I see several articles about AI bubble every day. Just recently Bloomberg had a essay on How
[“AI Is Testing What Economists Know About Bubbles”](https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2026-11-20/is-ai-a-bubble-what-economists-know-about-market-bubbles?accessToken=eyJhbGciOiJIUzI1NiIsInR5cCI6IkpXVCJ9.eyJzb3VyY2UiOiJTdWJzY3JpYmVyR2lmdGVkQXJ0aWNsZSIsImlhdCI6MTc5NTE5NjMzNywiZXhwIjoxNzk1ODAxMTM3LCJhcnRpY2xlSWQiOiJUT1NJNjBOM04wOVAwMCIsImJjb25uZWN0SWQiOiJEMzU0MUJFQjhBQUY0QkUwQkFBOUQzNkI3QjlCRjI4OCJ9.hkG6d23qzu8dyo-dPVFZsP7gapkTeCA9DKsn-vbtANQ&utm_source=reddit&utm_medium=social&utm_content=business&utm_campaign=giftlink&leadSource=article-gifting)
The author starts by saying “One of these days, the long, long upward run of US stock prices that began in 2009 will come to an end, not just with a temporary “rotation” or “drawdown” or “correction” but years of falling valuations and disappointed expectations.”
First of all, why do we presume that years of falling valuations and disappointing expectations have to exist? In 100s of years of market history even predating the stock market, zooming out there have rarely been periods of years of falling prices. Zooming out even events like 2008 and 1970s are corrections in what is a long term bull market. This idea is supported by the efficient market hypothesis which says that markets where flow of information is quick price in all negatives and positives of the underlying investment. This is especially true for stocks today where we have reached levels of transparency that was never seen in 1900 years of human history. In 1850 it would take a mail carried by a courier for you to get hold of a company’s earnings report. Now that’s available and priced in almost instantly.
Second, addressing the main argument of “AI bubble” the valuations in the market simply don’t support it. The PE multiples of the “bubble” stocks are not high enough to even call it a bubble. Even if we assume that earnings expectations are false and will not turn out to be accurate and look at trailing PE there’s still no bubble.
NVDA’s trailing PE that is actual report earning of TTM is 13.5. I do concede that AMD, AVGO, MRVL, etc trade at high multiples but I would argue that these stocks have actually earnings potential even without AI. AMD was already eating Intel’s lunch by offering better CPUs, Broadcom was already diversifying into recurring revenue and software(30% revenue from software) and Marvel was doing AISC’s before AI.
Not to mention that all of these companies sit on massive amounts of cash. Nvidia has 50bn in cash, MU has 40bn, even Anthropic has 100bn in cash. Talking about the hyperscalers ie those buying the hardware, MSFT, META, AMZN and GOOG are all seeing fastest pace of revenue growth in years. AMZN is growing cloud at 40%, GOOG at 90% and so on.. not to mention that the original business of these companies are still very sound. Even if we presume the worse case scenario that software has a demise and search is no longer used, their are still years before these businesses start contracting. And meantime they will generate enough cash for the hyperscalers to pivot. Google and Microsoft are already selling Gemini and Copilot to enterprises. Meta already has a successful app in the form of Muse.
The fundamental picture barring the neoclouds is actually very strong for the so called AI stocks.
Also, what exactly is the bear case?
- If data center build up does slow down or even stop, hyperscalers are bound to benefit as the supply of compute remains the same while the demand increases. These companies go back to being FCF positive and can do buybacks again. Even Anthropic which is already operating profitable, generates actual EPS as they get more pricing power. Sure the hardware stocks suffer but the overall market should be fine.
- If open source models become the norm, then hyperscalers win as they have the data centers and the hardware to run these open source models. And companies like NVDA win as they can sell more and more hardware to run open source models.
- If AI is truly the threat to traditional business and software as promised companies like Microsoft and Google should go down. But if that is indeed true Nvidia and Hardware stocks should go up!
Lastly, remember all I have written above doesn’t even take into account that AI is a revolutionary technology. OpenAI has solved one of the six millennium prize math problems and is on the verge of solving a second. As sad as it may sound to the mathematicians that dedicated their whole life to this stuff the fact is it’s a powerful technology. Anecdotally I don’t think anyone can claim that they don’t use AI in some form or another every day in their lives now. I was just talking to an accountant friend of mine who mentioned how much THEY are using copilot. I strongly disagree with people like Ed Zitron and others who think that AI is nothing more than a chatbot. This is a technology with real potential.
So what am I missing here? To me there doesn’t seem to be any fundamental justification for why this isn’t MORE than a correction. SPY is down 13% from its highs Nasdaq is doen 18% from its highs. SPY is now flat and Nasdaq negative on the year all while companies are delivering actual earnings and actual cash.
Even if we assume that somehow AI development stops right here, even at current capability there are so many places this tech can be used. Thomson Reuters is now using AI for its legal services businesses which is basically a digital library for lawyers, AI has sped up the lockup so much!
Sure the tech isn’t perfect, companies got way to greedy with data centers, they should never have asked for tax breaks from states, never have built these near residential areas and run them with Gas turbines. They are at fault here and should rectify.
But, that is the stuff of a correction not a years long bear market. The multiples aren’t high enough, euphoria not big enough and indiscipline not prevalent enough for there to be a major crash. Investors are NOT being indisciplined, they are infact being cautious. Remember, META, AMZN, GOOG, MSFT are flat or down on the year because the market is punishing them for going FCF negative compare that with dotcom era when markets rewarded such companies. AT&T, Walmart, Barnes and Noble, Toys r Us were rewarded for 100s of millions spending on internet. Today’s market punishes companies for investing in AI. It crashes Meta’s stock every time it announces capex, I don’t think we should even mention oracle which has HALVED for spending billions on AI.