r/Stormlight_Archive • u/j_stein89 • 54m ago
r/Stormlight_Archive • u/AdorableIncident5949 • 6h ago
Rhythm of War spoilers Wit, you absolute savage Spoiler
I went "oooooooooh" out loud while reading this sick burn
r/Stormlight_Archive • u/Razor_Amethyst2 • 1h ago
No Spoilers I just realized I've been giving Roshar the wrong background noises in my head
I was reading on my porch yesterday when a bird started making an absolutely ridiculous amount of noise in the tree above me.
And for some reason that made me realize I've been imagining birds chirping in the background of Stormlight scenes for years.
Not consciously. My brain just adds them whenever I picture people walking around outdoors.
Which got me thinking about how completely wrong my mental soundtrack for Roshar probably is.
When I imagine a quiet morning in Alethkar, there's always this vague background of wind in the trees, insects buzzing, birds calling, leaves rustling. Basically the same ambient sounds I'd hear walking through a park near my house.
Except Roshar isn't remotely like that.
Most of the landscape is bare stone. The plants behave nothing like ours. The wildlife is full of things with shells and claws. Even the rain hitting the ground would sound different without normal soil and grass absorbing it.
And now I'm sitting here trying to imagine what a completely ordinary morning on Roshar would actually sound like.
Little claws clicking against rock? Chulls making whatever noise chulls make? Wind whistling through cracks in stone? The occasional plant snapping shut when something gets too close?
Would a quiet stretch of countryside actually be quieter than ours, or would there be constant scraping and rattling from creatures moving around?
I also realized I've been imagining the Shattered Plains with basically the same ambient audio as a grassy field, which is an impressively stupid thing for my brain to do considering how much time Sanderson spends describing the place.
I can picture the architecture, clothing, creatures and landscapes pretty clearly. Apparently I've been doing absolutely zero work imagining what any of it sounds like.
Now I'm curious how other people experience this.
When you're reading Stormlight, do you have a specific soundscape for Roshar? Or does your brain just quietly import all the background noises from Earth like mine apparently does?
No plot spoilers please. I'm genuinely just interested in what people imagine hearing while reading.
r/Stormlight_Archive • u/Right_Environment365 • 15h ago
Wind and Truth spoilers Why the hate??? Spoiler
I finished WaT a few days ago, so I decided to watch some videos on SLA. While there were a lot of ranking videos, I found a lot of videos which basically said that Wind and Truth was lackluster and doesn't fit in with the other books due to change in writing style.
Honestly, I didn't think the change was that blatant, but even if it was, the story was not lackluster at all. WaT was a 10/10 book for me, best in SLA and best book I've ever read.
This post doesn't have any bad feelings toward the people who didn't like WaT as much. I just wanted to rant about this (because I've seen a bunch of people rant about stuff on reddit).
r/Stormlight_Archive • u/Ibrahimx96 • 7h ago
Rhythm of War spoilers Wondering about Taravangian's motives Spoiler
I read RoW a few years ago and maybe I missed this, but Taravangian's whole motive from the very beginning of the books was to save humanity from Odium.
But I'm wondering why has this not been achieved after he took the power of Odium? Why did the conflict with the rest of humanity keep going? Why didn't he use the power to save humanity from the Voidbringers? And what does he hope to achieve now?
r/Stormlight_Archive • u/Winter_Witchh • 18h ago
Oathbringer spoilers Elhokar Spoiler
I can’t believe I’m crying over Elhokar’s death!! I just read that chapter and I can’t stop crying damn it!
I never even liked the guy. He was so annoying and arrogant. Am I crying because I had to witness Kal seeing his mates die again?
I hate Moash!
r/Stormlight_Archive • u/cali_howler • 20h ago
Wind and Truth spoilers Rereading Stormlight: a timing question. Spoiler
Ok so I’m reareading Stormlight and I’m on WoR. I’m at the part of the book after the balcony attack on the king.
When did Moash get the time to bond a shard blade? He is the one that cut the balcony handrail right? To do so you need to be able to summon the shard blade. To do that you need to carry it around and bond with it. So, when did that happen?
Or, I forgot a detail and will be corrected once I keep rereading.
Thanks all!
r/Stormlight_Archive • u/Tefts_pain • 1d ago
The Way of Kings spoilers Dang Duo, didn't know you are a Stormlight fan. Spoiler
Fantastic Vorin adherence.
r/Stormlight_Archive
•
u/Kiruko_Kun
•
2d ago
The Way of Kings spoilers [OC] Shardbearer in Sharpie (by Me) Spoiler
Stuck at my desk at work with nothing but my notebook and a couple of pens so I started drawing a shardbearer summoning a blade because why not. The whole thing is done with a sharpie and one of those biro pens with multiple colours. Enjoy!
r/Stormlight_Archive • u/Hefty-Reward-2772 • 1d ago
Words of Radiance spoilers Finished Words of Radiance Spoiler
Wow that book was just incredible.
