TLDR: Founders know everything about their startup and to them their decks make sense in their heads. But the number one killer is they pitch to themselves first and to themselves as customers second. Decks then become non sensical with inside language.
I review dozens of pitch decks every week on behalf of founders and investors for deal flow. After a particularly egregious one I decided to write this post.
Disclaimer: I’m not the end all be all authority on pitch decks. Many founders have raised using decks that ignore my advice. This is all IMHO based on my experiences raising for 7 startups, writing angel checks, and working in VC.
Next: I know many really smart founders that deserve to be funded but totally botch their decks. How good you are at pitch decks does not reflect the value of your startup. However, they do tell us how clear you are on your idea. But a lot of times it’s just a skills issue with pitch decks.
Mistake 1: founders overload their decks with everting because that’s what they’d want to know if they were the investor, right?
Founders self-insert and pitch to an audience of one, themselves. I’d say it’s more about insecurity than ego. But some founders definitely like to hear themselves think and pitch.
The solution is to put yourself into the investors shoes. What do they want to hear? What do they need to hear and in what order? If it’s my first time looking at your deck, I want to know if it even fits my investment thesis rather than your life story. I want to know what the problem you’re solving is, not the 100 features you offer. I want to know your team and what experience you have with the problem versus your whole biography and origin story.
Investors whether they’re technical or not don’t want to see long acronyms or jargon that are in your head all day. They want to know in plain words the problem, solution, and how big the market is in less than 30 seconds before they decide to look at the rest of your deck.
The only exception is if you have so much cred like a unicorn exit or you’re famous. If so, start with that.
Mistake 2: pitching the customer because of course you’d be your own customer, right?
The first sign of this is when founders use “you” or “your.” For example they’ll say things like “You can get access to your medical records all one app and save 50% on your insurance.”
What if the investor doesn’t need better insurance? What if they’re happy and don’t have the problem of lost medical records? You’re taking a big risk of alienating the investor.
If seen more egregious examples of someone pitching women’s health products using the same language to groups of men.
Now, in of itself the mistake is not that bad from a semantics standpoint. But it’s a cognitive position that shades the rest of the deck. These decks are filled with buzz and hype targeting the customer and selling versus explaining to the investor how much you know about your market and what you’ve done to derisk it.
Another exception is if you’ve got baby unicorn in a rocket ship traction, and can show a hockey stick graph week over week, then start with that.
Bonus mistake: founders name their round and put the investment terms in the deck, because that’s what smart founders do, right?
Some might find this polarizing but I never put deal terms in introduction pitch decks. These are the first decks investors see. My goal is to get a meeting, not close a check or get a term sheet. So less is more.
But I see founders label it a seed round when they only have an idea. Then they put in strange valuations and classes of shares with discounts in the first 30 days.
It’s another risk here. Don’t give investors any reason to think you’re dumb and naive even if you’re totally new at this. You don’t want the power dynamic going in that direction. A lot of investors are jerks and if you give them an inch they’ll put it through your eye. Sad but true and I have receipts. Get them to the table first and then they’ll work with you on the terms and have a lot more patience because they want to invest.
The moral of this long story (if you made it this far, kudos and apologies for bad grammar and typos) is get out of your own head. Show your pitch decks to real humans before investors. AI will never be able to tell you the nuances of how people will respond. AI is great for logical structure and mechanics but it can’t tell you the cognitive biases of investors or how your biases are getting in the way.
Have a great weekend!