r/StarWars • u/Logical-Bullfrog3216 • 8h ago
r/StarWars • u/AutoModerator • May 25 '25
Meta r/StarWars Official Watch Order Discussion Thread
So we haven't had an official watch order discussion thread in many years, so we figure its time to update the one in the FAQ. There are various other links in the FAQ, the Wookieepedia timeline of canon media, and various other discussion threads and topics over the years including a link to just searching the sub which people find challenge apparently. Also as a reminder, the Wookieepedia timeline of canon media can be sorted via the table on that page by release order or chronologically (if you decide to go that route).
A lot of the new Disney+ content brings new eyes to Star Wars all the time, and new movies will eventually too. We want to get a bit more aggressive with automod removals and referrals to the FAQ for these questions about watch order. So let's hash it out here in the comments. We will sticky this for a while and eventually it will just be linked in the FAQ along with the other topics and maybe in the sidebar too. And like some of other stickies about rules, spoilers, and new episode discussion guidelines, we may trot out this link and sticky it from time to time.
As a general rule the sub typically recommends for new viewers to watch in release order, especially for the movies. This is the semi-consensus from the fandom, and you will routinely see this as the most upvoted and posted response.
With that being said what we would like to do here also discuss other options, and possible orders to also toss in the TV media as well. Should you watch Andor first and then Rogue One before the OT? Should movies like Solo be done in release order or chronological? Should you watch The Clone Wars TV show before the PT? So on and so forth...
So lets have a solid discussion about this and make it a solid resource for those who may be new to Star Wars.
r/StarWars • u/Embarrassed_Day_1873 • 15h ago
TV I love Krennic so much, his hand gestures, diva attitude and line deliveries are perfect
r/StarWars • u/Reasonable-Film7219 • 16h ago
General Discussion Out of all the live-action lightsaber duels that occurred in the Prequel Trilogy, which one of them was your favorite one to watch, and why is that?
r/StarWars • u/ASW-G-21 • 19h ago
General Discussion Why not use multiple clone templates?
Jango Fett is a solid choice for infantry, but wouldn't the clone army be better off with multiple templates for the clones? They could use an agile little gymnast mercenary for spec ops duties, a giant for manual labor and a genius for command positions etc. Specialization usually leads to better results than just having a single jack of all trades.
r/StarWars • u/Vaderduder13 • 21h ago
Movies These two Cantina ladies look more like extras from Star Trek!
r/StarWars • u/rogue---ninja • 16h ago
General Discussion I love this vanity fair photoshoot so much and also find it really funny because they gathered up the major cast from the first 6 movies only to have both trilogies' main characters at the very corner while jar jar, bail and dooku are at the most center for some reason
The fact that george himself also isnt even at the center is also funny
r/StarWars • u/ShockOk1764 • 14h ago
TV I love how in the 1v1 between maul and palpatine on mandalore, right after maul kicks palpatine away you can see palpatine being absolutely furious for a few seconds.
r/StarWars • u/Hot_Quote2416 • 18h ago
Movies Why is it that Luke's hair in the OG Trilogy is light brown, but he is often portrayed as blonde in other media and fanarts?
r/StarWars • u/RealAd8853 • 9h ago
General Discussion What if Anakin left with Ahsoka when she left the Jedi Order?
What if Anakin just said “fuck yall” and left with her? How would everything after that change? The main thing I think would change is that I don’t think Palpatine is really going to be able to manipulate Anakin anymore since he won’t have much access to him anymore. So Anakin presumably won’t fall.
r/StarWars • u/Background_Corgi_359 • 18h ago
General Discussion Is Stormtrooper armor practical or could it be made practical for real world use?