It is cool how Kaladin, Shallan, Dalinar and Renarin line up as Windrunner, Lightweaver, Bondsmith and Truthwatcher. I am curious what the last two can do.
Interesting how that Herald revived Szeth. Weird sense of values where he killed Ym for a murder decades ago and was going to kill Lift for thieving but somehow Szeth gets a pass for mass murder.
Adolin butchering Sadeas was brutal and satisfying. Sadeas's hubris really caught up with him. The detail about him whimpering right before his death was a nice touch. He got a small taste of what he has made thousands of bridgemen to go through.
r/Stormlight_Archive • u/Meep_o • 2d ago
Rhythm of War spoilers Lirin Spoiler
I'm 70% into Rythym of War and man Lirin is such a bitch. Can't stand him.
r/Stormlight_Archive • u/CurryInAHurry02 • 22h ago
early Rhythm of War spoilers Shallan Rhythm of War rant Spoiler
I just started Rhythm of War. 51 pages in, and the first line for Shallan is
> Veil was growing increasingly upset that nobody had kidnapped her.
CurryInAHurry was growing increasingly upset at this mf Shallan!! Kidnap ME so I don't have to read ts anymore!
The books so far have been like a gourmet meal, beautiful, tasteful stuff and for a quarter of it the chef decided to turn around and shit on it.
I liked Shallan in Way of Kings! She was my favorite! That all went out the window after she took Kaladin's boots and she's been a stuck up prick in my mind ever since. I'd NEVER want to be near a degrading wisecrack like her in my life, and I don't really want to read from her POV for like a quarter of this story.
She'd be a GREAT character if she wasn't one of the main POVs. I'd love her if she were like Renarin or Jasnah! Hell even an equal amountof time as Adolin would suffice.
All of this was made SO MUCH WORSE by the whole Veil/Radiant thing she has going on. It is so so so annoying. I thought that after her whole deal with Wit in Oathbringer she'd settle it down a bit, but upon reading that she's STILL got this weird, voluntary personality thing going on I let out an audible groan.
I had to put the book down. I sat down to read it again today, re-read that line, got half a page further and I was so annoyed I decided to rant about it on reddit.
Genuinely I don't know what anyone sees in her. She's a radiant ig? Why does Jasnah give af about her? Jasnah seems to be in a perpetual state of disappointment with Shallan. Maybe that's just Jasnah being perpetually disappointed by everyone. Why does Adolin wanna marry HER? Sorry Adolin but the girl you want to marry is only like a third of who she is. A third of her (Veil) doesn't even LIKE Adolin.
I could not ever imagine what a shitshow getting into an argument with Shallan would be like while married.
I could stomach this if it were involuntary, but she is actively and consciously perpetuating this delusion! "Hmm yes today I will continue to be delusional," - Shallan "I agree," -Radiant "Righty-O," - Veil
I've been annoyed at a lot of characters throughout this story, Kaladin got me shaking my head a lot during words of radiance, but at least I could see the light at the end of the tunnel. At least, during that whole moody teenager thing he had going on he had redeeming qualities, like his sense of duty and dedication towards his work. Yeah his racism thing against Lighteyes was annoying but at LEAST he listened to reason when Syl was like "Yeah but you KNOW Dalinar is good,".
I THOUGHT I saw the light at the end of the tunnel for Shallan but it seems she's dug her feet in more.
What's nice about Shallan? Hmm let's see well definitely not how she treats others, definitely not how she treats herself. Definitely not her academic capabilities (she can't academic her way into realizing that Veil and Radiant are coming from her mind and are thus just Shallan anyways). Ig light-weaving is pretty cool? Pattern is cool too, and they're kind of a package deal. My dad named his dog after Pattern. He's a cutie.
I do not think her trauma makes her a more likable character, if not for the fact that she has in no way dealt with or made meaningful progress towards healing.
When will it end? A lot of my frustration with Shallan was being disappointed that she's still got this thing going on. If I knew it would keep up I wouldn't be so frustrated right now. When can I expect Shallan to at LEAST stop seeing Veil as a separate entity? like how it was back in Words of Radiance.
r/Stormlight_Archive • u/Linorelai • 2d ago
Wind and Truth spoilers I now have a question about Honor and Odium Spoiler
Rhythm of Honor + Rhythm of Odium = Rhythm of War. Which makes sense to me.
