r/SportsCardTracker • • 19d ago

Important [EOY 2026 Survey] Determine rule satisfactory and warnings for scammers

2 Upvotes

Hi everyone,

The holidays are fast approaching us as we reach the end of the year. Therefore, there has been an uptick in posts warning about potential scammers. I'd like to gauge what everyone thinks about the current rules, whether people should be allowed to warn about potential scams, and how useful you think requiring proof for negative feedback has been. Please take a moment to fill out the survey form below and reach out if you have any concerns, or questions!

https://forms.gle/4qRiEhujKWkfGyga7


r/SportsCardTracker • • Apr 04 '26

Important Megathread - April 2026 - Potential Scammer/Pre-Sale Feedback

8 Upvotes

Please post all potential warnings for scammers, or pre-sale feedback here. You must provide photographic proof of your claims and any personal information must be redacted before providing the photos. I've attached a photo of an example of how claims/photos must be posted in order to prevent removal of your comment.


r/SportsCardTracker • • 7h ago

Positive [positive] u/fryryeasianboi

3 Upvotes

Purchased a Yu Darvish Relic. Shipped out quickly and arrived well packaged. Card came just as advertised.


r/SportsCardTracker • • 6h ago

Positive [Positive] u/thedeadfrequency

2 Upvotes

Excellent experience with this collector. Made a purchase for a few Trouts.
Packaged well, great communication. Highly recommend.


r/SportsCardTracker • • 12h ago

Positive [Positive] u/thedeadfrequency

2 Upvotes

Easy transaction, cards were shipped quickly, packaged very well and arrived in great shape. Will buy from again!


r/SportsCardTracker • • 12h ago

Positive [positive]u/electricmagician

2 Upvotes

I did another trade with him. All cards arrived safe all the way from Canada. Will continue to trade!


r/SportsCardTracker • • 10h ago

Positive [positive] u/memomlb6

1 Upvotes

Great friendly seller. Hope to have now business together


r/SportsCardTracker • • 13h ago

Positive [positive]u/russianpravda

1 Upvotes

I did another trade with him. Awesome as usual. Will keep trading.


r/SportsCardTracker • • 13h ago

Positive [positive] u/ToastGhost47

1 Upvotes

The ToastGhost is great! Prices are very fair. Communication is easy. Shipping is fast. I’m sure our paths will cross again. I highly recommend this seller!


r/SportsCardTracker • • 13h ago

Positive [positive] u/CaMcA527

1 Upvotes

I have had multiple easy purchases from CaMcA over the last few months. Always an easy and positive experiences. Communication is great. Prices are very fair. Shipping is fast. Highly recommend this seller to all!


r/SportsCardTracker • • 13h ago

Positive [positive] u/Good-Advantage872

1 Upvotes

I recently bought two vintage cards from this seller. The prices were very fair, the cards were as described, and the transaction was smooth and easy. I recommend this seller!


r/SportsCardTracker • • 13h ago

Positive [positive] u/Downtown_Ant

1 Upvotes

I recently bought multiple vintage cards from this seller in one transaction. Price was great. Shipping was fast. Communication was easy, and the cards were as described. Very positive experience all around. I recommend this seller!


r/SportsCardTracker • • 13h ago

Positive [positive] u/AGH051115

1 Upvotes

I recently bought a vintage card from this seller. The process was quick and easy. Shipping was fast, and the card is great. I recommend this seller!


r/SportsCardTracker • • 13h ago

Positive [positive] u/Tzzzzzzzzzzx

1 Upvotes

I recently bought a vintage card from this seller. The transaction was quick and easy. The card was as described. Shipping was fast. Can’t get better than that. I recommend this seller!


r/SportsCardTracker • • 14h ago

Positive [positive] u/RockyMountainRips

1 Upvotes

Grabbed a really nice looking Sal Stewart auto from RMRs for a fair price…item arrived quickly, was well packaged and in mint condition. I would definitely work with this seller again!


r/SportsCardTracker • • 15h ago

Positive [Positive] u/B-sizzauce

1 Upvotes

Great experience, bought a 1950 Bowman Phil Rizzuto. Arrived safe and looks great!


r/SportsCardTracker • • 15h ago

Positive [Positive] u/daddy_chill_300

1 Upvotes

Bought a 1957 Topps Hank Bauer. Arrived safe, looks great, would buy from again


r/SportsCardTracker • • 19h ago

Positive [Positive] u/Tzzzzzzzzzzx

1 Upvotes

Fast shipping. Great transaction.


r/SportsCardTracker • • 19h ago

Positive [Positive] u/Downtown_Ant

1 Upvotes

Great experience with seller. Fast shipping!


r/SportsCardTracker • • 1d ago

Negative [NEGATIVE]u/pretty_dragonfly_716

18 Upvotes

November 1st, User has a sales post up and had some Royals autographs from Gypsy Queen. I claimed the Royals lot on his post. User contacted me, via DM, said the lot was $10 and we agreed.

I promptly sent the money, via Venmo, to a Brandon Penvose.

I never heard another word from this user.

On November 12th I reached out to this user, disclaiming that it’s been 2 weeks and still no communication, no tracking, and of course, no cards.

This user should be banned from any platform.


r/SportsCardTracker • • 20h ago

Positive (Positive) u/ScaryParking9837

1 Upvotes

Very good items, communication, and fast shipping!


r/SportsCardTracker • • 20h ago

Positive [positive] u/IslayHaveAnother

1 Upvotes

In the end no transaction was made due to lost cards in the mail. However even though this was fault of nobody u/IslayHaveAnother immediately refunded me even though it wasn't necessary. What a gem! Will make more deals in the future!


r/SportsCardTracker • • 21h ago

Positive [positive] u/dansFC1

1 Upvotes

Another great transaction ⚾ thanks so much again!


r/SportsCardTracker • • 22h ago

Positive [Positive] u/EmoSean

1 Upvotes

Another successful transaction. Thanks!