Bordering on being a shitpost, but it was just a random silly question I had.
r/StarWars • u/JoshyBear28 • 18h ago
General Discussion Even tho Palpatine is pure evil POS if there’s anything ‘redeemable’ or good about him is the fact he always seems to have a wonderful time whenever he’s fighting someone. Look that wonderful smile on his face.
r/StarWars • u/GargantaProfunda • 23h ago
TV Star Wars Director Says Lucasfilm Got Angry After Promising Creative Freedom on New 8-Episode Series
r/StarWars • u/OhGawDuhhh • 14h ago
General Discussion 'Satan Presiding at the Infernal Council' by John Martin (1824) and Palpatine presiding over the Sith Eternal cult on Exegol in 'Star Wars Episode IX: The Rise of Skywalker' (2019)
r/StarWars • u/GargantaProfunda • 1d ago
TV Andor's creator wonders if Star Wars is 'brave' enough to continue his story
r/StarWars • u/EzraLikesLothcats • 21h ago
Fan Creations Ahsoka Season 2 '77 poster (fan art)
r/StarWars • u/Dracojo01 • 18h ago
Merchandise Is this toy actually inspired by this piece of Plo Koon concept art?
I bought this Plo Koon toy several years ago and always wondered why it came with a double-bladed weapon—something I’ve never seen anywhere else. Recently, I stumbled upon this piece of Plo Koon concept art, and it was a real lightbulb moment.
Is this toy truly inspired by this concept art, or has Plo Koon ever wielded a double-bladed weapon in any other medium?
r/StarWars • u/fiftythreestudio • 22h ago
Fan Creations I mapped the entire Skywalker saga.
r/StarWars • u/RedHeadedSicilian52 • 1d ago
Comics Still the greatest panel in a Star Wars comic
r/StarWars • u/BrunoXande • 15h ago
Games What would be the perfect Star Wars game for you?
My dream has always been to be a game developer, and as a Star Wars fan, I'm constantly wondering what the perfect game in the franchise would be.
Not the game itself, but the experience it would bring... I imagine two scenarios.
One of them would be Beginning of the Order, a game that tells the story of the High Republic's past and how the whole Jedi and Sith saga began.
Another possibility would be a game similar to Hogwarts Legacy, where a new Jedi would be at the height of the New Republic, living our own story and creating our own character.
And you, which game would you like to see come to life?
r/StarWars • u/Imaginary_Golf548 • 20h ago
Meta George Lucas' vision on the Stormtroopers being clones
Here are all the quotes I've gathered from the most direct sources regarding George Lucas's opinion on this subject! To summarize, stormtroopers were initially humans, but seeing the franchise's popularity with children, Lucas began toying with the idea of them being clones (not necessarily of Jango Fett), before confirming this in the Prequels and then gradually backtracking, particularly due to the humanization of the clones in TCW:
“LUKE
The Academy didn't change you
much...but you're back so soon? Hey,
what happened, didn't you get your
commission?
Biggs has an air of cool that seems slightly phony.
BIGGS
Of course I got it. Signed aboard
The Rand Ecliptic last week. First
mate Biggs Darklighter at your
service...”
Excerpt from a deleted scene from ANH in 1976 by George Lucas showing that Imperial military personnel are assigned to distinct roles based on their performance at the Imperial Academy (although this may only apply to the Navy and officers, not stormtroopers)
“LUKE
Well, I'll be at the Academy next
season... after that who knows. I
won't be drafted into the Imperial
Starfleet that's for sure...”
Excerpt from a deleted scene from ANH in 1976 by George Lucas showing that the imperial military depend on human recruits from the academies (even if this may only concern the navy and officers, not stormtroopers)
“LEIA
(finally)
Aren't you a little short to be a
stormtrooper?”
An excerpt from ANH as released by George Lucas in 1977 showing that the stormtroopers are all a certain height, more likely for recruitment criteria than because they are all clones (the stormtroopers have different heights and voices throughout the Original Trilogy, that ended in 1983)
“ORIGIN
The creation of an Imperial Stormtrooper. A cloned man is one of a group of genetically identical humans, an assembly-line product. He is a thinking man, but he serves a specific purpose and no other. A clone has no mother; only his trainers, and he accepts his fate because he believes it is inevitable.
A clone is, physically and emotionally, a normal man. He simply has no human rights and no name. He is the property of the Emperor.
