r/StLucia • u/SleepyOrchid531 • 1d ago
St. Lucia in December — All-Inclusive vs Airbnb or Hotel? Need Advice!
Hi everyone!
My boyfriend and I are planning a 4-day trip to St. Lucia in December for his birthday, and I’m having a hard time deciding where we should stay.
We’re currently considering the Royalton St. Lucia (all-inclusive), but I’m also looking into Airbnbs or hotels that include breakfast.
For those who have visited St. Lucia, I have a few questions:
All-inclusive vs Airbnb/hotel: For a short 4-day trip, which would you recommend? Is an all-inclusive worth the money, or would we save more staying elsewhere and eating out?
Food prices: How expensive is it to eat out in St. Lucia? Are local restaurants and food spots reasonably priced, or does eating out add up quickly?
Transportation: If we choose an Airbnb or regular hotel, how easy is it to get around? Would we need a rental car, or could we rely on taxis/private drivers? I’d also appreciate recommendations for reliable, reasonably priced private drivers!
Location: What areas would you recommend staying in if we want easy access to restaurants, beaches, and activities without spending a fortune on transportation?
Royalton: If you’ve stayed at the Royalton, how was your experience, especially the food and service? I’ve been reading mixed reviews, so I’d love some honest opinions.
We’re looking for a nice, relaxing birthday getaway but also want to explore the island, try authentic local food, and maybe do an excursion or two. I just don’t want to spend unnecessarily on an all-inclusive if staying elsewhere would give us a better experience.
For only 4 days, what would you personally recommend?
Any advice or recommendations would be appreciated! 😊