r/startups • • 2h ago

I will not promote Which biz would you pursue and why? I will not promote

4 Upvotes

I'm considering starting one of two marketplace businesses and would appreciate some objective opinions.

  1. An F&B space marketplace: A platform connecting F&B businesses, including home-based food operators, food trucks and small brands, with available commercial spaces and trading opportunities such as kiosks, pop-up spaces, retail spots, bazaar stalls and event locations. Revenue would come from booking commissions, placement fees and potentially recurring partnerships.
  2. A travel distribution marketplace: A B2B platform connecting tour operators, DMCs, hotels and experience providers with independent sales partners such as travel consultants, licensed guides, creators and travel communities who promote and sell their packages for a commission. Revenue would come from booking commissions and potentially supplier fees.

Which would you pursue and why? Based on ease of getting off the ground, supplier and partner willingness to participate, market demand, speed to first revenue, repeat business, commission potential and long-term scalability. Which has fewer barriers to acquiring supply and customers and reaching viable revenue? I'd appreciate honest criticism, including reasons you wouldn't pursue either.


r/startups • • 7h ago

I will not promote Advice on cold emailing for validation conversations with potential B2B customers? (I will not promote)

9 Upvotes

I'm in the validation stages of a B2B SaaS and about to reach out to public relations agency Partners/Directors/key decision makers in Sydney.

Of course, these people are very busy and I know that my email cannot come across as a sales pitch or fail to get to the point quickly - at the same time, I need to address their potential pain point in order for them to feel this is something worth speaking to me with.

Does anyone here have good experiences/advice with cold email outreach when you are in the validation stages of an idea? I'm hoping to secure 5-10 20 minute coffees in the city.

I also have a landing page setup (won't link in case not allowed - but has a short blurb on my mission and a 'stay updated' form) which uses the same domain as the email I am sending from and a MVP - although I won't show the MVP until later in a meeting and only if I think it goes some way to solving the pain points they have expressed.

I really don't want to end up in a position where all my outreach has failed and I'm stuck with validating my SaaS.

Any advice on my draft email below and how to do this is appreciated - thanks!

Subject: A question from an ex-financial PR

Hi [first name],

I spent [X] years in corporate and financial PR in London, at {firm 1} and {firm 2}, and have just moved to Sydney.

Something I've been thinking about since leaving is how agencies show clients the impact of their work: what goes into the coverage emails and monthly reports, how much time it takes, and what clients actually value. I'm keen to hear how it works at firms here, and [agency] came up as one I'd love to learn from.

Could I please buy you a coffee and have just 20-minutes of your time in the next few weeks? Happy to come to you.

Best,


r/startups • • 18m ago

I will not promote How to join as a founding CTO and find a CEO ? What has worked for you? I will not promote

0 Upvotes

I'm a software engineer, reached 40 y.o, with various experiences (made my own iOS apps, backend, HW, etc), living in the bay area, and I want to make a change in my life. If I don't see traction, I will come back to a job search.

One option is to raise money and create a startup. I don't think I will be successful alone and I don't think I should be the CEO. Networking, selling, etc is not my strong suite.

How do I find a CEO? (so that I would be the CTO)
There are some events out there, and websites dedicated to match making, but I wondered : Would the good CEOs join these platforms ? Don't they already know people who would die to start something with them? Are these platforms for the "left overs" ?

I'm curious to know what people in my situation did, what worked and what hasn't worked for them, or what are some observations that you made

Thanks!


r/startups • • 13h ago

I will not promote Are developer tools becoming too saturated? I will not promote

10 Upvotes

I've been observing the developer tools space lately, and something feels different.

It seems like more developers are building their own tools instead of adopting existing products. Many ideas that seemed like interesting opportunities just a few months ago now feel crowded or easy to replicate.

At the same time, some of the problems that remain seem to require resources and infrastructure that only larger companies can realistically afford.

Am I looking at this the wrong way? Is the devtools market actually becoming harder to enter, or am I just overlooking opportunities?

I'd especially appreciate advice from founders who have built or launched products in this space.


r/startups • • 1h ago

I will not promote What startup credit programs actually give you with $0 raised (i will not promote)

1 Upvotes

Most credit lists quote the funded tier, the $100k AWS and $350k Google kind. We're self-funded, so I wrote down what we actually got instead. So far it is $30,500. AWS $10,000, Cloudflare $10,000, DigitalOcean $5,000, Google Cloud $3,000, OpenAI $2,500. All we had was a registered company, a live site and an email on our own domain.