Soldiers fully formed in the growth tanks quickly proved impractical. Scientists found themselves the befuddled fathers of one hundred sixty-pound blubbering idiots. A fetus is now removed from the hatchery after a gestation period of sixty weeks and is delivered immediately into the hands of its trainers.
TRAINING
As kids, Stormtroopers live like hardened cell-block inmates, only barely under control. Hundreds of nasty little orphans with only one thing on their minds: the sheer unparalleled joy of a good raid.
These boys know that they are special and they strut with the proud arrogance of samurai. Their military education is picked up as naturally as an infant learns to talk, and any purpose other than their preordained future as commandos is inconceivable.
By the time they are actually fourteen, they are anxious to fulfil their lifelong ambition: to wear the Imperial armor and be carried away with the Star Fleet into incredible adventure and battle.
Trainees are generally devoid of imagination, but after years of rough talk and stories, individual temperaments emerge.
[…]
IMPERIAL GUARDS
The real promotion is to become an Imperial Guard. Each Guard is assigned to an Executive of the Imperium.
Governor Moff Tarkin’s personal guard… forty men. Lord Darth Vader’s personal guard… twelve men.
Snappy uniforms and light duty. A Guard travels with his assignment, usually to the plushest environments. There are hazards.
The personal ambitions of the leader one is assigned to protect may give rise to little-publicized but very lethal feuds. The size of a titled officer’s private army is a factor in realizing his political goals, and Imperial Guards often find themselves in the role of hit men.
It is a satisfying position. A Guard never feels he is playing the traitor by assassinating rival Imperial Officers. Troopers have always been taught that the enemy are worthless insects to be stomped out, but a Guard who has successfully overcome or defended against other Imperial Guards feels that he has defeated an opponent…
RETIREMENT
Only a small percentage of Troopers survive to retirement age. As they get older, they are assigned to light duties: training, communications, stores.
Eventually they are sent to the Troopers’ Rest Camp on the holiday planet of Sochi. There are literally scores of Troopers who, captured by enemies or wounded and abandoned by their commanders, now live out the twilight of the Empire.
They have names. Without their armor, they are almost indistinguishable from the general population. Of course, such cases are rare. Officially, they do not exist.
For the Stormtroopers remain loyal to their dedication to the proposition that the only good alien is a dead one.”
An excerpt from the article "Soldiers of the Empire" written by Anthony Fredrickson for the January 1978 issue of Star Wars Official Poster Monthly 4 already suggests that stormtroopers are clones, although George Lucas's input remains difficult to estimate; it is possible that he nevertheless suggested the idea, given the quality of other information in the issue, and the fact that it creates a parallel with the police officers in his earlier film THX-1138 who are revealed to be helmeted androids with very human voices and in the service of a totalitarian regime
“EXT. TIPOCA CITY, PARADE GROUND (RAINSTORM) - DAY
OBI-WAN, LAMA SU and TAUN WE come out onto a balcony. Below is a huge parade ground. The rain and wind are brutal. THOUSANDS OF STORMTROOPERS, faces covered by helmets, are marching and drilling in formations of several hundred.”
Occasion when the clone troopers were referred to, for the only time, as Stormtroopers by George Lucas in the first two drafts of AOTC (2000-2001)
“OBI-WAN
Where is this bounty hunter now?
LAMA SU
Oh, we keep him here. After a few
hundred thousand clones, the
genetic pattern starts to fade, so
we take a fresh supply. He lives
here, but he's free to come and go
as he pleases.”
Cut dialogue, present in the first two drafts of AOTC by George Lucas, signifies that the stormtroopers are not clones of Jango Fett (since he dies at the end of the movie), but clones of other genetic templates, or perhaps not clones at all (2000-2001)
“OBI-WAN
Cloners? Are they friendly?
DEXTER JETTSTER
It depends.
OBI-WAN
On what, Dex?
Dexter grins.
DEXTER JETTSTER
On how good your manners are...
and how big your pocketbook is...”
