I'm a male in my mid 30s, BMI 23, with persistent obstructive sleep apnea despite several surgeries, including a 12 mm maxillomandibular advancement (MMA). It was done by double distraction (upper and lower jaw), with a distractor anchored in bone and teeth on the upper jaw and anchored on teeth on the lower jaw. The double distraction had no effect on my sleep apnea and little effect on my nasal breathing.
My main problem is persistent fatigue and unrefreshing sleep, rather than excessive daytime sleepiness (Epworth 9).
What makes my case unusual is that my apnea is essentially REM-only: my breathing is almost normal during non-REM sleep but deteriorates dramatically during REM.
My sleep studies
| Before MMA | 8.5 months after MMA |
|---|
| Overall AHI | 17.9 | 18.3 |
| Non-REM AHI | 9.8 | 4.9 |
| REM AHI | 33.3 | 40.6 |
| Supine AHI | 21.3 | 23.7 |
| Non-supine AHI | 12.8 | 9.6 |
Both studies were manually reviewed by the same sleep specialist. It's one night on each side, so some of the difference may be night-to-night variation.
I also estimated REM AHI by position from the report's hypnogram: about 56.6 supine and 20.2 lateral, based on 75 and 59 minutes of REM. My doctor hasn't confirmed these calculations.
About 80% of events are hypopneas. ODI is 9.6/h, minimum SpO2 88%.
My overall AHI has stayed between 14 and 21 since 2023, including after jaw expansion in 2024 and the MMA in 2026. Non-REM AHI went down after the MMA, but my overall AHI and REM AHI did not, so I count it as no effect on my apnea.
What I've already tried
- CPAP: it improves my fatigue a little (noticeable, but slight, not night and day). I can only use a full-face mask, because with a nasal mask my mouth opens during the night and wakes me up. Important: my nasal breathing clearly improves with CPAP.
- Mandibular advancement device: brought my AHI to 7 (REM AHI 15) in 2021, but it was painful. I also have bite and orthodontic issues after MMA.
- Sleeping on my side: helps substantially, but doesn't eliminate REM events.
- Myofunctional therapy: tongue rehabilitation before the distraction, to stop mouth breathing. It improved my daily comfort. Also done after the MMA.
- Weight: BMI 23.
What my DISE showed
Before MMA, drug-induced sleep endoscopy under propofol, supine only:
- Complete anteroposterior soft palate collapse.
- Very enlarged lingual tonsils, narrowing the airway by about 80%, also seen on MRIs years apart.
- The lingual tonsils pushing the epiglottis backward into an inverted V, suggesting secondary epiglottic obstruction.
- Jaw thrust improved the tongue-base and epiglottic airway considerably, but barely the soft palate.
This DISE predates the MMA. I haven't had another since.
What my two surgeons say
Maxillofacial surgeon (did the MMA): he did the maximum advancement and says there is not much else he can do for me.
Sleep ENT surgeon: he says to remove the lingual tonsils, and under a single anesthesia he proposes:
- Lingual tonsillectomy with coblation, removing the lymphoid tissue while staying out of the tongue muscle.
- A small epiglottic procedure he does systematically: he scarifies it so it heals slightly attached to the tongue and doesn't collapse backward. I'm not sure it qualifies as epiglottopexy, since sutures weren't mentioned.
- Turbinate reduction. My nasal breathing improves greatly with Derinox (a decongestant nasal spray), and the goal is to get that same breathing naturally, without the spray.
He advises against repeating the DISE: propofol sedation doesn't reproduce REM sleep, where nearly all my events occur, so it could mislead him and we would end up treating events that aren't the ones making me tired. For the same reason he wouldn't touch the soft palate, which he thinks is probably not the problem. If the surgery fails, his next step would be hypoglossal nerve stimulation, but he says we are not there at all.
One more concern: my mandible, and so the genioglossus attachments, already advanced about 13 mm during the MMA (no genioplasty), yet the REM obstruction remains. I'm unsure whether further genioglossus advancement would help or be redundant.
What I'd really like to know
- REM-isolated OSA: has anyone had a non-REM AHI below 5 but a REM AHI of 30 to 50+? What actually worked? Did your REM AHI normalize?
- Failed MMA: has anyone had a 10 to 15 mm MMA with almost no improvement? Did a repeat DISE reveal the remaining obstruction (tongue base, epiglottis, soft palate)?
- Lingual tonsillectomy or epiglottis surgery: has anyone had lingual tonsillectomy after MMA? Did it improve your REM AHI specifically? If your lingual tonsils pushed the epiglottis back, did removing them solve it, or did you need epiglottic surgery too? Has anyone had epiglottic stiffening or scarification without sutures?
- Other treatments: has anyone had success with hypoglossal nerve stimulation or genioglossus advancement for mainly REM-related OSA, especially after MMA?
I'm especially interested in real before-and-after PSG results, including unsuccessful treatments.
After so many interventions, I'm trying to understand whether removing the remaining anatomical obstruction can genuinely fix this REM-specific pattern, or whether the airway will still collapse when muscle tone drops in REM.
Any firsthand experience would be hugely appreciated. Thanks!