it to discipline/terminate employees. We will leave it UFCW 3000 to detail the nuances of that legal dispute before an NLRB arbitrator, but this legal dispute is ongoing and will likely continue, possibly being appealed up the jurisdiction chain, for many months if not longer.
In conclusion, we say this is an example of "textbook union busting" because management is using every tool at their disposal to break communication between the workers and the customers or workers and each other. Most shockingly by intimidating and discplining workers for speaking their mind and wearing their union pins.
Can union workers be legally trespassed from "private property" for any reason and management's discretion? Yes. Is this a tactic to disrupt completely legitimate union activity, ie: holding a petition? Also yes.
It's no different in our minds than Starbucks shutting down dozens of stores that had won successful union elections due to "security" or "financial viability" concerns. Just because it's their legal right doesn't mean it's not union busting, and we see PCC management for exactly what they are. Corporate-minded union-bustint cowards, so terrified of their workers and shoppers coming together to reclaim our Co-Op in earnest that they're willing to fire hard-working employees and ask private security and SPD to do their dirty work. Too bad for them we're only building more momentum each day.
If you've taken the time to read this we hope it gave you the context you sought. If you'd like to discuss more, then I encourage you to attend our next picket! Thank you for your time and attention to our struggle, Solidarity Forever!