So I'm reflecting on my 10yrs on Reddit, the online culture and the quality of conversations I have had, been a part of and witnessed; some thoughts and worries arise, which made me (want to) design a course/lecture on how to navigate internet and social media forums such as Reddit.
Because I worry and am convinced unchecked online behavior will ultimately shape real world public discourse negatively in the future, if you're not equipped to handle it.
.
.
.
I can't speak on your behalf, only for mine, but I have seen a lot of- quite frankly- toxic behavior on this platform. Yes, I might have gotten 'butt-hurt' sometimes, but this isn't about my feelings neccessarily, since it got me thinking about this more deeply.
Reddit is and can be a great platform overall, but it has its glaring flaws: it supports and reinforces group-think and tribalism by amplifying voices who agree and silencing/pushing down those who dissent. The downvote system is broken and moderation is often compromised. You can't have true, honest and transparent discussions online about most things. I have seen lots of great, relevant, polite, calm and logically sound comments being absolutely buried and dogpiled on various topics. And they all had 1 thing in common: they threatened the tribe by shaking the status-quo, introducing nuance and asking questions. They didn't fully agree with the tribe, but they didn't fully disagree either, so what happened? Right?
I'm saying all this because it directly paves way for my next bit and it is essential for context.
Now we are in this situation:
- Person 1 disagreed with Person 2 about a subject 'X', saying what about this 'Z' and introduced nuance, the 'Y'.
- Subject 'X' was widely agreed upon, people echoing the sentiment and no one was challenging it. Until Person 1 came in with nuance 'Y' and they were met with the anger and hostility of majority of the group.
- Person 1 didn't attack anyone. They were calm and respecful. They only said, ''I understand the 'X', but I also can understand the 'Z', because of this 'Y' here.
I don't think Person 1 deserved to be attacked. There were no logical reason to. But why does this happen literally all the time across various subs and threads anyway, if it makes no sense?
I mentioned toxic behavior in the beginning, let me specify what I mean and what I have seen that made me say so. It is the casual normalization of violent rhetoric, bullying, labeling, doxxing, targeting, name-calling and even death-threats in online culture when one's views are challenged. I'm gonna be confident here and say that I'm sure all of us have been there. Or at least seen this happen.
So I've figured that when people sit behind a screen, anonymous and physically separated from you, they lose their empathy and social filters. They don't see you as a human being with feelings, they see you as an avatar representing 'the opposition''. Online spaces quickly tribalize into "us vs. them." If you question a political stance or offer an alternative view, you are instantly categorized as the ultimate enemy. In their minds this "justifies" treating you with maximum cruelty.
Algorithms and upvote systems reward 'high arousal' emotions like anger and moral superiority. Extreme statements get attention, engagement, and reinforcement from likeminded users, creating an echo chamber that rewards unhinged behavior and punishes calm, logical and structured voices.
Because people are getting ultimately getting used to the "us vs. them" tribalism modeled on Reddit, real world public discourse is eroding. People are increasingly losing the ability to have a polite, nuanced disagreement in town halls, school board meetings, or family dinners. The immediate recourse in real life is becoming exactly what it is online: total cancellation, screaming over the other person, and treating them as an existential threat rather than a fellow citizen with a different perspective.
This realization got me ultimately worried.
People have been radicalized online before and acted upon it.
The barrier between online behavior and real-world actions is porous and the dehumanization nurtured in digital echo chambers actively spills into reality. So it's not a question about if, but when this happens. So we must do what we can to combat it, the best that we can.
So I came up with an idea of a lecture on Digital Literacy and Psychological Immunization.
I have begun a rough draft of what I'd like to do and lecture and I would like to see what do you guys think and what would you add to it or improve upon:
Teach "Digital Self-Defense" and emotional awareness, rather than just how to use software or website.
- Prebunking: Teaching people how online manipulation tricks work like scapegoating, tribalism, and sensationalism before they encounter them. Once you recognize the blueprint of an outrage trap, you become immune to it.
- Emotional Autopsy: Training kids to pause when they feel a spike of anger or moral superiority online. They must learn to ask: "Is this post informing me, or is it trying to hijack my adrenaline for profit?" / ''Am I lashing out at a stereotype I've created in my head, instead of the actual user, who is disagreeing with me?''
- Empathy Training via Simulated Conflict: Using controlled, text-based classroom exercises to show students how easily written words are misinterpreted without facial expressions, proving how quickly digital communication dehumanizes others.
The ultimate goal is to shift our culture from impulsive reaction to conscious consumption, treating internet hygiene the same way we treat physical health.
Cognitive Dissonance - Why and How We Justify Everything - Belief Revision and Mental Friction
- Identifying the Friction ("Why am I angry?"): Teaching kids to recognize that cognitive dissonance feels like literal emotional distress or anxiety. When a user encounters a fact or worldview that contradicts their own, the brain often defaults to anger, mockery, or insults as a defense mechanism to escape that discomfort.
- The Upvote as a Dissonance Shield: Showing kids how Reddit's voting system acts as an "escape hatch" for this discomfort. Instead of doing the hard mental work of processing a counterargument, it is much easier to click downvote to hide the comment, post an aggressive reply for easy upvotes, and retreat into the safety of the echo chamber.
- The "Pause and Flip" Exercise: Training them to use their own anger as a trigger for self-reflection. When they feel the urge to brutally downvote or insult someone, they are taught to ask: "Am I angry because this person is genuinely wrong, or am I angry because they might be right, and accepting that would force me to change my mind?"
This is aimed to reframe cognitive dissonance from a threat into a signal, a sign that you have just encountered an opportunity to audit your own beliefs and grow.
Would this be beneficial for kids to learn, do you agree, or am I just having too much time on my hands and making a problem when there is none?