Timing matters more than the amount. Credits expire, usually 6 to 24 months after approval, so applying on day one mostly means watching them run out. Apply when real load starts.

Google and Microsoft credits don't cover Claude, it goes through their marketplaces. Microsoft's famous $150k is a ladder that starts at $200, and the upper steps take months of Azure usage. NVIDIA Inception is free and opened a bigger AWS tier for us. Brex, Mercury and Clerky show partner perks once you open an account, and everyone sees the same ones.

Has anyone here been approved or turned down somewhere with zero funding? Feels like a few programs changed their rules this year without saying so.


r/startups • • 1d ago

I will not promote Is it easier to partner with someone who has the skills that you lack, or learn them yourself? What if said partner leaves? (I will not promote)

37 Upvotes

Basically the title.

Operating yourself gives you more controls. But more skills to learn.

My dilemma is that I would like to make decisions, the issue is that there is a potential partner who possesses the skills that I lack (e.g sales skills, public presentations) but he has also vocalised that it’s important that only one person should make the final decision. He has expressed that he would like to make the final decisions.

On paper, we compliment each other with skills that the other person lacks. I am more of a background person, he likes to network and be in the light etc etc.

Thoughts?


r/startups • • 2d ago

I will not promote After reviewing dozens of pitch decks this week this is the biggest common mistake (I will not promote)

54 Upvotes

TLDR: Founders know everything about their startup and to them their decks make sense in their heads. But the number one killer is they pitch to themselves first and to themselves as customers second. Decks then become non sensical with inside language.

I review dozens of pitch decks every week on behalf of founders and investors for deal flow. After a particularly egregious one I decided to write this post.

Disclaimer: I’m not the end all be all authority on pitch decks. Many founders have raised using decks that ignore my advice. This is all IMHO based on my experiences raising for 7 startups, writing angel checks, and working in VC.

Next: I know many really smart founders that deserve to be funded but totally botch their decks. How good you are at pitch decks does not reflect the value of your startup. However, they do tell us how clear you are on your idea. But a lot of times it’s just a skills issue with pitch decks.

Mistake 1: founders overload their decks with everting because that’s what they’d want to know if they were the investor, right?

Founders self-insert and pitch to an audience of one, themselves. I’d say it’s more about insecurity than ego. But some founders definitely like to hear themselves think and pitch.

The solution is to put yourself into the investors shoes. What do they want to hear? What do they need to hear and in what order? If it’s my first time looking at your deck, I want to know if it even fits my investment thesis rather than your life story. I want to know what the problem you’re solving is, not the 100 features you offer. I want to know your team and what experience you have with the problem versus your whole biography and origin story.

Investors whether they’re technical or not don’t want to see long acronyms or jargon that are in your head all day. They want to know in plain words the problem, solution, and how big the market is in less than 30 seconds before they decide to look at the rest of your deck.

The only exception is if you have so much cred like a unicorn exit or you’re famous. If so, start with that.

Mistake 2: pitching the customer because of course you’d be your own customer, right?

The first sign of this is when founders use “you” or “your.” For example they’ll say things like “You can get access to your medical records all one app and save 50% on your insurance.”

What if the investor doesn’t need better insurance? What if they’re happy and don’t have the problem of lost medical records? You’re taking a big risk of alienating the investor.

If seen more egregious examples of someone pitching women’s health products using the same language to groups of men.

Now, in of itself the mistake is not that bad from a semantics standpoint. But it’s a cognitive position that shades the rest of the deck. These decks are filled with buzz and hype targeting the customer and selling versus explaining to the investor how much you know about your market and what you’ve done to derisk it.

Another exception is if you’ve got baby unicorn in a rocket ship traction, and can show a hockey stick graph week over week, then start with that.

Bonus mistake: founders name their round and put the investment terms in the deck, because that’s what smart founders do, right?

Some might find this polarizing but I never put deal terms in introduction pitch decks. These are the first decks investors see. My goal is to get a meeting, not close a check or get a term sheet. So less is more.

But I see founders label it a seed round when they only have an idea. Then they put in strange valuations and classes of shares with discounts in the first 30 days.

It’s another risk here. Don’t give investors any reason to think you’re dumb and naive even if you’re totally new at this. You don’t want the power dynamic going in that direction. A lot of investors are jerks and if you give them an inch they’ll put it through your eye. Sad but true and I have receipts. Get them to the table first and then they’ll work with you on the terms and have a lot more patience because they want to invest.