So why Honor + Odium = Retribution and not War?
r/Stormlight_Archive • u/Sanchezzy123 • 2d ago
Oathbringer spoilers Reading Oathbringer and pages 649-673 are printed like this Spoiler
Text is cut off on those pages, thankfully I think I can still follow but am wondering if this is common with this edition ? During my read of the way of kings, I also noticed that a whole chapter was repeated in it.
r/Stormlight_Archive • u/Ok_Discipline_6922 • 2d ago
Wind and Truth spoilers Thoughts on the Dramatised Adaptation. Spoiler
I’ve read the entire series twice and listened to a lot of both versions of the audiobook, so I want to see what other fans think of it compared to the book and how it may possibly influence the show when it comes out.
r/Stormlight_Archive • u/CSEliot • 2d ago
Wind and Truth spoilers Why don't they just drop ... Spoiler
Boulders. There's more sky breakers, no? Or at least enough to where they could just infuse a ton o Boulders, take em up REALLY high, and them drop em like bombs. Onto the tower.
In book 5 there is all this "scary awakened tower scary" but like ..... physics???
Or idk, lashing a boulder from MILES away at a 1000x lashing, towards the tower.
Thank you.
r/Stormlight_Archive • u/Graphica-Danger • 3d ago
Mid Wind and Truth spoilers (Day 5 interludes) Taravangian is delightfully... Spoiler
PETTY! His interlude between days 5 and 6 where he chooses the destructive path against Dalinar and Jasnah is such an in-character moment that reveals what he truly is despite claiming he's doing all this for Roshar's benefit in the long run. His solidification into Odium wasn't driven by intellect but instead drawing on the powerful desire he has to not only believe he's right, but prove to those he claims to respect that he's better. He sees Dalinar as his kingly equal and Jasnah as his intellectual rival, but the catch is that he can only consider himself successful if he can determine he's "better" than them. Relationships are a transactional means of self-gratification for him, and it's the same motivation for his quest to now conquer the Cosmere. He's right somebody would try to eventually, but he believes it should happen regardless so long as it's him doing the conquering and nobody else. Pure narcissism.
r/Stormlight_Archive • u/Panthera_Panthera • 1d ago
Oathbringer spoilers Evi: A Short Character Assessment Spoiler
I just finished chapter 76. I'm a little pissed with Evi.
I think she is actually somewhat unintelligent though, not merely "unfamiliar with alethi customs". I cannot imagine any other Rosharan non-alethi woman making such choices. Not Fen, not Venli, and not even Shallan Davar. (With the exception of Lift of course, whose apparent recklessness is subsidized by her radiant awesomeness, who is also 10yo by the way.)
After Evi's first advice (partly) leads to Dalinar getting his squad wiped out and he himself NEARLY killed. She should've returned to her tent and waited it out. Not tried to PLAY war.
Thinking about what could've possibly happened if Dalinar hadn't ordered the messengers shot, there's only two real possibilities:
- Tanalan takes her hostage and negotiates from a position of power. Thus showing other highprinces, that oh the way to get what you want is kidnap royal family members. This would have the downstream effect of causing other rebellions where even more lives are lost as a result of her actions.
- Gavilar comes down himself, refuses to negotiate with terrorists (Tanalan), promises Dalinar a new wife and sends him on a long vacation. (Foolhardy Dalinar would've probably led an elite stealth squad into the city to steal his wife back and of course meet his end in that attempt.) While Gavilar puts the highprince's family and probably every fighting man in the city to the sword for even daring such a measure. To make an example.
Heck, I wanted Dalinar to use shardblade to cut Tanalan's arms and take him back to court and make him the new King's Wit.
Tanalan had twice spat on the kindness of warmonger Dalinar "Genghis" Kholin. It did not make any sense to cast her lot in with him.
She's good-natured and kind yes, but clearly unable to think about the second-order consequences of her actions.
r/Stormlight_Archive • u/CurrentWeather6 • 3d ago
Wind and Truth spoilers Taravangian Spoiler
The hell is Taravangian on about? What painful lesson? His next words barely made sense as an answer to Dalinar. It’s so tedious to read Taravangian’s dialogues!
r/Stormlight_Archive • u/pollitoshh • 4d ago
No Spoilers My new tat
Dont have big arms but it still looks cool af
r/Stormlight_Archive • u/Linorelai • 2d ago
Wind and Truth spoilers Ok, i finished wind and truth, and Spoiler
It's so unsatiafying🥲 i'm ruined on so many levels, not a single plot line... Ok, one. One plotline that gave me satisfaction—freeing Mishram. Adolin is crippled. Shallan is trapped. Gavinor is completely fucked in the soul. Navani is widowed. Dalinar is dead and ready to serve Taravangian. Jasnah is crushed. Honor is no more, and im the huge fan of consept of Honor. Kaladin is at least promising, but i didn't get to see much of him after the level up. 3 (or 2? Did Shallan even?) knights spoke the 5th ideal and i did not get to see any of the powers. Nada.
I understand that it's only half of the story, but it was so unsatiafying. Could we have some more positivity please? Im pissed