Recently I posted about my 20 years experience as a Canadian Teksavvy independent internet service provider customer (i.e. not Bell, Rogers, or one of their fake (flanker) brands created to kill true and fair telecom market competition) and self-hosting with them.
I realized that my experience may be of interest to people here and decided to expand on that post.
During the past 26 years I self-hosted a server at the end of my ADSL and now VDSL residential termination. That includes email (SMTP inbound and outbound), IMAP, web (https), authoritative DNS, and ssh servers.
Many will say that a functioning email server cannot be self-hosted. My experience self-hosting email and reliably sending and receiving it proves otherwise! Don't get me wrong, running an inbound and outbound email server successfully requires knowledge, care, persistence, a backup email account elsewhere, and maybe acceptance of email loss or outage at worst . It is not the project or service one should start with. I'm fortunate in that I have self-hosted email before broadband internet was available: UUCP mail. So I learned email incrementally over the decades, growing my knowledge (and mistakes!) as email delivery requirements became much more strict.
I even host business-critical email lists, with phpList. This takes extra care!
Running a primary, authoritative DNS server at the end of a VDSL termination? In reality, the latency is about the same as my other DNS server in a data center. DNS is cached anyway, so there would only be a ~10ms delay (if that) on the first lookup of my domain.
To be clear, my self-hosted services have always existed to serve a regional, city-scale audience. Except for email, I block IP access from outside Canada now, which significantly reduces attacks and log noise.
Most importantly, I am fully able to self-host in my home because TekSavvy offers a static IP and even subnet for a few dollars more monthly, sets up a PTR record for my email server, and will even delegate DNS for my subnet. Read more about my Teksavvy experience.
I also currently operate these same services and setup in a Canadian data center VPS for a volunteer-based community newspaper.
Why do this? Firstly, because I can! Like you, I like to be self-sufficient. As a Linux enthusiast since Linux first same out (I was running a UNIX variant on a 386 computer before that) it was a natural activity. Throughout the years I learned a lot technically! I was interested to do so- and also about sysadmin rigour.
I like that our household's email messages are stored in my home (backed-up elsewhere of course) and have no storage limit. We can still access them if there is an internet outage. I have all my messages from up to 30 years ago. My self-hosting also ensures the most privacy possible for plain emails i.e. not end-to-end encrypted. Canadian emails, depending on the hosting, stay in Canada and are not subject to secret FISA requests and snooping by U.S. 'law' enforcement. I serve multiple email domains and have hundreds of email aliases to help protect privacy.
I'm keen to learn about your own experience, compare notes, and to answer questions as I am able to. (I have some real volunteer server work to do for the community newspaper so please allow a reasonable response time.).
cheers,
TheLinuxMailman