The moral of this long story (if you made it this far, kudos and apologies for bad grammar and typos) is get out of your own head. Show your pitch decks to real humans before investors. AI will never be able to tell you the nuances of how people will respond. AI is great for logical structure and mechanics but it can’t tell you the cognitive biases of investors or how your biases are getting in the way.

Have a great weekend!


r/startups • • 2d ago

I will not promote How did your open source startup make money? (I WILL NOT PROMOTE)

14 Upvotes

So, I've started a new product around three weeks ago. And later decided to open-source it.

First let me explain my decision:

The app operates in a sensitive space, basically it's an inbox app for email (not gonna go into details). And as you all know, email is very sensitive, and not many people would be willing to trust a random company it.

And that's the main reason. I'm open-sourcing it for trust and transparency. And anyone who does not trust me with their email, can self-host it.

That said, I'm still looking for advice. I’ve never tried to make money from an open source project. I’ve studied Plausible, Cal.com and Supabase, but I’m still nervous. I should also mention that I'm fully bootstrapped, so I'm looking for advice, if you're building an open-source product,

  • How did you manage to get your first customers? And where did they come from?
  • What was different about running a business on open source?
  • Did self-hosters cut into paid conversions? If so what were their reasons?
  • How did you choose a license, and did it matter commercially? (I'm planning on choosing AGPL).

r/startups • • 2d ago

I will not promote First sales motion, how you found yours (I will not promote)

30 Upvotes

Hi guys, I’m doing b2b first time in my life and find most advice and guiding focuses on repeating already discovered sales motion and tells about how to scale it, make it repeatable etc.

But the very first experiments and attempts feel so weird and unclear. And I figured it out that at least for myself AI doesn’t help with it much, neither with some brainstorming, nor drafts.

I just can’t figure out so far what’s the moment when it starts working and how you understand it (besides “it starts selling”).

I’m trying to do cold outreach in hr space, collecting signals, trying to find relevant data and timing, do some work before reaching to a person and doing some artifacts, but have no results.

So would love to hear about your case and how you found what’s working with cold, how much time it took and what you figured out were your main mistakes in mindset probably.

I’m now reading founding sales book, trying to “feel” it and just send 10-20 well researched(imho of course) cold emails per week and some LI DMs.

I’m just lost a little bit because of the silence, and just putting in more effort doesn’t change anything for me. Maybe I have some blockers in my head, or in my product, or in my approach, or I just don’t know how to talk to people because last 10 years I spent in my room with computers - idk.

Please share your story, I'm tired of AI/guides/books and just want to talk to a human :’)


r/startups • • 2d ago

I will not promote Software Is Becoming More Like Content & SaaS Could Thrive Because of It. ("i will not promote")

13 Upvotes

Every few days I see another post saying AI is killing SaaS. But Honestly, I think the opposite is going to happen. We’re going to have more SaaS products than ever, and they’ll become much more personalized.

one thing I’ve noticed is that people don’t always care about impressive features. Sometimes they keep using an app because it solves one boring problem in their daily routine. AI is making it easier to build software for those very specific needs.But here’s another thing I’ve been thinking about. A lot of these products might not last very long. People could try an app for a few weeks, switch to something better, or just build their own version. Software might become a bit like content. New things appear every day, people try them, and only a few become part of their lives.

The ChatGPT ecosystem makes this even more interesting.I recently listened to Tibo Sottiaux on Lenny’s Podcast. He talked about revenue sharing for popular ChatGPT plugins and how retention and quality influence which plugins get recommended. Sam Altman has also talked about making apps inside ChatGPT more interactive and personalized.

It got me wondering whether we’ll eventually move toward a single subscription model. Imagine paying for ChatGPT and getting access to thousands of useful little apps, while their creators earn revenue based on actual usage.I could be wrong, but I can see something like this becoming a real business model.

Now, if AI makes it possible for almost anyone to build SaaS, where does the value come from? I think YouTube is a good comparison. When YouTube started, anyone could upload videos. But how many people actually became successful creators? The ability to upload wasn’t what made them successful. They had to understand their audience, improve their content, and keep showing up.

I think something similar will happen with SaaS. Building the product is becoming easier. Understanding users, earning their trust, and consistently improving something they actually need is still difficult.

