A Few Thoughts After Taking AI Music Seriously
Disclaimer: This text was originally written by me in Spanish, then translated and polished with the help of an LLM to make the English version clearer and more fluid.
---------
(Edit: for the people that think this story is fake (I dont know why because the post is nothing special just random silly thoughts), the contest I talk about is AILOVEJAZZ, you can search it by yourself)
-------
I just wanted to share a little experience I had over the past few days that left me with some interesting impressions about AI-generated music.
Recently, I took part in an AI music competition, so I decided to approach music generation with a bit more seriousness than usual. Rather than the typical aimless SUNO sessions where you generate random stuff just to see what happens, and spend some time going through a cycle of surprises, laughs, and boredom, this time I had a much more specific and constrained goal: make a song that was genuinely worth listening to.
To keep this from becoming too long, I'll try to distill some of the main things I learned along the way.
1. Generating is easy. Actually creating something is a different story.
Generating music is easy. Getting the fine details under control, pushing an idea to its full potential, and making everything move in the direction you actually envision? That's a completely different story.
In many ways, the process ends up looking surprisingly similar to pre-AI music production: extracting takes, editing, recording, creating demos, uploading new versions, and going through endless iterations.
This is why I find the criticism that AI music users aren't really musicians because "all they do is write a prompt" rather misleading. At least in my experience, getting something truly worthwhile out of these tools requires a lot of hands-on work, even if you're working entirely within the AI tool itself.
For this particular song, I ended up generating more than 500 variations. And even after all that, I never quite managed to get everything to fit together the way I had imagined it.
So no, it's definitely not just "write a prompt and you're done."
Interestingly, though, I found that this friction, this struggle, actually makes the creative experience more rewarding. As you work through the process, you gradually feel that what you're creating is yours. The effort, the frustration, and the time invested give you a stronger sense of ownership.
Regardless of where you stand on the AI debate, I think there's something fundamentally human about this: we're naturally more attached to things we've struggled to create. The satisfaction of finally getting something right is much greater when you've had to fight for it.
2. A great song is a great song, regardless of how it was made.
After submitting my song to the competition (which I eventually had to do because the deadline arrived before I could get it to sound exactly the way I wanted), I started listening to other participants' entries.
This turned out to be the most interesting part of the whole experience.
There was a lot of what I would personally call "slop." But buried among all that were a few songs that genuinely blew me away. Songs I really loved, regardless of whether they were made with AI or not.
And that's when something became very clear to me, almost on a gut level: I simply didn't care how those songs were made. I just cared that they were great.
The distinction between AI-generated and traditionally produced music suddenly felt completely irrelevant.
Slop existed before AI, and it still exists today. Great music existed before AI, and it still exists today. The only thing that had changed was the tool.
Actually discovering some genuinely amazing songs among the entries made this much more than just an intellectual argument for me. It was something I experienced firsthand.
At the end of the day, what matters is whether you manage to create something that stands out.
3. The uncomfortable discovery: Maybe your "unique" banger isn't so unique after all.
And now for the slightly horrifying part.
I didn't listen to every single entry because there were over 1,000 submissions, and eventually I just got tired. But among the ones I did listen to, I noticed something unsettling: a few songs sounded surprisingly similar to mine.
Not identical, of course, but similar in certain arrangements, melodic touches, and overall musical feel.
This genuinely freaked me out.
I had been thinking of my song as something completely original, something I had managed to discover and develop through my own creative process. But then it hit me: we're all using the same tool. And when you start combining similar style tags, genres, descriptions, and other prompts, you may end up navigating toward very similar musical territory.
Different generations, different details, but sometimes essentially variations of the same underlying idea.
The scary thing is that you might spend hours discovering what feels like a little musical gold nugget, a truly unique banger, only to find out that someone else has stumbled upon a very similar nugget using the exact same tool.
Of course, this kind of thing also happened before AI. Certain melodies, chord progressions, and musical ideas are universal, and different musicians can independently arrive at very similar results. But I think AI makes this risk much more immediate and much more common.
It left me with an interesting image: perhaps we're all sitting inside our own little SUNO bubbles, happily listening to our latest bangers, convinced we've discovered something unique, without realizing that thousands of other users might be getting something remarkably similar on their side of the fence.
So, something to keep in mind.
I think this is particularly relevant when using SUNO to generate original melodies from scratch, rather than using it as a tool to arrange or reinterpret melodies you've written yourself (for example, through its Cover feature).
I'm probably more forgiving of similarities in arrangements, instrumentation, or production styles, since those are naturally more connected to genre conventions and shared musical language. But when it comes to the actual melodies, I think we should be much more careful.