r/SolidWorks • • 8h ago

CAD Split function not working?

Hi all, hope you're doing well.

I've been regularly using the Split function in my projects without any issues, but recently I've run into a strange problem. When I try to split a piece, the option is grayed out and unavailable. Even if I overwrite an existing sketch using the exact same plane and surface that worked previously, it still stays grayed out.

Has anyone else run into this, or know why a setup that used to work is suddenly unavailable? 🤔

PS tried same on my personal laptop and work pc both have same issue and co workers also have the same problem while one guys pc works fine when i do it there... so is this a software issue?

0 Upvotes

14 comments sorted by

1

u/MetalDamo 8h ago

Are both PCs running the same version.? Did you create the model you're splitting. Some imported/converted geometry may have solids or surfaces that are invalid for some features. Have you recently updated your SW version.? I regularly see/hear of features that break in newer releases.

1

u/Initial_Fennel8518 7h ago

Everything was made exactly from scratch on same versions and we tested just on simple cubes...

0

u/MetalDamo 7h ago

Yeah. SW be like that sometimes. I've used it for >10yrs, and I've seen sheet. Without actual inspection of the file, I couldn't say.

I assume your 'simple cubes' were your test at creating a new file and testing that..?

1

u/Initial_Fennel8518 7h ago

Yes just a line to split the cube and test it does work on 2025 version on our legacy system but when i do the same steps on modern system it just fails...

0

u/MetalDamo 7h ago

Updates can break or make bugs in things that used to work fine.

Have you taken it up with your VAR.?

1

u/Initial_Fennel8518 7h ago

Im Bad with acronyms what does VAR stand for?

1

u/MetalDamo 7h ago

Ah.. they are the people you bought it from.. your Value Added Resellers. You would surely have a maintenance subscription with them. It's their job to fault find thru your issues. And they have many ways they can help..

1

u/Initial_Fennel8518 7h ago

And yes we upgrade at work regularly but never seen this big of an issue we even reached to dessault système but no response after 2 months and we have found work around but we prefer to use 1 feature instead of this work around

3

u/Drugtrain CSWP 8h ago

A good place to start is to tell which SW and SP you are using

2

u/Initial_Fennel8518 7h ago

I use 2026 commercial/enterprise and the hobbyist at home

And the only pc that seems to be working is the guys 2025 commercial pc at work

1

u/experienced3Dguy CSWE | SW Champion 7h ago edited 7h ago

Do you have a serial number-based license or is it a 3DEXPERIENCE platform-based license?

If you are using a 3DEXPERIENCE SOLIDWORKS license, make sure that you are connected to your 3DX platform's Collaborative Space. The Split function being grayed out can be an indicator of a failure to connect to a Collaborative Space.

Take a look at Kaivalya KHISTI's replies in this post from the Official SOLIDWORKS Maker Support Community forum.

https://r1132100503382-eu1-3dswym.3dexperience.3ds.com/community/swym:prd:R1132100503382:community:kKnaKWHGTPC4ut-q1X_9uA?content=swym:prd:R1132100503382:qnaquestion:9O-Ta5OWQ7ydW7wNBJN0MA

2

u/Initial_Fennel8518 7h ago

All of it is connected we use the cloud system they provide and everything is fully integrated.

Fun fact split did work after uninstall but the failed to work after second usage... never seen something like this tbh

1

u/experienced3Dguy CSWE | SW Champion 7h ago

Thanks for the info. I'm definitely convinced its a failure to connect to your Collaborative Spaces. Try out the fixes suggested in the post I linked above.

0

u/Vegetable_Flounder12 6h ago edited 6h ago

avoid using line geometry for the split, generate and use a plane rather. if the line is not recognised as attached or passing completely through the body, you will get this issue. view the line normal to its sketch plane to ensure it extends through as well as hits the body you want to split.