If I were starting a SaaS today, I’d rather have 30 people using it every week than 3,000 people signing up and never returning. Especially if platforms like ChatGPT start rewarding products based on how useful they are to real users. So I don’t think SaaS is dying. I think the number of products will explode, but building a product and building a sustainable business will become two very different things. I'm curious what other SaaS founders think.


r/startups • • 2d ago

Feedback Friday

14 Upvotes

Welcome to this week’s Feedback Thread!

Please use this thread appropriately to gather feedback:

  • Feel free to request general feedback or specific feedback in a certain area like user experience, usability, design, landing page(s), or code review
  • You may share surveys
  • You may make an additional request for beta testers
  • Promo codes and affiliates links are ONLY allowed if they are for your product in an effort to incentivize people to give you feedback
  • Please refrain from just posting a link
  • Give OTHERS FEEDBACK and ASK THEM TO RETURN THE FAVOR if you are seeking feedback
  • You must use the template below--this context will improve the quality of feedback you receive

Template to Follow for Seeking Feedback:

  • Company Name:
  • URL:
  • Purpose of Startup and Product:
  • Technologies Used:
  • Feedback Requested:
  • Seeking Beta-Testers: [yes/no] (this is optional)
  • Additional Comments:

This thread is NOT for:

  • General promotion--YOU MUST use the template and be seeking feedback
  • What all the other recurring threads are for
  • Being a jerk

Community Reminders

  • Be kind
  • Be constructive if you share feedback/criticism
  • Follow all of our rules
  • You can view all of our recurring themed threads by using our Menu at the top of the sub.

Upvote This For Maximum Visibility!


r/startups • • 2d ago

I will not promote Keiretsu Forum charges $14,000 to pitch, with no guarantee of an investment I will not promote

55 Upvotes

Why in the world would anyone pay $14k to pitch to an angel group?! And why does it charge that: doesn’t it make enough from investments and member dues?

The $14k is a verified amount.

There are lots of angel groups that don’t charge anything to pitch.


r/startups • • 3d ago

I will not promote Just quit my first job which had me at $175K OTE. Moving on & trying to start a business (26 years old) - I will not promote

30 Upvotes

Part of me is scared but excited. Spoke to my bosses today, told them that I am nothing but grateful for the opportunity. I was with the company for 2 years and it was actually my first real job. I was able to make $120K the first year & $175K the second (the cap).

I could've seen myself growing more within the company (albeit not financially as I hit my curve/cap) but I honestly grew burnt out. I was easily one of the top guys and it churned and burned me whenever I would have successful months and things would be taken from my book or business to help others that were lagging behind.

Regardless of that, I emphasized to them all that I'm leaving without any bitterness & that it's nothing they necessarily did, but that I just want to take a shot in the dark.

I want to start a business in this same industry I've been in for almost 2 years. I want to begin & I've received some mellow guidance as to how to slowly pile up bricks to build it.

Part of me feels scared as I mentioned, and excited. I'm 26 after all.. and leaving behind this much cash is scary considering I'm not sure I can't find jobs that will deliver that back to me.

I have $120K saved and ready to invest into my business, low expenses, support from my significant other & a few industry friends.

I would love if any of you can share some advice and/or thoughts after reading this post.


r/startups • • 4d ago

I will not promote Very sad rn I will not promote

58 Upvotes

So I was part of an accelerator and recently had their final pre seed funding round. They say I am very good technically and built something great but they think my ceo is really bad commercially as we were not able to sell a pretty good product.

I am depressed we gave our all the last few months and really built a cool product. Sales are hard and my co-founder is a good friend, I accept we could have done better commercially but still cannot accept this is the end.

I do want to continue building but I am really short on money and cannot afford it anymore.

Sorry you had to hear the rant


r/startups • • 4d ago

I will not promote I will not promote. How to turn a failed startup to skip ahead in corporate?

27 Upvotes

Second startup. First one conferred me no advantages when I went back to corporate. 2nd startup also dying. How do I leverage this to skip a few levels ahead instead of going back as a Senior PM. Self funded so no fund raising required. Small team of 3 founders who worked full time/ part time for no pay. I was CEO.


r/startups • • 3d ago

I will not promote How to get a product made ( i will not promote)

6 Upvotes

How to make a product . I will not promote

So ive been watching lots of shark tanks etc. How do I go about actually getting a product made, made to test, sell .

They all say on the show it costs "this much landed"

How do I go about getting my idea of a product made? Are there specific companies that do all the development?