Quote from AOTC present since the first draft, mentioning that producing clones is very expensive
“It wasn’t until I started working on this script that I decided to make Boba the son of the original clone. Before, he was just another clone who was, you know, for whatever reason, broken loose from the stormtroopers. I didn’t really go into detail at that point even in my mind or in the backstory about any more of it other than they were connected. But early on, the stormtroopers were meant to be clones.”
George Lucas's Audio Commentary for AOTC in 2002
“This is our first chance to really realize, oh my gosh, these clone troopers are really stormtroopers.”
An animator during the AOTC Audio Commentary in 2002
"Throughout, as we go through the movie, there's all little funny moments, like Jango bumping his head, because in Star Wars, one of the stormtroopers bumps his head on the door as they leave the control room on the Death Star. And I thought, wouldn't it be funny if that's a trait that Jango has. When he puts his helmet on and everything, he can't really see that well and he's constantly bumping his head. And that trait gets cloned into all the stormtroopers, and that's why they keep bumping their heads."
George Lucas's Audio Commentary for AOTC in 2002
"Well, they start to turn to different sources when they need it, that's why you get the differences," offers George as an explanation. "We get a model that isn't the Jango version, that doesn't bump his head on doors. But then we get versions that can't shoot straight," he laughs. "I can see the corruption in the Empire: someone says to the Emperor, my cousin would like to fight in the wars, but he doesn't want to do any of the actual fighting. Can you clone him? Well, can he shoot? Ah, yeah. Sure he can."
George Lucas's quotes on the set of AOTC in 2002
"I always knew the Stormtroopers were clones."
George Lucas's quote in a Starlog Magazine from 2002
“To develop the next generation of clone troopers, the Art Department attempted to bridge the gap between Episode II clones and the stormtroopers seen in Star Wars: A new hope. As Episode III takes place only three years after Episode II and about 19 years before Episode IV, the design had to favor the beginning of this transition. The thematic transition – cemented in the shocking betrayal of the clones against their Jedi masters – was so complete that writer George Lucas was referring to the armored soliders as “stormtroopers” by the end of the shooting script.”
The Making of Revenge of the Sith from 2005
“Aging at twice the rate of normally birthed humans, only two-thirds of the original army of clone troopers are alive. Clones are also being grown on other worlds, with cells procured from new templates.”
ROTS Visual Dictionary from 2005
“After Palpatine's creation of the Empire, academies for the training of non-clone Imperial officers will appear.”
ROTS Visual Dictionary from 2005
“Those who have seen all six movies now know that there is a direct link between the Clone Troopers of the first three episodes and the Storm Troopers of the three that follow. So are all those soldiers from the original trilogy actually just the same guy? "Yes," Lucas said. Fair enough, master — but if that's true, then why do the troopers in the earlier movies possess different voices?
"Well, yeah, some of the voices have been changed, um, to make it more consistent," he said, raising an eyebrow at the precociousness of the Padawan. Indeed, Lucas has gone back and changed the voices of the Storm Troopers during recent re-edits for the special editions. "Those particular two guys that you're talking about — which I know about, which is a very good performance — the idea is that over time, there were new clone strains introduced, and then they even conscripted guys to be Storm Troopers. So it's not just purely clones: It started out as clones, but then it got diluted over the years as they found out they could shanghai guys [more cheaply] than they could build clones."
Excerpt from a May 2005 interview with George Lucas by MTV News during the promotion of ROTS
“Imperial citizens must do their part. Join our grand star fleet. Become the eyes of the Empire by reporting suspected insurrectionists. Travel to the corners of the galaxy to spread the principles of the New Order to barbarians. Build monuments and technical wonders that will speak of our glory for generations to come.
The clone troopers, now proudly wearing the name of Imperial stormtroopers, have tackled the dangerous work of fighting our enemies on the front lines. Many have died in their devotion to the Empire. Imperial citizens would do well to remember their example.”
Palpatine's full speech in ROTS as written by Pablo Hidalgo and Daniel Wallace for the article "Republic HoloNet News Special Inaugural Edition 16:5:241" for Star Wars Insider 84 in 2005
“None of the stormtroopers will be clones. This is because, according to George Lucas’ notes, the clones proved too individualistic, whereas stormtroopers recruits will be more patriotic. Some of the clones still alive went on to train the stormtroopers, while the others became disaffected with the regime.”
