I (20F) am a junior in college. One of my close friends, “Michael” (20M), and I have known each other since freshman year, but our friendship has gotten increasingly complicated over the past year. I'm starting to wonder whether he still has some lingering feelings for me, and I'd really appreciate some outside perspectives.
Some background:
Last semester, Michael and his girlfriend of three years were very on-and-off. During that time, I felt like he started making moves to blur the line between friendship and something more.
I brought it up to him because I felt uncomfortable about the situation, especially since he was apparently back together with his girlfriend. He told me I was misinterpreting things, so I dropped it.
Eventually, they broke up for good. Not long afterward, he invited me to a party, kept offering me drinks, and we ended up making out after I got pretty drunk.
Afterward, I found out that he had told mutual friends I was just a "rebound" and that he'd only invited me because "he knew I would make out with him."
Despite this, we stayed in contact over the summer while I was studying abroad. When I got back, I visited him before school started, and we hooked up. Afterward, he essentially ghosted me for two weeks.
Then, out of nowhere, he asked me to help him make his Hinge profile.
At that point, I'd had enough and stopped responding to him.
A little while later, he showed up at my surprise birthday party on campus, even though he was taking a gap semester and living in New York.
Eventually, we sat down and had a long conversation about everything. He specifically asked me to tell him what I was upset about, so I brought up the rebound comments, the ghosting, the Hinge situation, and the movie night when he had apparently already gotten back together with his girlfriend.
He apologized and told me he really valued our friendship. I thought we had finally cleared the air.
However, the next day, he sent me several pretty aggressive texts, essentially warning me never to suggest that anything between us had to do with his previous relationship, or we would "genuinely never speak again."
I was really upset by the way he handled the situation, so I blocked him for approximately three months.
Fast-forward to recently:
We reconnected around Halloween, and things have been surprisingly normal between us. I had heard through mutual friends that he recognized how poorly he'd handled the situation.
A couple of weekends ago, my friend and I visited him in New York City, where he's currently living during his gap semester.
He was incredibly generous the entire weekend, treating us to drinks, dinner, and other things. He probably spent around $600 on us, and neither of us really paid for anything.
Obviously, I know spending money isn't necessarily romantic, especially because he was treating both of us. However, there were a few things that made me wonder whether the attraction between us was still there.
At dinner, our legs kept touching under the table. Neither of us really moved away. We also kept catching each other's eyes throughout the night, and I noticed him texting his friends about me.
Later, we watched a movie at his apartment. We sat next to each other on the couch, and I kept noticing him flexing and inspecting the arm closest to me. He's pretty muscular, so I thought this was kind of funny, but I also wondered whether he was deliberately trying to draw attention to himself.
Nothing physical happened between us that weekend.
Then, this past weekend, he came back to town for a big college football game.
He was visiting from New York, and I had agreed to drive him to Boston for the game the following day.
The night before, we went out to dinner together. Afterward, we walked around for a while and talked before going back to my place to watch a movie.
We sat next to each other on my couch, and once again, our arms were touching for part of the movie. Neither of us really made an effort to move away.
The whole evening felt very comfortable and familiar, but there was also that same underlying tension that I've felt between us before.
During dinner, I also happened to notice a notification from his ex-girlfriend on his Apple Watch. I couldn't read the message and have no idea what it said or what their current relationship is. However, given our history, it definitely caught my attention.
Here's my dilemma:
Despite everything that's happened, I think I still have some feelings for him. I don't necessarily know what I want to happen, but I can't deny that there's still attraction on my end.
I also have a suspicion that he has some residual feelings for me, or at least that the physical attraction hasn't completely disappeared.
The problem is that I absolutely do not want to make the first move.
Given our history, particularly the rebound comments, the ghosting, and the way he spoke to me before I blocked him, I feel like I've already put myself in a vulnerable position with him multiple times.
If he genuinely wants something romantic to happen between us, I want him to be the one to communicate that clearly. I'm not interested in chasing him or putting myself in another situation where he can dismiss everything as me misinterpreting his behavior.
At the same time, I recognize that our history might make him hesitant to initiate anything, especially since I blocked him for several months.
So I'm genuinely conflicted.
My questions are:
- Does his recent behavior suggest there might still be some attraction or romantic interest on his end, or am I reading too much into otherwise platonic interactions?
- Given our history, is it reasonable for me to expect him to make the first move if he wants something to happen?
- Could he be hesitant because of how badly things ended between us previously?
- Most importantly, should I even be entertaining the possibility of something romantic with him given how he's treated me in the past?
I'm perfectly capable of remaining friends with him, but I can't shake the feeling that there's still something unresolved between us.
TL;DR: My close male friend and I have a complicated history involving hooking up, mixed signals, and a falling-out that resulted in me blocking him for three months. We've recently reconnected, and over the past two weekends, we've spent a lot of time together, including dinners, movies, lingering physical contact, and moments that feel flirtatious. I suspect he might still have feelings for me, but given our history, I refuse to make the first move. Am I reading too much into things, and is pursuing anything with him even worth considering?