Thanks for any advice


r/startups • • 4d ago

I will not promote Consumer apps that spread without paid ads: what was the actual mechanic? (i will not promote)

9 Upvotes

I keep reading "make it shareable" but rarely the specifics. The examples I know: Wordle's emoji grid, Spotify Wrapped, BeReal's daily notification, Duolingo streaks people screenshot.

For those who've seen a consumer app grow mostly through users sharing it: what exactly did people share, and why did it make someone else install? Was it a result, an identity thing ("look what I am"), a challenge, or something useful to the person receiving it?

I'm especially curious about boring categories like education or personal finance, where nobody brags about their spreadsheet.


r/startups • • 3d ago

I will not promote I will not promote - How much do early-stage startups care about email infrastructure pricing?

4 Upvotes

Hey founders!

I'm trying to understand how early-stage startups approach transactional email costs.

A lot of products start with free providers, but eventually need more volume.

Resend is one of the popular options, but its first paid tier is around $20/month.

We're exploring whether a smaller paid entry point would be more useful for startups.

Here's the pricing structure we're considering:

PlanMonthly priceEmail allowance
Free$0500
Starter$725,000
Pro$1575,000
Scale$75200,000

The differentiators we're considering:

  • Unlimited contacts on every plan.
  • Unlimited broadcast audience starting at $7.
  • No daily transactional sending cap on $15 and $75 paid plans.

We would initially offer a smaller free tier because we can't afford to match established providers' free infrastructure costs.

I'd love to understand:

  1. Is $20/month too much for email infrastructure at an early stage?
  2. Would $7/month make a meaningful difference?
  3. Do you need broadcast emails as well as transactional emails?
  4. Would you trust a new provider if it offered comparable reliability?
  5. What would make you switch from your current provider?

Not launching anything here. Just trying to validate the pricing and use cases before committing to building it.


r/startups • • 4d ago

I will not promote After 10 years we made our core paid feature free. Revenue dropped hard. Was it a mistake? (I will not promote)

8 Upvotes

I've run a small bootstrapped consumer app since 2015. It moves music libraries between streaming services. I won't name or link it, because I want pushback on the decision, not traffic.

The old model

Free users could move 300 songs (600 if they joined our newsletter). Then a subscription. On paper it worked: the limit converted a lot of one-time users into paying users.

The catch: most of them cancelled right after their transfer. Moving your library is a one-time job. People paid once, got what they needed, and left. Our "subscription" business was really a one-time purchase business with extra steps.

A decade of stagnation

The market is small and crowded. Every year it was the same fight with the same competitors over the same one-time customers. Revenue stayed flat.

What we changed

We made basic transfers free, with a fair-use limit (up to 10,000 songs per account). The subscription now pays only for ongoing value: playlist tools and auto-sync between services. If you use two services at the same time, you need it every week, not once.

The bet: a free app spreads much further than a paid one (more installs, more ratings, more word of mouth), and recurring users convert to MRR that actually stays.

Where we are now

Revenue dropped significantly. We have enough savings to ride it for a long time, so this is not a survival post. But I underestimated how hard it is to watch the number drop every day and keep trusting the plan.

What I learned so far

  1. High conversion can hide a bad model. Our free limit converted well, and that made us blind to how fast people churned.
  2. State the free limit up front. Otherwise you get angry customers.
  3. With no revenue per transfer, growth has to come from somewhere else: a rating ask after a good transfer, share links, referrals and SEO.

My questions for you

  • If you moved a core feature from paid to free in a mature product, how long until revenue came back, if it did?
  • How do you decide when a drop is "the bet needs time" and when it is "the bet failed"? What metric did you watch?
  • We also sell a lifetime plan next to monthly and yearly. Lifetime brings cash now but eats future MRR. Did anyone regret offering it?

My biggest question is, do we go back to freemium model if this does not grow our app? How long to wait to verify if it works or not?

We have other revenue streams, so it is not live or die situation for our company, but I have to say, it hurts to see less money coming in every day.


r/startups • • 4d ago

I will not promote My startup is falling ( I will not promote)

41 Upvotes

Hi everyone I'm currently a solo founder building my own startup but for the last year I noticed something very disturbing that makes me very sad. Every month I get six meetings but only two people show up and they normally don't close and I never get a follow-up. I tried finding a co-founder, everyone says my ideas are great but out of the three people who expressed interest in my company never showed up to the second meeting they all didn't show up at all and stopped responding to my messages. The 4th person was nicer that didn't show up for the call and they apologized and said they would rebook but despite me emailing them several times they never did.