Information obtained by journalist Rich Alot at New York Comic Con in 2013 regarding the production of Star Wars: Rebels, so after TCW
"Stormtroopers were clones until around 2007 when he changed his mind and actually started telling stories with clones."
Pablo Hidalgo on Twitter in June 24, 2017, showing that with the creation of TCW which humanizes the clones for children, making it impossible that, Lucas returned to indoctrinated conscripts to solve the moral problem of the OT heroes killing stormtroopers, which he wanted to explain with Underworld
"StarWars.com: By documenting the total story of troopers as a story element in the saga, and as an icon of Star Wars in our world, you also are giving a history of Star Wars moviemaking, merchandising, and cultural impact, from the original trilogy through the prequels, TV series, and into the Disney era with the sequels and standalones. What in this overall history really stands out for you? What cool tidbits of information really amazed you?
Adam Bray: I was surprised how much influence Hasbro has had on recent Star Wars animation, from initiating Tartakovsky’s Clone Wars series, to the classic Kenner action figures as inspiration for the character designs in Star Wars Rebels. I was also fascinated how George Lucas’ ideas about who stormtroopers were actually changed over time. It wasn’t until he began conceptualizing a Star Wars TV show that Lucas decided the stormtroopers would be normal humans rather than clones.
George Lucas’ artistic choices about how to portray the militaries of the Republic and Empire were also fascinating. The diversity in personalities within the clone army versus the uniformity of troopers and officers within the Empire (despite no longer being clones) is quite a contrast. The Republic valued diversity, and so the clones were allowed freedom of personal expression. The Empire, on the other hand, was a repressive regime that demanded order through conformity, or sameness. […]"
Quotes published StarWars.com in 2018 about Lucas's opinion changing around 2007 during the writing of story treatments for the never-produced live-action Underworld series
"THE CHOSEN ONE
George Lucas: When writing the movies, I tried to make sure that aliens and droids got killed, but not people.
Paul Duncan: A lot of stormtroopers died.
George Lucas: That's right, but you didn't know they were people. We did kill three humans and that was unfortunate. I was always bothered by it.
Paul Duncan: When was that?
George Lucas: On the Death Star, when Han and Luke go into the prison with Chewie to rescue Leia, they shoot three Imperial guys. The guards drew their guns and fired first, but it's still a shame.
Paul Duncan: Really?
George Lucas: Yeah, we very consciously didn't kill very many humans in those movies.
Paul Duncan: What about the stormtroopers? They look robotic, but they're not.
George Lucas: How do you know what they are?
Paul Duncan: Did you have a different idea of what they were?
George Lucas: Yeah, they started out as clones. Once all the clones were killed, the Empire picked up recruits, like militia. They fought, but they weren't very good at what they did.
Paul Duncan: That's why they kept missing.
George Lucas: That's why they kept missing."
An interview with George Lucas conducted around 2019 for the The Star Wars Archives: Episodes I-III 1999-2005 book
r/StarWars • u/EveningDust780 • 7h ago
Movies What do people mean when they say that Hayden Christensen "looks" the part?
I've heard it said multiple times that Hayden "looks" like the character of Anakin Skywalker. I find this interesting considering there really isn't much to compare him to. There's Sebastian Shaw, but his force ghost was exchanged with Hayden's in the edited version of ROTJ. Shaw still appears as Vader unmasked, but I don't think that's a very good basis to compare Hayden to because the character is scarred and deformed at this point. To me, it's like someone saying: "such and such actor looks like (insert mythological character here)!" Admittedly, I really do want to agree with this sentiment, but I know that I'm simply biased because I only know Hayden as Anakin and can't imagine anyone else portraying the character. I could also just be looking to deeply into this.
On another note, I've also heard people complain that animated counterparts of characters don't look like the actors that portrayed them in the movies. I don't hate this because it makes the characters seem more like characters rather than actors, if that makes any sense.