My uncle says I should go ahead and shut down my company but I really had hope for it but at the same time I realized that I'm pretty much doing everything alone and burning money I don't have. Pretty much all the money I have goes to rent, bills and support my family with the little money I have left from school....


r/startups • • 4d ago

I will not promote Lovable vs. Bolt for a beta MVP that engineers can take over later? ( i will not promote)

6 Upvotes

I’m a semi-technical founder looking to build a quick MVP, put it in front of a small group of beta users, and learn what’s worth building next.
My first instinct is to use Lovable or Bolt, keep the code in a GitHub repo I own, and use Supabase for auth and the database. If the beta gets traction, I’d bring in engineers to build on top of it.
For anyone who’s gone this route:
Which tool did you use, and would you pick it again?
How easy was it to edit and deploy the app directly from GitHub once you started making changes outside the builder?
If you handed it off to engineers, how much of the original code did they keep?
Anything you wish you’d set up differently before inviting beta users?
Open to other stacks too. I’m mainly looking for a fast way to get something into users’ hands while keeping the option to build on it later


r/startups • • 4d ago

I will not promote Judge a VC by the questions they ask [I will not promote]

0 Upvotes

I just spoke with a founder raising his seed round and they said:

Recently I feel like the diligence questions got weird. They are super specific, about stuff that doesn't really matter.
​

It feels like VCs just type in “poke holes in this project heres the deck” into their AI and then, it pokes holes and finds reasons to pass.

In my experience, you have to judge an investor by the questions they ask.

If their questions do not make sense for the type of business you run or the stage you’re at, walk away immediately.

These investors either:

  • don’t understand the business you’re in, so nothing you say will ever change their mind ​
  • are not serious about investing in you and they’re dragging the conversation for as long as possible to give you the illusion they’re doing “due diligence”

The right investor for you will:

  1. Ask questions specific to your market and your stage. You will feel their competence instantly. ​
  2. Call out the one or two things that could kill the business. They will test your blind spots. ​
  3. Move fast and give you clear next steps with a date.

Protect your time at all costs.


r/startups • • 5d ago

I will not promote I passed on an early DoorDash role. What might the equity have been worth? (I will not promote)

84 Upvotes

I found this email from Tony Xu, dated March 4, 2014. I’ve redacted my name:

“Hey [redacted],

It was good to meet you today. You've got a great head on your shoulders for sales.

I'm intro-ing you to Evan, one of my co-founders, on this thread. I want to potentially consider you in a hybrid role, including Ops, which Evan oversees. I'll let him set up time with you to connect and describe more the world of Ops at DoorDash.

Thanks,
Tony”

This wasn’t an offer, but it was a conversation about a hybrid sales and ops role. It would have been DoorDash’s first sales hire.

A little context on how early it was:
- DoorDash was mainly operating in Palo Alto, Mountain View, and San Jose.
- It raised a $17.3 million Series A in May 2014.
- In the early days, the founders handled orders and deliveries themselves, and the site listed menus from eight restaurants.

I didn’t take the role. The email doesn’t mention equity, and I don’t remember what might have been discussed. Curious what a first sales hire could have been offered at that stage and what it might have turned into after dilution.


r/startups • • 5d ago

I will not promote How do you evaluate a startup or app idea before building it? (i will not promote)

37 Upvotes

Hey everyone,

I’m a developer, and building isn’t usually the hard part for me. The hard part is knowing whether an idea is worth building at all. I’ve seen (and done) the classic mistake of spending weeks on an MVP and then finding out nobody really needed it. What I’m working on now isn’t another AI wrapper; it’s a practical product meant for everyday people.

So I’m not asking you to judge an idea. I’m asking how you judge one before writing any code.

A few things I’m curious about:

  • Your first step: what do you do when an idea comes up? Talk to people, look at competitors, check search trends, something else?
  • Talking to users: how do you get honest answers instead of polite “yeah, I’d use that” replies? Any questions you always ask, or ones you avoid?
  • Testing without building: have you used landing pages, WhatsApp/manual “concierge” versions, pre-orders, or anything else to test demand?
  • What counts as a real signal: what numbers or behaviour convinced you to keep going, or to drop it?
  • Competition: if others already do it, how do you decide whether there’s still room for you?
  • Mistakes: what did you learn the hard way about validating ideas?

Frameworks, books, personal stories, or a simple checklist you follow would all help. I think this could be useful for other devs who keep getting stuck in “build first, ask later” mode too.

Thanks!